Skip to content

Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh

Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. Kali Singh

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (8) SC 53

Equivalent citations: 1978 (84) CriLJ 187 : AIR 1977 SC 2432 : 1976 CAR 214 : 1977 CrLR(SC) 42 : 1977 (1) SCC 57 : 1977 SCC(Cr) 33 : 1977 (1) SCR 125

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Syed Murtaza Fazalali, J.; P.N. Bhagwati, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Criminal Appeal No. 74 of 1976
For petitioner / appellant
A.K. Sen and A.K. Nag, for the Appellant.
For respondent
D. Gobrudhan, for the respondent.
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 1

  1. Pramatha Nath Taluqdar v. Saroj Ranjan Referred (Para 1)

Referred in 2

  1. Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. Music Broadcast Pvt. Ltd. LOK 2012 (5) SC 42 Referred (Para 19)
  2. Mahesh Chand v. B. Janardhan Reddy LOK 2002 (12) SC 46 Referred (Para 1)

Judgment

FAZAL ALI, J.

This appeal by special leave exhibits the

careless and cavalior manner in which the Sub-Divisional

Magistrate appears to have dealt with the complaint filed

before him as far back as 21st February, 1966. The com-

plaint itself contains allegations of a very petty nature,

of which hardly any cognizance could have been taken and

which would be a trivial act under Sec. 95 of Indian

Penal Code for which no criminal proceedings could be taken.

There were proceedings under Section 107 between the parties

and both

parties applied for copies of .these proceedings on the 20th

December, 1965. It is alleged in the complaint that the

appellant got the copy which was meant for the complainant,

by signing his name. The complainant also got his copy a

few days after eventually. Such a small matter could have

been resolved by the Magistrate himself if he had persued

the complaint carefully and was certainly not a , matter

for which a detailed inquiry under section 202, Code of

Criminal Procedure, 1908 was called for. It appears, howev-

er, that the Magistrate tossed the complaint from one Magis-

trate to another for inquiry and report, without conclusive

results, starting from 21st February 1966 to 23rd November

1968, that is, for a period of more than two years. Ulti-

mately, on the 23rd November, 1968 the complaint was dis-

missed under section 203 of the Criminal Procedure Code on

the ground that the complainant was absent and did not

show any interest in the inquiry ordered by the Court.

On the 7th of December, 1968 the respondent appeared

before the Magistrate and filed an application for recalling

his order. The Magistrate passed no orders on this applica-

tion but he sent the case' for inquiry to Mr. K.P. Sinha,

another Magistrate. Thereafter, the matter was sent to Mr.

S.N. Dube on 30th of October, 1969. Mr, Dube reported that

the inquiry had been completed and hence he returned the

papers. of inquiry to the Magistrate. On 9th of Decem-

ber, 1970, the Magistrate recalled the inquiry from Mr. K.P.

Sinha and transferred to Mr. A.R. Ansari and on the basis of

his report, the learned Magistrate passed the order taking

cognizance of the case and summoned the accused by his order

dated 3-5-1972, and issued processes against the appellants.

It would thus appear that a very petty matter was allowed to

have a long and chequered career because the Magistrate

refused to apply his mind either to the' allegations made in

the complaint or to control the proceedings before him.

In support of the appeal Mr, Nag has submitted a short

point. He has contended that the Magistrate had no jurisdic-

tion to recall the order dated 23-11-1968, by which he had

dismissed the complaint under Section 203 of the Code of

Criminal Procedure. In fact, there was no express order

recalling the order dismissing the complaint, but by a

process of deeming fiction the Magistrate thought that the

order dismissing the complaint stood recalled.

We might mention that the order dated 23rd November,

1968 was a judicial order by which the Magistrate had given

full reasons for dismissing the complaint. Even if

the Magistrate had any jurisdiction to recall this order,

it could have been done by another judicial order after

giving reasons that he was satisfied that a case was made

out for recalling the order. We, however, need not dilate

on this point because there is absolutely no provision in

the Code of Criminal Procedure of 1908 (which applies to

this case) empowering a Magistrate to. review or recall an

order passed by him. Code of Criminal Procedure does contain

a provision for inherent powers, namely, Section 561-A

which, however, confers these powers on the High Court and

the High Court alone. Unlike Section 151

of Civil Procedure Code, the subordinate criminal courts

have no inherent powers. In these circumstances, there-

fore, the learned Magistrate had absolutely no jurisdic-

tion to recall the order dismissing the complaint. The

remedy of the respondent was to move the Sessions Judge or

the High Court in revision. In fact after having passed the

order dated 23-11-1968, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate became

functus officio and had no power to review or recall that

order on any ground whatsoever. In these circumstances,

therefore, the order even if there be one, recalling order

dismissing the complaint, was entirely without jurisdiction.

This being the position, all subsequent proceedings follow-

ing upon recalling the said order,would fall to the ground

including order dated 3-5-1972 summoning the accused which

must also be treated to be a nullity and destitute of any

legal effect. The High Court has not at all considered this

important aspect of the matter which alone was sufficient to

put an end to these proceedings. It was suggested by Mr. D.

Goburdhan that the application given by him for recalling

the order of dismissal of the complaint would amount to a

fresh complaint. We are, however, unable to agree with this

contention because there was no fresh complaint and it is

now well settled that a second complaint can lie only on

fresh facts or even on the previous facts only if a special

case is made out. This has been held by this Court in

Pramatha Nath Taluqdar v. Saroj Ranjan Sarkar(1). For these

reasons therefore, the appeal is allowed. The Order of the

High Court maintaining the order of the Magistrate dated

3-5-1972 is set aside and the order of the Magistrate dated

3-5-1972 summoning the appellant is hereby quashed.

M.R.

Appeal allowed.

(1) [1962] 2 Supp. S.C.R. 297.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/bindeshwari-prasad-singh-v-kali-singh/