Skip to content

Silvi Valentina v. State of Kerala & Ors.

Silvi Valentina v. State of Kerala & Ors.

LOK Law Journal

LOK 2026 (11) Ker. 203

Equivalent citations: 2026 KER 88786

Court
High Court of Kerala
Bench
Harisankar V. Menon, J.
Case No.
W.P.(C) No. 40401 of 2024
For petitioner / appellant
S.M. Prasanth and Reshma Das P., Advocates
For respondent
Paul Jose, Senior Government Pleader; George Cherian, Senior Advocate; George A. Cherian and Arathi Prabhakaran, Advocates

Service Law

Tags

WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

  • Medical Insurance Scheme for State Employees and Pensioners (MEDISEP) — Clause 3

Headnote

Service Law — MEDISEP — Medical reimbursement — Non-empanelled hospital

A retired government servant challenged refusal of MEDISEP reimbursement for cardiac treatment at a non-empanelled hospital. The Court considered the scheme’s emergency-treatment clause and the decisions requiring medical reimbursement claims to be assessed with regard to the actual treatment and the scheme. (Paras 1–13)

Clause 3 required consideration beyond the insurer’s stated restriction to accident, stroke and heart attack. The Court set aside the impugned orders and directed the Additional Chief Secretary to reconsider the claim, with a hearing, within three months. Any entitlement was limited to the approved rate or package for the hospitalization claimed. (Paras 13–14 and concluding directions)

Acts, Sections and Scheme Provisions

Medical Insurance Scheme for State Employees and Pensioners (MEDISEP) — Clause 3

Cases referred 6

  1. Yusuff A.M. v. State of Kerala 2026 (2) KHC 175 Referred
  2. Anilkumar B.S. v. State Medical Officer, Thrissur 2026 KHC OnLine 2080 Referred
  3. Appeal from Anilkumar B.S. v. State Medical Officer, Thrissur W.A. No.1656 of 2026 Referred
  4. Jijo Thankachan v. State of Kerala 2025 KHC OnLine 12176 (Ker.) Referred
  5. Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India LOK 2018 (4) SC 135 : (2018) 16 SCC 187 Referred
  6. Daily Rated Casual Labour Employed under P and T Department through Bhartiya Dak Tar Mazdoor Manch v. Union of India and Others AIR 1987 SC 2342 Referred

Judgment

The petitioner is stated to be a retired Government Servant, receiving only a meagre amount towards ex gratia pension. She is stated to be an “insured person” with reference to the Medical Insurance Scheme for State Employees and Pensioners (MEDISEP) introduced by the State Government pursuant to Ext.P1. It is further pointed out that the petitioner had very serious cardiac issues, pursuant to which an “Aortic Valve Replacement” was carried out in the year 2005 , also advising for replacement of the valve after 15 years. On 23 .11.2023, upon feeling giddiness and double vision, she was taken to Little Flower Hospital, Angamaly, and later referred to Lisie Hospital, Ernakulam. The petitioner was also advised by the doctor at Lisie Hospital to carry out an “Aortic Valve Replacement”. The petitioner states that she wished to have the replacement procedure performed by the same doctor who had performed the procedure in 2005 and, accordingly, sought permission from the Government to undergo the procedure at Lisie Hospital, Ernakulam. In response, the Government, vide Ext.P3 dated 23.11.2023, informed the petitioner that Lisie Hospital, Ernakulam, is not an empanelled hospital and therefore, the benefits could not be extended to her. The petitioner further points out that she again consulted Lisie Hospital on 26.12.2023, when she was advised to undergo tooth extraction in view of her dental issues. Accordingly, she was admitted to the hospital on the same day and discharged on 28.12.2023 in a stable conditi on. It is further pointed out that, on 03.01.2024, the petitioner felt breathlessness and was taken to Lisie Hospital, where she was admitted to the CTICU for furthe r management. Later, the Aortic Valve was replaced on 06.01.2024, and thereafter, she was discharged on 12.01.2024. Ext.P4 is the discharge summary with respect to the afore procedure. Ext.P5 is the bill issued by the hospital as per which an amount of Rs.6,87,646.81 was paid by the petitioner towards the procedure as above. Later, the petitioner submitted Ext.P6 claim for reimbursement of the hospital expenditure as above under the Scheme, which stood rejected pursuant to Ext.P7 issued by the 3rd respondent herein. The reason stated in Ext.P7 is to the effect that the hospital where the procedure was carried out is not an empanelled hospital and hence not entitled to reimbursement under the Scheme. The petitioner filed a further representation at Ext.P8 before the Government, which was directed to be considered as an appeal under the Scheme pursuant to Ext.P10 judgment in W.P.(C) No.25252 of 2024. Pursuant to the direction as above, the 4 th respondent issued Ext.P12 communication informing the petitioner that reimbursement could be effected only in an emergent situation with respect to the treatment carried out through a non-empanelled hospital, and since Lisie Hospital is a non-empanelled hospital and there was no emergency to the petitioner, the appeal could not be accepted. Ext.P13 Government Order was also issued by the Government in tune with the communication at Ext.P12. It is seeking to challenge Ext.P7 issued by the 3rd respondent – Insurance Company, as confirmed in Exts.P12 and P13 by the Government, the petitioner has filed the captioned writ petition.

2. I have heard Sri. S.M.Prasanth , the learned counsel for the petitioner, and Sri.George Cherian, the learned senior counsel instructed by Sri. Sri.George A. Cherian, the learned counsel for the 3rd respondent, and Sri.Paul Jose, the learned Senior Government Pleader for the State.

3. Sri.Prasanth, the learned counsel for the petitioner, sought to rely on Clause 3 of Ext.P1 Scheme and the discharge summary at Ext.P4 to contend that since the petitioner was admitted to the hospital in an emergency, the claim ought to have been accepted. He would also point out that the petitioner is entitled for reimbursement with reference to the principles laid down by the Apex Court in Shiva Kant Jha v. Union of India [(2018) 16 SCC 187]. He also sought to place reliance on the judgments of this Court in Yusuff A.M. v. State of Kerala [2026 (2) KHC 175] and Jijo Thankachan v. State of Kerala [2025 KHC Online 12176 (Ker.)] in this regard.

4. Per contra, Sri.George Cherian, the learned senior counsel for the 3rd respondent, would contend that even going by the application filed by the petitioner at Ext s.P2 and P8, the fact that the petitioner wanted the procedure to be carried out by the same cardiac surgeon who carried out the valve replacement in 2005 is very clear. Therefore, it is his submission that the procedure carried out in Lisie Hospital was a planned one and hence cannot be considered to be an emergency situation covered by Clause 3 of Ext.P1. He sought to rely on the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in W.A.No.1656 of 2026 dated 31.08.2026, to contend that ultimately the claim requires to be considered only with reference to the provisions of the Scheme and therefore, the petitioner is not entitled to any reliefs. Without prejudice to the afore, he would also point out that if at all the petitioner can claim any amount under the Scheme, that can only be the approved amounts under the Scheme and not the entire amounts covered by the bills issued by the Hospital.

5. The learned Government Pleader has also joined the issue, seeking to support the stand taken b y the Insurance Company as above.

6. I have considered the rival contentions and the connected records.

7. The facts are not in dispute. As already noticed , the petitioner underwent a valve replacement in the year 2005. She was advised to go for further replacement after 15 years. The petitioner is stated to have been taken to Little Flower Hospital, Angamaly, in November, 2023, pursuant to giddiness and double vision, and she was directed to take a second opinion from Lisie Hospital. Pursuant to this, the petitioner was admitted to Lisie Hospital during December, 2023, when certain dental issues were noticed, and the tooth was also extracted. The petitioner was discharged from the hospital on 28.12.2023 in a stable condition. At this juncture, reference requires to be made to the averments contained in paragraph 4 of Ext.P8 application filed before the Government, wherein the petitioner has specifically pointed out that the afore procedure was carried out as a necessary requirement with respect to surgery/procedure which requires to be carried out under any circumstances and not with reference to the procedure to be carried out at Lisie Hospital alone.

8. The petitioner has pointed out that it was subsequently that she felt breathlessness on 03.01.2024 and was admitted to Lisie Hospital. At this juncture, the discharge summary dated 12.01.2024, issued by the hospital following the procedure, also requires to be taken note of. The brief clinical history in Ext.P4 reads as under:

“Mrs.Silvi Valantina, 59 years old female K/C/O VHD-S/P AVR in 2005 (#21mm Mosaic) presented with history of giddiness and double vision. She went to L.F.Hospital where Neurology consultation sought. CT brain done, report showed TIA (23.01.23). Patient sought Cardiology consultation in same hospital. Echo done showed increased AV gradients (72/39mmHG). Hence advised Redo AVR. Patient admitted to Emergency due to sudden onset of breathlessness shifted to CTICU for further management.”

(Underlining supplied) Thus, the fact that the petitioner was admitted to emergency due to sudden onset of breathlessness and later shifted to CTIUC for further management requires to be taken note of. In Ext.P8 representation filed before the Government also, the petitioner has pointed out that, in view of the emergency as above, she was not in a position to shift to any other hospital, simply because she could get the procedure carried out in an empanelled hospital. This Court is of the opinion that the health condition of the petitioner on 03.01.2024, when she was taken to Lisie Hospital, can only be considered to be an emergency situation, on account of which she could not have sought treatment from an empanelled hospital.

9. The relevant portion of Clause 3 of Ext.P1 Scheme reads as under:

“3. ……………. The coverage is restricted only to the empanelled public and private hospitals under the scheme. However, the coverage of the medical assistance under the scheme shall also be extended in respect of accident/emergency cases where the patient is treated for approved treatment/surgery undergone in non – empanelled hospitals. In such cases, treatment cost shall be reimbursed by the insurance company to beneficiary based on the approved rates/package of the scheme .”

(Underlining supplied) Thus, the claims in respect of an accident or an emergency also require to be approved even when the treatment/surgery is in a non-empanelled hospital. As already noticed, since the petitioner was facing an emergency as certified in Ext.P4 discharge summary, the claim ought to have been considered under the provisions of Clause 3 of Ext.P1 Scheme.

10. It is also to be noticed that the claim made by the petitioner was rejected by the 3rd respondent solely on the basis of the discharge summary from Lisie Hospital dated 28.12.2023, wherein only the tooth extraction was carried out, and the petitioner was discharged in a stable condition. No reference is seen made to the emergency noticed by the doctors on 03.01.2024.

11. The Apex Court in Shiva Kant Jha (supra) had to consider the claim for reimbursement with respect to a treatment carried out in a non-empanelled hospital, holding as under:

“17. It is a settled legal position that the government employee during his lifetime or after his retirement is entitled to get the benefit of the medical facilities and no fetters can be placed on his rights. It is acceptable to common sense, that ultimate decision as to how a patient should be treated vests only with the doctor, who is well versed and expert both on academic qualification and experience gained. Very little scope is left to the patient or his relative to decide as to the manner in which t he ailment should be treated. Speciality hospitals are established for treatment of specified ailments and services of doctors specialised in a discipline are availed by patients only to ensure proper, required and safe treatment. Can it be said that taking treatment in speciality hospital by itself would deprive a person to claim reimbursement solely on the ground that the said hospital is not included in the government order. The right to medical claim cannot be denied merely because the name of the hospital is not included in the government order. The real test must be the factum of treatment. Before any medical claim is honoured, the authorities are bound to ensure as to whether the claimant had actually taken treatment and the factum of treatment is supported by records duly certified by doctors/hospitals concerned. Once, it is established, the claim cannot be denied on technical grounds. Clearly, in the present case, by taking a very inhuman approach, the officials of CGHS have denied the gra nt of medical reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to approach this Court.

18. This is hardly a satisfactory state of affairs. The relevant authorities are required to be more responsive and cannot in a mechanical manner deprive an employee of his legitimate reimbursement. The Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) was propounde d with a purpose of providing health facility scheme to the Central Government employees so that they are not left without medical care after retirement. It was in furtherance of the object of a welfare State, which must provide for such medical care that the scheme was brought in force. In the facts of the present case, it cannot be denied that the writ petitioner was admitted in the abovesaid hospitals in emergency conditions. Moreover, the law does not require that prior permission has to be taken in such situation where the survival of the person is the prime consideration . The doctors did his operation and had implanted CRT -D device and have done so as one essential and timely. Though it is the claim of the respondent State that the rates were exorbitant whereas the rates charged for such facility shall be only at CGHS rates and that too after following a proper procedure given in the circulars issued on time to ti me by the Ministry concerned, it also cannot be denied that the petitioner was taken to hospital under emergency conditions for survival of his life which requirement was above the sanctions and treatment in empanelled hospitals.” (Underlining supplied) Thus, it has been categorically found by the Apex Court that ultimately it is the factum of treatment which requires to be taken note of, supported by the records, and once the same is established, the claim is not to be denied on technical grounds. The Apex Court also found that the Scheme was propounded with the purpose of providing health facilities to the Central Government Employees, and the authorities are required to be more responsive and not to act in a mechanical manner.

12. Following the afore judgment of the Apex Court, as well as the judgment of the Apex Court in Daily Rated Casual Labour Employed under P and T Department through Bhartiya Dak Tar Mazdoor Manch v. Union of India and Others [AIR 1987 SC 2342], which held that the Government should be a model employer, this Court in Yusuff A.M. (supra), has allowed a similar claim, which was sought to be disallowed since the treatment was carried out in a non-empanelled hospital. Again, in Jijo Thankachan (supra), the case of a Government Employee who availed treatment at a non-empanelled hospital following an accident was also ordered to be reimbursed.

13. This Court also notices the judgment of a learned Single Judge of this Court in Anilkumar B.S. v. State Medical Officer, Thrissur [2026 KHC OnLine 2080], wherein a similar claim was rejected since the treatment was undertaken in a non-empanelled hospital, the petitioner contending that the empanelled hospitals were not having the equipment to treat the medical condition (Acute Myeloid Leukaemia) and therefore, the treatment was availed from a non-empanelled hospital. Considering the situation, with reference to the principles laid down by the Apex Court in Shiva Kant Jha (supra), the learned Single Judge of this Court directed the claim to be reconsidered in the manner directed thereunder. The Insurance Company had filed an appeal against the said judgment as W.A.No.1656 of 2026, which was also rejected by the Division Bench of this Court, further adding that the claim requires to be considered strictly in terms of Clause 3 of the Scheme (Ext.P1 in this writ petition). The Division Bench held that, in the impugned proceedings before the learned Single Judge, the respondents took up the contention that treatment in a non-empanelled hospital would be eligible to be covered under the ambit of MEDISEP only in the case of three eventualities viz., accident, stroke and heart attack and, according to the Division Bench, since Clause 3 of the Scheme is not so limiting the claim; the matter requires to be considered only in tune with the provisions of Clause 3.

14. On the whole, this Court is of the opinion that the matter requires a reconsideration at the hands of the 2nd respondent. This is especially so since the petitioner has clarified that she is only seeking reimbursement as regards the bill in connection with her hospitalization from 03.01.2024 to 12.01.2024 and under the Scheme, the petitioner’s entitlement, even if any, can only be on the “approved rate/package”.

Hence, this writ petition would stand disposed of as under:

i. Exts.P7, 12 and 13 are set aside.

ii. There will be a direction to the 2nd respondent to consider the matter afresh with specific reference to the observations in this judgment, as expeditiously as possible, at any rate, within a period of three months from today. Needless to say that the petitioner is also to be granted an opportunity of being heard in the matter.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/silvi-valentina-v-state-of-kerala/