Skip to content

Board of Trustee of Port of Bombay v. Indian Goods S

Board of Trustee of Port of Bombay v. Indian Goods S

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1977 (3) SC 213

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 1622 : 1977 (2) SCC 649 : 1977 (3) SCR 343 : 1977 UJ 302

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
P.S. Kailasam, J.*; M. Hameedullah Beg, CJI; A.C. Gupta, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 1353 of 1975
For petitioner / appellant
(Appeal by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dated 1-11-1974 of the Bombay High Court in Appeal No. 493 of 1966 from original Decree.) F.S. Nariman, B.R. Zaiawala, B.S. Bisaria, J.B. Dadac- hanji, O.C. Mathut, K.J. John and Shri Narain, for the appellants.
For respondent
P.H. Parekh and Miss Manju Jetely, for the respondent.
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 5

  1. Trustees the Port of Madras v. M/s. Referred (Para 1)
  2. Aktieselskabet Reidar v. Arcos Referred (Para 1)
  3. Budgett & Co. v. Binnington & Co. Referred (Para 1)
  4. Compania Crystal De Vapores of Panama v. Herman Referred (Para 1)
  5. Lord Esher in Budgert Co. v. Bin- Referred (Para 1)

Referred in 1

  1. Board of Trustees of Port of Bombay v. Jai Hind Oil LOK 1987 (1) SC 92 Referred (Para 1)

Judgment

KAILASAM, J.

This appeal by special leave is preferred

by the Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay against the

judgment of the Bench of the Bombay High Court in first

appeal confirming the decree passed by the City Civil Court

and dismissing the appeal with costs. The respondents,

Indian Goods Supplying Co., a partnership firm in Bombay,

filed suit No. 3304 of 1959 in the Bombay City Civil Court

at Bombay praying for a decree against the Trustees of the

Port of Bombay in the sum of Rs. 24,950 with interest.

Three consignments of Chinese newsprint were imported by

the respondents for home consumption in India. The first 2

consignments arrived on February 16, 1957. Suffice it to

say that the clearance of the two consignments as well as

the third consignment

was considerably delayed and the Port Trust claimed demur-

rage for the period from March 25, 1957. The respondents

disputed the right of the Port Trust to charge any demurrage

for the period during which the goods were detained by the

Customs authorities for analytical test. as well as for the

Import Trade Control formalities. It is common ground that

so far as the period for analytical test certified by the

Customs authorities is concerned the Port Trust cannot

charge demurrage. But so far as the period during which the

goods were detained for the Import Trade Control formalities

by the Customs authorities the Port Trust claimed demurrage.

Due to protracted correspondence between the parties the

goods were not cleared and ultimately the suit was filed by

the respondents for recovery of a sum of Rs. 24,950 and

interest thereon from the Port Trust being the aggregate

loss sustained by them. The appellants denied that liabili-

ty and pleaded that the Port Trust. was in law entitled to'

collect the demurrage levied on the respondents and that as

they failed to pay the demurrage the Port Trust was entitled

to sell the goods by public auction.

The City Civil Court, Bombay, decreed the suit for a

sum of Rs. 24,950 with interest at the rate of 6 per cent

per annum from the date of the suit till judgment and there-

after at 4 per cent per annum and costs of the suit.

The appellants preferred an appeal to a Division Bench

of the Bombay High Court which dismissed the appeal and

confirmed the decree passed by the City Civil Court.

When the appeal was pending before the High Court the

appellants deposited the decretal amount in court which was

withdrawn by the respondents. Mr. Nariman, counsel for the

Port Trust, stated that the Port Trust does not want to ask

for the repayment of the money and that he will confine

himself to the question of the correctness of the decision

of the Bombay High Court holding that the Port Trust is not

entitled to collect demurrage in the circumstances of this

case. It is therefore sufficient for the purposes of the

appeal to confine ourselves to determining the question of

law which has been raised before the High Court and decided

by it.

The question that was raised before the High Court was

whether the claim of demurrage by the Port Trust for the

period during which the goods were detained with the Port

Trust in respect of Import Trade Control formalities is

maintainable. The High Court held that the importer of the

goods cannot be held responsible for any delay not at-

tributed to his own default and that the importer whose

goods are detained by the Customs Department is entitled to

claim the clearance of goods without demurrage during the

period for which the Customs Department has detained them.

The appellants, the Board of Trustees of the Port of

Bombay, is a statutory body constituted by the Bombay Port

Trust Act, Act 6 of 1879, and is a body corporate. Chapter

VI of the Act relates to Revenue and Expenditure and pro-

vides for levy of rates. Section

43 empowers the Board to frame a scale of tolls, dues,

rents, rates and charges to be levied for each or any of the

matters enumerated in clauses (a) to (d). Sub-section (a)

enables framing of scale of rates relating to the landing,

shipping, wharfage, cranage, storage or demurrage of goods.

We are concerned with the framing of the scale of rates for

demurrage of goods. Section 43B(1) requires that every

scale framed by the Board shah be submitted to the Central-

Government for sanction and, when so sanctioned and pub-

lished in the Bombay Government Gazette, shall have the

force of law; and subject to the like sanction and publica-

tion, may from time to time be amended or added to by the

Board. It is admitted that the Board framed a scale of

rights for demurrage of goods and the scale so framed by the

Board was submitted to the Central Government and was sanc-

tioned by the Central Government and published by the

Bombay Government in the Gazette as required. The result is

that under section 43B(1 ) the scales so framed by the Board

and approved by the Central Government shall have the force

of law.

The learned counsel for the appellants as the Port Trust

in this appeal have given up its claims to refund of the

money taken by the respondents. In view of this the counsel

for the respondents confined his arguments to supporting the

view taken by the High Court regarding the question of law.

He submitted that the Central Government had taken action

under section 43B (IA) and had called upon the Board to

modify the operation of such scales and therefore the Board

was bound to modify the scales accordingly. This conten-

tion is based on a D.O. letter dated 7th September, 1952

addressed by the Government of India to the Port Trust which

is typed at page 350 of the Supplement Paper Book No. 2.

In the D.O. letter the Government expressed its view that it

seems unreasonable to charge an importer any demurrage once

it is accepted that clearance was delayed on account of

the reasons beyond his control. The letter concluded by

expressing an earnest hope that the Bombay Port Trust will

reconsider their decision and fall in line with the practice

of the Calcutta and Madras Ports. It concluded by stating

"We shall be grateful if you will kindly place the matter

before the Trustees for their favourable consideration and

intimate to us the result." The Board considered this

letter and after taking into consideration the several

circumstances, suggested that demurrage may be levied on a

graded scale. The Government of India was informed of the

Resolution of the Board and no further action was taken by

the Government. The D.O. letter addressed by the Government

of India cannot be considered as a direction by the Central

Government calling upon the Board to modify any portion of

the scale framed by the Port Trust. The language of the D.O.

would indicate that the Government wanted the Port Trust to

consider the Government's proposal and nothing further.

The Port Trust considered the proposal and made its report.

We are unable to accept the plea of the learned counsel for

the respondents that the D.O. letter should be construed as

a direction calling upon the Board to modify the portion of

the scale framed by the Board. Section 43B(1A) has there-

fore no application to this case.

Chapter VII of the Port Trust Act enumerates the powers and

functions of the Board. It is the duty of the Board to

recover the rates to have a lien on the goods and

seize and detain the goods until such rates are

fully paid. The Board is empowered to sell the

goods if rates are not paid or lien for freight is not

discharged. It can also dispose of goods not removed from

the premises of the Board within the time limited. Section

65 also provides the mode of application of proceeds of the

sale. Under section 66 the Board is entitled to distrain for

non-payment rates. The Port clearance shall not be granted

till the rates are paid. It is thus a statutory duty of the

Board to collect the rates prescribed.

The contention put forward on behalf of the respondents

is that they are in no way responsible for the delay in

clearing the goods as the goods had been detained under the

Import Trade Control Regulations. It is no doubt true that

before clearance is given by the Import Trade Control

authorities and the Customs Department the goods cannot

be cleared by the respondents. Neither can the Port Trust

deliver the goods without the consent of the Import Trade

Control authorities. Taking into account the hardship

caused to the importer because of the delay certain conces-

sions in demurrage rates are permitted. The Port Trust has

prescribed the reduced demurrage levy which is 1/6th of the

normal rate from the date of expiry of the free days upto

the 60th day, 1/3rd of the normal rate after the expiry of

the 60th day, upto the 90th day, half the normal rate after

the expiry of the 90th day upto the 120th day, 2/3rd of the

normal rate after the expiry of the 120th day upto the 150th

day and at the full rate after the expiry of the 150th day.

As the scale of rates are framed by virtue of the statutory

powers conferred on the Board under section 43 and as the

rates have been approved by the Central Government under

section 43B the rates have the force of law and cannot be

questioned. Taking into account the hardship to the import-

ers certain concession has been given but the legality of

the rates which are being levied according to law cannot be

questioned. This view was taken by this Court in a recent

decision reported in Trustees the Port of Madras v. M/s.

Aminchand Pyarelal & Ors. (1) Where it had t6 consider the

validity of the scale of rates fixed by the Madras Port

Trust. In a suit by the Port Trust against the importer

and the Union of India and the Customs authorities to recov-

er the balance of demurrage amounting to about rupees three

lakhs the question arose whether the scale of charges in

the Port Trust Regulations under the heading "Demurrage"

was void and ultra vires for the reason that it was unrea-

sonable and not within the authority of the Port Trust. The

relevant provisions of the Bombay Port Trust Act with which

we are concerned are in pari materia with the provisions of

the Madras Act which fell for consideration by the Supreme

Court.The Supreme Court held that the scale of

rates and statement of conditions flamed by the

Madras Port Trust under sections 42, 43 and 43A

are not by-laws

(1) [1976] 1 S.C.R. 721.]

and the sections confer authority on the Board to frame a

scale of rates at which and a statement or conditions under

which any of the services specified therein shall be per-

formed. It observed "The Board's power to frame a scale of

rates and statement of conditions is not a regulatory power

to order that something must be done or something may not

be done. The rates and conditions govern the basis on which

the Board performs the services mentioned in sections 42, 43

and 43-A. Those who desire to avail of the services of the

Board are liable to pay for those services at prescribed

rates and to perform the conditions framed in that behalf by

the Board." The Court rejected the view of the High Court

that demurrage being a charge for wilful failure to remove

the goods within the free period can' be levied only if the

failure to remove the-goods is due to the fault or negli-

gence of the importer or his agent. It also did not agree

with the view taken by the High Court that the authority

given to the Board to frame the scale of rates can be exer-

cised only for the purpose of levying charges where the

importer was not prevented by any lawful authority from

clearing the goods from the transit area and he had default-

ed or was negligent in clearing the goods. Justice Chandra-

chud, who spoke for the Court, observed in his judgment at supra that the statute had not placed any limita-

tion on the power of the Board to fix rates and as the Board

had the power to frame a scale of rates at which and the

statement of conditions under which any of the services

specified in the section shall be performed and as the Board

has fixed the scale of rates it was difficult to see in what

manner or respect the Board has exceeded its power under

section 42. The Court proceeded to observe in rejecting

the view of the High Court that the Board cannot fix rates

of demurrage when the failure to remove was not due to some

fault or negligence of the importer, that there is no such

fetter on the Board's powers to fix the rates. This deci-

sion of the Supreme Court is on all fours with the facts of

the present case and concludes the question.

Mr. Nariman, counsel for the appellants cited three deci-

sions of the English Courts in support of his contention

that even on the basis of a contract the right of the Port

Trust to recover demurrage cannot be denied unless the

person claiming the demurrage is responsible for the

delay. In Aktieselskabet Reidar v. Arcos, Limited (1), Lord

Justice Atkin in answering the question whether if the

chatterer has failed to complete the loading of the ship

within the lay days, and the ship during the demurrage days

becomes, without the default of the shipowner, unable to

carry as much cargo as she would have carried if loaded

within the lay days, but receives from the charterer a full

cargo for her diminished capacity, the loss falls upon the

charterer in addition to the demurrage, expressed his opin-

ion that the decision should be for the shipowner. It was

held that "The result of the authorities appears to be that

in a contract fixing a number of lay days and providing for

days at demurrage thereafter, the charterer enters into a

binding obligation to load a complete cargo within the lay

days subject to any default by the shipowner or to the

operation

(1) [1927] 1 K.B. 352.

of any exceptions, matters which do not arise in this

case ….If however, for reasons other than the shipown-

er's default, the chatterer becomes unable to do that

which he contracted to do-namely, put a full and complete

cargo on board during the fixed laydays, the breach is never

repaired, the damages are not completely mitigated, and the

shipowner may recover the loss that he has incurred in

addition to his liquidated demurrage or his unliquidated

damages for detention." Thus it appears clear that claim of

demurrage cannot be resisted unless where the detention was

due to the shipowner's default. In the present case the

Port Trust's claim for demurrage cannot be denied unless it

is proved that the delay was due to the Port Trust itself.

In Budgett & Co. v. Binnington & Co., (1) a clause in

the charterparty fixed the number of lay-days for unloading

and allowed other days for demurrage. During the lay-days a

strike took place both among the labourers employed on

behalf of the ship and those employed by the consignees,

with the result that the unloading ceased, and could not be

resumed till some days after the expiration of the lay-days.

The Court of Appeal held that as the number of lay-days was

fixed the consignees were liable to pay demurrage, notwith-

standing the inability of the shipowners, owing to the

strike, to do their part in the unloading. The test that

was laid down by Lord Esher Master of the Rolls, was. Has

the shipowner failed in his duty through any default of

his own or of persons for whom he is responsible ? As the

non-delivery was occasioned by something which the shipowner

could not foresee or by the act of persons over whom he had

any control it was held that he was not liable.

In Compania Crystal De Vapores of Panama v. Herman &

Mohatta (India) Ltd., (2) Justice Devlin quoted with approv-

al the law laid down by Lord Esher in Budgert Co. v. Bin-

nington & Co. (supra) which is in the following terms :–

"If the shipowner by any act of his has

prevented the discharge, then, `though the

freighter's contract is broken, he is ex-

cused', he was referring to a case in which

the shinowner's act preventing the discharge

was in breach of his obligation to give the

charterer all facilities for the discharge.

But here the act of the shipowner which de-

layed the discharge was not a breach of any

obligation of his."

The position therefore is that even though the delay in

clearing the goods was not due to the negligence of the

importer for which he could be held responsible yet he

cannot avoid the payment of demurrage as the rates imposed

are under the authority of law the validity of which

cannot be questioned. The claim cannot be resisted as there

is no evidence that the delay was due to any act of the Port

Trust or persons for whom the Port Trust is responsible.

(1) [1891] 1 Q.B.p. 35.

(2) [2953] 2 ALl. E.R. 508.

One other contention which was raised before the High

Court but was not dealt with by it may be referred to. It

was submitted on behalf of the respondents that the defini-

tion of the words "free days" would not include the period

of holidays or part of a holiday or Sunday in computing the

number of free days during which the Customs Duty may not be

assessed or received and therefore the period of detention

of the goods during the operation of Import Trade Control

formalities must be considered as free days. In the scale

of rates charged at the docks framed by the Bombay Port

Trust under sections 43. 43A and 43B of the Bombay Port

Trust Act, 1879, in Section III reference is made to free

days. Under the heading "Free Days" it is provided that

all goods will be allowed storage in Docks free of rent for

5 days. It-is further provided that in computing the number

of free days Sundays and holidays referred to in by-law 118

as well as any other days on which Customs Duty may not be

assessed or received, will be omitted in the case of all

goods liable to duty under section 20 of the Sea Customs

Act. The submission was that not only Sunday and holidays

should be omitted but also other days on which Customs

Duty may not be assessed or received will have to be

omitted and this should be understood as days during which

the Import Trade Control formalities could not be completed.

This contention cannot be accepted as these Rules are in-

tended only to omit Sundays, other holidays and days on

which the assessment of Customs Duty cannot be taken up and

would not include the entire period during which the Import

Trade Control formalities have not been completed.

The High Court was therefore in error in holding

that the importer of the goods cannot be held responsible

for any delay not attributable to his own default and that

demurrage under section 43A could never be imposed as long

as the goods were detained for the purpose of the operation

of the Import Trade Control Regulations. In the result the

appeal is allowed but due to the concession made by the

learned counsel for the Port Trust there will be no order

directing the refund of the money that had already been

deposited by the Port Trust and withdrawn by the respond-

ents. The appellant also does not press his counter claim.

There will be no order as to costs in this appeal.

S.R. Appeal allowed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/board-of-trustee-of-port-of-bombay-v-indian-goods-s/