Skip to content

Bashir Ahmed Magrey v. Ghulam Quadir Mir

Bashir Ahmed Magrey v. Ghulam Quadir Mir

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (12) SC 22

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 231 : 1977 (1) SCC 285 : 1977 (2) SCR 297 : 1977 UJ 38

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; V.R. Krishnaiyer, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 317 of 1976
For petitioner / appellant
M.N. Phadke, Altaf Ahmed and Veerappa, for the Appellant.
WhatsApp
Print

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

During the general elections held in March

1972 five candidates, namely, the appellant and respondents

No. 1 to 4, contested tile election for the Jammu & Kashmir

State Legislative Assembly from Rajpura constituency. There

was a sixth candidate, namely, Mohamed Abdullah Sheikh,

respondent No. 5, but his nomination paper was rejected. The

appellant secured 9,079 votes and was declared elected.

Respondent No. 1 was the nearest rival and he secured 8,248

votes. Respondents 2 to 4 secured 1,340, 1,126 and 1,217

votes respectively. 2,034 votes were declared invalid at the

time of counting. After the declaration of the result of

the election, respondent No. 1 filed election petition out

of which the present appeal arises. Two prayers were made in

the election petition: (1) that the election of the appel-

lant be declared to be void; and (2) that respondent No. 1

be declared to have been duly elected. The High Court

accepted the first prayer and declared the election of the

appellant to be void. The second prayer that respondent No.

1 be declared to have been duly elected was not granted. The

present appeal has been filed by the appellant against the

judgment of the High Court insofar as it has declared his

election to be void. Cross-objections have been filed by

respondent No. 1 and it has been prayed on his behalf that

he be declared to have been duly elected.

The election petition was founded on the

following three grounds:

(1 ) Improper rejection of the nomination

paper of respondent No. 5.

(2) Improper rejection of the votes which had

been cast in favour of respondent No. 1

(hereinafter referred to as the respondent);

and

(3) Improper reception of the votes in favour

of the appellant on the day of polling at the

following polling stations:

1. Lassipora–Polling station No. 49

2. Nowpora Pain–Polling station No. 50

3. Drubgham-B–Polling station No. 24 4.

Drubgham-A–Polling station No. 23

4. Drugbham-A–Polling station No.23

5. Aliaipora–Polling station No. 51

6. Chandgham–Polling station No. 46

7. Arihal–Polling station No. 35, and

8. Tikan Batapora–Polling station No. 26.

According to the case of the respondent as set up in the

election petition, the result of the election was materially

affected because of the improper rejection at the time of

counting of the votes which had been cast in his favour and

by the improper reception of the votes in favour of the

appellant on the day of polling. Giving particulars in

respect of the third ground, namely, that there was improper

reception of votes in favour of the appellant on the day of

polling, the respondent stated that the total number of

votes at Lassipura (polling station No. 49) was 824. All

those votes were shown to have ben polled, although 162

voters registered in that area did not cast their votes.

The figure of 162 included 16 persons who were dead before

the date of polling. Electoral numbers of those 162 voters,

including 16 dead persons, were also mentioned in the peti-

tion. The votes of 162 persons were thus stated to have

been improperly received. Similar allegations were made in

respect of Nowpora Pain (polling station No. 50), Drubgham

B (polling station No. 24), Drubgham A (polling station No.

23), Alaipora (polling station No. 51), Chandgam (polling

station. No. 46), Arihal (polling station No. 35) and Tikan

Batapora (polling station No. 26).

We may add at this stage that the first ground, namely,

that relating to the improper rejection of the nomination

paper of respondent No. 5, was not pressed at the trial of

the election petition, and as such no 1onger survives.

The election petition was resisted by the appellant and

he denied the various allegations made by the respondent.

He also pleaded that the allegations in the election peti-

tion were vague, indefinite and uncertain. Objection was

also raised regarding the maintainability of the petition on

the grounds that it had not been properly verified and there

war misjoinder of parties.

The petition was initially heard by Wasi-ud-Din J. It

thereafter came up for hearing before Jalal-ud-Din J.

Ultimately, it came up for hearing before Mufti Baha-ud-Din

Farooqi J. who finally decided the petition and gave the

judgment under appeal.

During the pendency of the petition, orders were made on

three occasions for inspection of the ballot papers. The

first order was made by Wasi-ud-Din J. on August 13, 1973.

The learned Judge, considered the prayer for inspection of

ballot papers under three heads:

"(1) Request for inspection of ballot papers

which were rejected at the time of counting;

(2) Request for inspection a ballot paper

account (Form No. 16) in respect of the var-

ious polling stations and of the ballot papers

relevant thereto;

(3) Request for inspection of marked

copies of electoral rolls at polling stations

Lassipora, Drubgham A & B, Achan, Chandgham,

Afthal, Nowpora Pain, Tikam Batopora, Alaipo-

ra."

Prayer under the first and third heads was rejected but that

under the second head was allowed to the extent of the

inspection of form No. 16 in respect of Lassipora, Nowpora

Pain, Drubgham B, Drubgham A, Alaipora, Chandgham, Arihal

and Tikan Batopora polling stations. Inspection of a few

ballot papers, of which the numbers were specified, relating

to some of the polling stations was allowed. On November 2,

1973 the learned Judge amplified his previous orders in

these words:

"My order as it stands should be read to

Clearly signify which I am amplifying here

also that the sorting of the ballot papers

will be done by the Deputy Registrar but in

the presence of the learned counsel for both

the parties. The learned counsel for the

parties will not be allowed to handle the

ballot papers until they are sorted out by the

Deputy Registrar and after this is done, the

respective learned counsel for the parties can

handle and inspect the ballot papers."

On June 13, 1974 the learned Judge, on an application made

by the respondent, allowed inspection of ballot papers of

two more polling stations, viz., Chandgham and Alaipora.

The respondent also made prayer for leave to inspect the

ballot papers of other polling stations, but the prayer in

that behalf was rejected. The following directions were

further issued by the learned Judge:

"The petitioner has also made a prayer

that the Deputy Registrar be given directions

to ascertain if the 34 series of two inspected

polling stations Nos. 24 and 50 are not mixed

in the fourth trunk which has been produced.

The Deputy Registrar will of course see to

this and such other discrepancies which may

come to his notice, he will make a separate

note and he will also make a note on the

envelope if he found the discrepancy."

After Wasi-ud-Din J. relinquished his office, the case was

assigned to Jalal-ud-Din J. An application was then made on

July 29, 1974 by the respondent seeking permission to in-

spect ballot papers and other documents pertaining to the

various polling stations, This application was disposed of

by Jalal-ud-Din J. as per order dated January 6, 1975 in

these words:

"I, therefore, allow the application of

the petitioner for inspection of ballot papers

in respect of four veiling stations, namely,

26 Tikan Batapora from serial No. 015051 to

15700, 35 Arihal-A from serial No. 020901 to

021550, 49 Lassipora from serial No. 031051 to

031900, 23 Drubgham from serial No. 013201 to

013800 and also the counterfoils of 15 Nowpora

Pain, 24 Drubgham B. 46 Chandgham and 51

Alaipora, the polling stations of which the

ballot papers have already been inspected by

the petitioner. 1, however, do not accede to

the request of the petitioner to inspect

electoral roll and

counterfoils and from 16 of the entire con-

stituency. The inspection as ordered will be

held by and in presence of the counsel for

the parties. But the Deputy Registrar will see

that neither the candidate nor their counsel

shall, handle the record. The Deputy Registrar

will further make a separate note and record

of the discrepancies found, if any. The

inspection will be held during vacation on a

date to be fixed by the Deputy Registrar."

In the judgment under appeal the learned Judge held that 59

votes validly polled in favour of the respondent were im-

properly rejected at the time of counting. It was further

found that 901 votes, including 28 votes of dead voters,

were improperly polled.. Out of 901 votes, 351 votes were

found to have been polled in favour of the appellant. De-

tails of those 351 votes were as under:

Alaipora polling station No. 51

Arihal polling station No. 35

Takin Batapora P.S. No. 26

Regarding the remaining 550 votes, the learned Judge found

that the evidence was not clear, and observed as under:

"The evidence, however, is not clear as

regards the fate of the remaining 550 such

votes. But having regard to overall circum-

stances of the case it will not be unreasona-

ble to conclude that respondent No. 1 was the

greatest beneficiary of these 550 votes al-

though the precise number by which he was

benefited out of those votes may not be easily

ascertainable. To these circumstances may be

added the circumstance that 59 votes validly

polled in favour of the petitioner were im-

properly rejected at the time of counting, as

held by me before. The cumulative effect of

these circumstances is that the respondent No.

1 was able to get an undue advantage of no

less magnitude and may be, even greater than

that reflected in his declared success over

the petitioner by 831 votes. In this view it

must be held that the result of the election,

insofar as respondent No. 1 is concerned, was

materially affected by the improper rejection

of votes in favour of the petitioner at the

time of counting and the improper reception of

votes on the day of poll and that his election

must be declared to be void. But that should

not entitle the petitioner to a declaration

that he was duly elected as the total number

of the votes improperly received in favour of

respondent No. 1 on the date of poll could not

be exactly worked out. The prayer for such

de- claration must be rejected."

In the result, the election of the appellant was declared to

be void. The prayer of the respondent for a declaration that

he be declared to have been elected was rejected.

When this appeal came up for hearing before this Court on

September 3, 1976, we passed an order wherein we referred to

the finding of the High Court that it cannot be said as to

who was the beneficiary of the 550 votes which were found to

have been improperly polled. We thereafter stated in that

order:

"In our opinion, it is necessary to find

out as a result of further inspection as to

how many d those 550 votes were in favour of

the appellant, and how many, in favour of

respondent No. 1 and the other contesting

candidates. For this purpose, we depute the

Registrar (Judicial) of this Court to make an

inspection in the presence of the parties and

their counsel and submit a report to this

Court within six weeks from today. The Regis-

trar may also have to locate the 55 ballot

papers referred to in the judgment of the High

Court at pages 31-51 of the cyclostyled judg-

ment. He may also, if necessary, refer to the

reports of the Deputy Registrar of the High

Court. The appeal should be put up for further

hearing as soon as the report is ready."

The Registrar of this Court thereafter submitted his report

dated September 15, 1976. The Registrar dealt with most of

the matters but in respect of some of the matters he sought

further directions. Necessary directions were thereafter

issued by this Court on September 17, 1976. As a result of

those directions, the Registrar had to scrutinise 571

ballot papers in all instead of 550 votes. The final report

of the Registrar is dated September 24, 1976. The result of

the reports of the Registrar taken along with the findings

of the High Court may be set out:

(1) Votes found by the High Court to

have been improperly received in

favour of the appellant

(2) Votes which were found to have been

improperly received in favour of the

appellant as per the first report of the

Registrar

(3) Votes which were found to have been

improperly received in favour of the

appellant as per the second report of

Registrar.

Total

(4) Total number of votes polled by the

appellant as per the results of the

election

9,079

(5) Valid votes polled by the appellant

9,079-778=8301

(6) Votes which were found to have been

improperly received in favour of the

respondent as per the first report

(7) Votes which were found to have been

improperly received in favour of the

respondent as per the second report

Total

(8) Total votes polled by the respondent

as per the result of the election

8,248

(9) Votes validly polled in favour of the

respondent which were found by the

High Court to have been improperly

rejected at the time of counting

(10) Total number of votes thus polled by

the respondent

8,248+59=8,307

(11) Valid votes polled by the respondent

8,307- 44=8,263

(12) Excess of votes validity polled in

favour of the appellant over those of

of the respondent.

Some votes were found by the Registrar to have been im-

properly received in favour of respondents 2 to 4, but it is

not necessary to set out those votes.

In appeal before us Mr. Phadke on behalf of the appel-

lant has urged that in view of the final picture as it

emerges from the reports of the Registrar, the appeal should

be allowed and the election petition be dismissed as the

appellant secured more valid votes than the respondent.

The above stand has been controverted by the respond-

ent, who has argued the case in person. At an earlier

hearing we requested Mr. Gambhir to argue the case amicus

curiae in view of the fact that the respondent was not

represented by counsel. The respondent thereafter stated

that he Would like the matter to be argued by counsel of his

own choice. Mr. Shaukat Hussain thereafter appeared on

behalf of the respondent. At the final hearing the respond-

ent, as mentioned above, chose to argue the case in person.

Perusal of the election petition filed by the respondent

shows that apart from the ground not subsequently pressed of

the improper rejection of the nomination paper of respondent

No. 5, the only ground on which the respondent challenged.

the election of the appellant was the improper reception of

votes in favour of the appellant and the improper rejection

of the votes cast in favour of the respondent.

This ground is based upon sub-clause (iii) of clause (d) of

sub-section (1) of section 108 of the Jammu and Kashmir

Representation of the People Act, 1957 (Act 4 of 1957)

corresponding to sub-clause (iii) of clause (d) of sub-

section (1) of section 100 of the Representation of the

People, Act 1951 fact 43 of 1951). According to the above

provision, if the High Court is of the opinion that the

result of the election, in so far as it concerns a returned

candidate, has been materially affected by the improper

reception, refusal or rejection of any vote of the reception

of any vote which is void, the High Court shall declare the

election of the returned candidate to be void. Keeping the

above provision in view, we may now turn to the facts of the

present case. The High Court found that 351 votes had been

improperly received in favour of the appellant. The High

Court further found that 59 votes which had been validly

polled i.n favour of the, respondent were improperly reject-

ed at the time of counting. In addition to. that, the High

Court found that 550 votes had been improperly received, but

it was not possible on the material on record to find out as

to who was the beneficiary of those votes. The High Court

all the same was inclined to believe that the appellant must

have been the major beneficiary of those 550 votes. This

necessarily involved an element of surmise and conjecture.

To find out the exact position, we directed the Registrar of

this Court to

scrutinise the 550 ballot papers in question and to make a

report as to how many of those votes were cast in favour of

the appellant and how many in favour of the respondent and

the other candidates. The Registrar thereafter submitted

reports and we have already set out the outcome of those

reports taken along with the findings of the High Court.

It would appear from the figures set out above that, exclud-

ing all the votes which were found to have been improperly

received by the appellant and also giving credit to the

respondent for 59 votes which were found by the High Court

to have been improperly rejected at that time of counting,

the net result still is that the appellant has a lead of 38

votes over the respondent. There is, therefore, no escape

from the conclusion that the election of tile appellant

should be upheld. In an election petition founded upon the

ground that the result of the election was materially af-

fected by the improper reception or rejection of votes, the

court has first to decide whether certain ballot papers were

improperly received or were improperly rejected. Once ,that

controversy is resolved, the rest is purely a matter of

arithmetical calculation. If the result of arithmetical

calculation is that the returned candidate has still a lead

over his nearest rival, his election would not be declared

to be void on the ground of improper reception or improper

rejection of votes. Improper reception or improper rejec-

tion of votes can result in invalidating an election only if

such improper reception or improper rejection materially

affects the result of the election.

In the course of his arguments, the respondent has

submitted that a number of improprieties were committed in

the conduct of election and therefore the election of the

appellant be declared to be void. Although it does appear

from the material on record to which our attention was

invited by the respondent that irregularities were committed

in the conduct of the election, the respondent cannot

derive any benefit on that account. As already mentioned,

the respondent sought to challenge the election of the

appellant only on the ground of improper reception and

improper rejection of certain votes. The election of the

appellant was not challenged on the ground of any irregular-

ity or non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitu-

tion or of the Representation of the People Act or of any

rules or orders made thereunder. Nor was the election of

the appellant assailed on the ground of being vitiated by

corrupt practice. As it is not permissible to widen the

scope of an election petition beyond the grounds actually

set up in the election petition, the respondent cannot seek

relief on grounds which were not taken by him in the elec-

tion petition.

It has also been urged by the respondent that the

number of votes which were improperly received was larger

than that found by the High Court. Nothing cogent has,

however, been brought to our notice in support of the above

submission to induce us to interfere with the finding of the

High Court in, this respect.

Lastly, the respondent submits that 153 ballot papers of

Lassipora polling station cast in favour of the appellant

should be rejected as

they bore the initials and not the full signatures of the

presiding officer. Our attention in this respect is invit-

ed to clause (h) of rule 56(2) of the Jammu and Kashmir

Conduct of Election Rules, 1965, according to which the

returning officer at the time of counting shall reject a

ballot paper if it does not bear both the mark and the

signatures which it should have borne under the provisions

of sub-rule (1) of rule 3 8. According to sub-rule (1 ) of

rule 3 8, every ballot paper shall before issue to elector,

be stamped by such distinguishing mark as the Election

Commission may direct, and be signed in full on its back by

the presiding officer. It is not disputed that the ballot

papers in question bore the distinguishing mark. The only

contention of the respondent, as already mentioned, is that

the ballot papers in question bore the initials and not the

full signatures of the presiding officer. In this respect we

find that no express ground on that score was set up by the

respondent in the election petition. This apart, we that

the matter is covered by the first proviso to sub-rule (2)

of rule 56 which reads as under;

"Provided that where the returning offi-

cer is satisfied that any such defect as is

mentioned in clause (g) or clause (h) has been

caused by any mistake or failure on the part

of a presiding officer or polling officer,

the ballot paper shall not be rejected merely

on the ground of such defect."

The above proviso which is based upon the principle that a

vote validly cast should not be excluded from consideration

because of the mistake or omission of the presiding or

polling officer, makes it plain that where the returning

officer is satisfied that any defect mentioned in clause (h)

has been caused by the mistake or failure on the part of a

presiding officer or polling officer, the ballot paper shall

not be rejected merely on the ground of such defect. The

fact that the returning officer in the present case did not

reject the ballot papers in question on the ground that they

bore only the initials and not the full signatures of the

presiding officer would go to show that the returning offi-

cer was satisfied that the alleged defect was caused by the

mistake or failure on the part of the presiding officer:

There can indeed be hardly any doubt on the point that the

defect referred to by the respondent occurred because of the

mistake or failure of the presiding officer. We, there-

fore, see no cogent ground to exclude from consideration 153

ballot papers polled in favour of the appellant.

Before we conclude, we may observe that some other con-

tentions were also advanced on behalf of the appellant. In

view of the fact that the appeal in any case has to be

allowed because of the arithmetical calculations referred to

above, it is not necessary to go into those contentions.

As a result of the above, we accept the appeal, set aside

the judgment of ,the High Court and dismiss the election

petition. Crossobjections filed by the respondent are

dismissed. Looking to all the facts, we leave the parties

to bear their own costs throughout.

P.B.R. Appeal al-

lowed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/bashir-ahmed-magrey-v-ghulam-quadir-mir/