Skip to content

Commissioner of Income Tax, Kanpur v. M/s. J.K. Commercial Corporation Ltd. Etc.

Commissioner of Income Tax, Kanpur v. M/s. J.K. Commercial Corporation Ltd. Etc.

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (9) SC 31

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 459 : 1976 (105) ITR 219 : 1976 (4) SCC 517 : 1977 (1) SCR 512 : 1976 UJ 798

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
N.L. Untwalia, J.*; Hans Raj Khanna, J.; Jaswant Singh, J.
Case No.
CA No. 1580, 1581, 1582 and 1583 of 1971
For petitioner / appellant
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION.: Civil Appeal Nos. 15801583/71. From the Judgment and Order dated 11-3-69 of the Allaha- bad High Court in Civil Mic. Writ Nos. 3251, 3252, 3253 and 3254/ 68. S.C. Manchanda, J. Ramamurthy and S.P. Nayar, for the Appellants.
For respondent
S.V. Gupte and Rameshwar Nath, for the Respondent. in C.A. 1580/71. Rameshwar Nath, for the Respondents.
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 5

  1. Circle "B", Ahmedabad v. Navanagar Transport Referred (Para 1)
  2. J. K. Commercial Corporation Ltd. v. Income-tax Referred (Para 1)
  3. Council in Commissioner Income-tax v. Khemchand Referred (Para 1)
  4. C.A. Abraham v. Income-tax Offi- Referred (Para 1)
  5. Harlalka v. Commissioner of Income-tax(") Referred (Para 1)

Judgment

UNTWALIA, J.

These four appeals by certificate are from

a common judgment of the Allahabad High Court allowing four

writ petitions filed by the two respondent companies namely

J.K. Commercial Corporation Ltd. and J.K. Synthetics Ltd.

In respect of the assessment years 1955-56 and 1956-57

assessment orders were passed by the Income-tax Officer,

Kanpur under section 23(3) of the Income Tax Act,

1922–hereinafter referred to as the Act. Subsequent to the

passing of the said orders of assessment the Income-tax

Officer passed four orders in respect of the two assessment

years against the two companies under section 23A of the Act

on January 21, 1957 asking the companies to pay certain

amounts of additional super-tax on the undistributed profit

of the concerned years. In

November, 1959 the Income-tax Officer issued a notice under

section 35(1) of the Act for rectification of the mistake

committed in the previous orders passed under section 23A

on 21.1.1957. the assessee companies in response to the

notices objected to the proposed rectification by the In-

come-tax Officer, inter alia, on the ground that he had no

power to rectify any mistake in an order under section 23A

of the Act. The Income-tax Officer over-ruled the objection

raised by the companies, rectified the mistakes in his

previous orders and increased the amounts of additional

super-tax payable by the companies in relation to the two

assessment years. The companies revision applications filed

before the Commissioner of Income Tax, U.P. were dismissed.

Thereupon, four writ applications were filed in the High

Court to challenge the orders passed by the Income-tax

Officer under section 35(1) of the Act as affirmed by the

Commissioner of Income Tax in revisions. A Bench of the

High Court feeling compelled to follow the decisions of this

Court in M.M. Parikh, IncomeTax Officer, Special Investiga-

tion Circle "B", Ahmedabad v. Navanagar Transport and

Industries Ltd. and another(1) and in S. Sankappa and others

v. Income-tax Officer, Central Circle 11, Bangalore(2) has

allowed the writ applications and quashed the impugned

orders passed by the Commissioner of Income-tax and the

Incometax-Officer. The decision of the High Court is re-

ported in J. K. Commercial Corporation Ltd. v. Income-tax

Officer, District 1, (i), Kanpur and another(3). Hence

these appeals by the Revenue.

In our judgment the High Court was not right in applying

the ratio of the two decisions of this Court referred to

above to the facts of these cases. We shall presently show

that the Income-tax Officer had jurisdiction and competency

to rectify the mistakes under section 35 (1) of the Act in

his previous orders passed under section 23A.

Chapter IV of the Act is entitled "Deductions and As-

sessment". In this chapter occurs various sections relating

to assessments of income, determination of tax or super-

tax, tax payable on it, payment of additional super-tax,

computation of loss, provisions for appeal and revision and

provisions for rectification of mistakes either by the

Income-tax Officer or by the Appellate or the Revisional

authorities. In one of the earliest decisions of the Privy

Council in Commissioner Income-tax v. Khemchand Ramdas(4) at it was said:

"One of the peculiarities of most Income-tax Acts is

that the word 'assessment' is used as meaning sometimes the

computation of income, sometimes the determination of the

amount of tax payable and sometimes the whole procedure laid

down in the Act for imposing liability upon the taxpayer.

The Indian Income-tax Act is no exception in this

respect ………. "

(1) [1967] 63 I.T.R. 663. (2) [1968] 68 I.T.R. 760.

(3) [1969] 73 I.T.R. 464. (4) [1938] 6 I.T.R. 414.

The above dictum of the Privy Council was quoted with ap-

proval by this Court in C.A. Abraham v. Income-tax Offi-

cer, Kottayam and another(1). In Sankappa's case (supra)

the same Bench which had decided the Parikh's case and

delivered-the judgment through Shah, J. as he then was,

speaking through Bhargava, J. followed Abraham's case

(supra) and the decision of this Court in Kalawati Devi

Harlalka v. Commissioner of Income-tax(") wherein it has

been stated that the word "assessment" is capable of bearing

a very comprehensive meaning; in the context it can compre-

hend the whole procedure for ascertaining and imposing

liability on the tax payer. It is to be noticed that the

marginal note of section 23 is "Assessment" and sub-section

(3) says "the Income-tax Officer …….. shall, by an

order in writing, assess the total income of the assessee"'

and then adds "determine the sum payable by him on the

basis of such assessment." Literally speaking, therefore,

the assessment is of the total income of the assessee and

then in the same order the sam payable by the assessee is

determined which would include income-tax, surcharge,

super-tax etc. Under section 24 of the Act, loss is comput-

ed and is allowed to be set off against the income of the

same year or carried forward to the next year. If one were

to go upon the use of the literal words, then section 24 is

for computation of the loss. Yet it is a step in the as-

sessment proceeding and will form part of the order of

assessment itself. Section 23A as the marginal note indi-

cates is the "Power to assess Companies to super-tax on

undistributed income in certain cases". The relevant words

of sub-section (1) of section 23A are the following: "Where

the Income-tax Officer is satisfied …….. the Income-

tax Officer shall unless he is satisfied. make an order in

writing that the company shall, apart from the sum deter-

mined as payable by it on the basis of the assessment under

section 23, be liable to pay super-tax" at the rates speci-

fied "on the undistributed balance of the total income of

the previous year …… " It would thus be seen that

although in a narrow sense an order under section 23A may

not be called an order of assessment, surely it is a part of

the assessment proceeding and may be called a supplementary

assessment order directing a company to pay additional

amount of super-tax on the undistributed balance of the

total income as assessed and determined in accordance with

the provisions of section 23.

We shall now read section 35(1):

"The Commissioner or Appellate Assistant

Commissioner may, at any time within four years

from the date of any order passed by him in appeal

or, in the case of the Commissioner, in revision

under section 33A and the Incometax Officer may, at

any time within four years from the date of any

assessment order or refund order passed by him on

his own motion rectify any mistake apparent from

the record of the appeal, revision, assessment or

refund as the case may be, and shall within the

like period rectify any such mistake which has been

brought to his notice by an assessee:

(1) [1961] 41 I.T.R. 425. at 429.

(2) (1967) 66 I.T.R. 680.

Provided that no such rectification shall be

made, having the effect of enhancing an assessment

or reducing a refund unless the Commissioner, the

Appellate Assistant Commissioner or the Income-tax

Officer, as the case may be, has given notice to

the assessee of his intention so to do and has

allowed him a reasonable opportunity of being heard

:"

The Commissioner or the Appellate Assistant Commissioner can

rectify any mistake apparent from the record of the appeal

or revision. In the like manner, as provided in sub-section

(2), the Appellate Tribunal has been given the power of

rectification of mistakes apparent from the record of the

appeal. The marginal note of section 30 is "Appeal against

assessment under this Act". Various types of orders passed

under the various sections in Chapter IV of the Act have

been enumerated as being appealable orders. The list in-

cludes an order by which the amount of loss may be computed

under section 24 or the amount of tax has been determined

under section 23 and an order made by the Income-tax Officer

under sub-section (1) of section 23A. It is, therefore,

plain that the Commissioner in revision, the Appellate

Assistant Commissioner and the Tribunal in appeal can recti-

fy a mistake in the record of the revision or the appeal, as

the case may be, taken from the order of assessment under

section 23, the order computing loss under section 24, or

an order made under section 23A by the Income-tax Officer.

Viewed in that light it follows as a matter of construction

that the Income-tax Officer can rectify any mistake apparent

from the record of assessment which expression is wide

enough not only to cover an order of assessment made under

section 23 but also an order computing loss under section 24

and an order made under section 23A directing the assessee

company to pay additional super-tax. It is neither advisa-

ble nor necessary in these appeals to give a complete list

of the types of orders, apparent mistakes in which can be

rectified by the Income-tax Officer under section 35(1) of

the Act. Obviously the first proviso to sub-section (1)

of section 35 and sub-section (3) lends support to the view

that rectification of apparent mistakes in an order comput-

ing loss or an order under section 23A is permissible and

may have the effect of enhancing the assessment or reducing

it. The provisions of sub-section (7) of section 35 of the

Act also give an indication that the opinion which we have

recorded above as to the power of the Incometax Officer to

rectify a mistake in an order made under section 23A is

correct. By a deeming provision sub-section (5) gives

powers to the Income-tax Officer to make consequential

correction in the assessment of a partner of firm on the

modification of the assessment of the income of the firm.

Similarly by a deeming provision engrafted in sub-section

(7) on the modification of an order under section 23A in

relation to the assessment of a company in appeal or revi-

sion, power has been given to the Income-tax Officer to make

rectification in the computation of the total income of the

shareholders as if it is a mistake apparent from the record

within the meaning of section 35 making the provisions of

sub-section, (1) applicable to such a case.

Some difficulty is presented, as we shall presently

show, in view of Parikh's ease (supra) from the provision of

time limit of 4 years provided in section 35(1) for the

exercise of the power by the incometax Officer for the

rectification of the mistakes apparent from the record of

assessment; the starting point of the period being "date of

any assessment order". In Parikh's case this Court was con-

cerned with the interpretation of the expression "order of

assessment", occurring in sub-section (3) of section 34 of

the Act. In that connection, Shah, J as he then was, deliv-

ering the judgment on behalf of a Division Bench of this

Court said at page 670 of 63 I.T.R.:

"In each of these cases there is computation of

income, determination of tax payable and procedure

is prescribed for imposing liability upon the

taxpayer. But still these are not orders of as-

sessment within the meaning of section 23. The

salient feature of these and other orders is that

the liability to pay tax arises not from the charge

created by statute but from the order of the

Income-tax Officer."

On the above principle an order under section 23A was held

to be outside the purview of limitation provided in section

34 of the Act as in the opinion of the Court it was not an

order of assessment. Doubt about the correctness of the view

taken in the above case has been expressed during the course

of hearing. We need not say anything about that as we

constitute a Bench of equal strength. But we are clear and

definite in our mind that the ratio of Parikh's case is

neither applicable nor should be extended to cover the

expression "Assessment Order" occurring in section 35(1) of

the Act. In the context the said expression would include

an order made under section 23A also, as, such an order

undoubtedly forms part of the record of assessment. Mr.

Gupte, learned counsel for the respondents in his usual

fairness conceded, and rightly, that the power of rectifica-

tion of mistake conferred on the Income-tax Officer under

section 35(1) of the Act cannot be confined within the very

narrow limit of an order of assessment made under section 23

only. Counsel submitted that it does embrace some other

kinds of order relating to assessment. Having conceded so

far Mr. Gupte endeavoured in vain to take an order made

under section 23A of the Act outside the purview of the

power of the income-tax Officer for rectification of mis-

takes.

In Sankappa's case, as we have said above, the same

Bench which decided Parikh's case, after stating on the

basis of certain earlier authorities that the word 'assess-

ment' under certain circumstances in a given context has a

more comprehensive meaning finally said at page 764 of 68

I.T.R. thus:

"It is clear that, when proceedings are taken

for rectification of assessment to tax either under

section 35(1) or section 35(5) of the Act of 1922,

those proceedings must be held to be proceedings

for assessment. In proceeding under those provi-

sions, what the Income-tax Officer does is to

correct errors in, or rectify orders of assessment

made by him, and orders making such corrections or

rectifications are, therefore, clearly part of the

proceedings for assessment."

The High Court in the judgment under appeal has extracted

the above passage from Sankappa's case but allowed itself to

be misled by it. Correctly appreciated, the passage means

that what the Income-tax Officer does in a proceeding under

section 35(1) is to correct errors in assessment or

rectify-orders of assessment made by him. Either of such

orders is a part of the proceeding of assessment. In our

considered opinion correcting an apparent error in an order

made under section 23A of the Act is rectifying a mistake in

the record of assessment and clearly falls within the ambit

of the power conferred upon the Income-tax Officer under

section 35(1) of the Act.

Although in the appeals before us we are concerned with

the Income-tax Act of 1922 only, in passing we may make

reference to the corresponding provisions in the Income Tax

Act of 1961. Corresponding to section 23A of the 1922 Act is

section 104 in the 1961 Act. Section 154(1) of the latter

Act corresponds to section 35(1) of the former Act. Clause

(a) of section 154(1) says:

"With a view to rectifying any mistake apparent from

the record–

(a) the Income-tax Officer may amend any order

of assessment or of refund or any other order

passed by him;"

The provision so made is very precise and definite giving

power to the Income-tax Officer to amend any other order

passed by him apart from the order of assessment or refund.

The language of section 35(1) of the 1922 Act, perhaps, is

not wide enough conferring power on the Income-tax Officer

to am.end any order passed by him under the Act and may not

be at par with the wide powers conferred on him under sec-

tion 154(1)(a)'of the 1961 Act. Yet it is not too narrow to

cover only the order of assessment or of refund in a very

restricted or limited sense. It is wide enough to take

within its sweep some other orders made under the Act in-

cluding an order under section 23A.

For the reasons stated above, we allow these appeals and

set aside the judgment and order of the High Court. The

writ petitions filed by the respondents are dismissed. Each

of the two respondent companies must pay one set of costs in

this Court in its respective appeals.

V.P.S. Appeals allowed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-kanpur-v-j-k-commercial-c/