Skip to content

Commissioner of Income-Tax, West Bengal-1,Calcutta v. Simon Carves Limited

Commissioner of Income-Tax, West Bengal-1,Calcutta v. Simon Carves Limited

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (8) SC 176

Equivalent citations: AIR 1976 SC 2368 : 1976 (105) ITR 212 : 1976 (4) SCC 435 : 1977 (1) SCR 207 : 1976 UJ 771

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; Ranjit Singh Sarkaria, J.; Jaswant Singh, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 1313 of 1973
For petitioner / appellant
(From the Judgment and Order dated 7-9-1972 of the Calcutta High Court in Income Tax Reference No. 208 of 1966). V.P. Raman, Addl. Solicitor Genl. and M.N. Shroff, for the Appellant.
For respondent
K. Ray and D.N. Gupta, for the Respondent.
WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

  • Rule 10, Income-tax Rules, 1962

Earlier decisions overruled or doubted 1

  1. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Lucknow Vs. Sh. Madho Pd. Jatia LOK 1976 (8) SC 172 : AIR 1977 SC 420 : (1976) 4 SCC 92 : (1977) 1 SCR 202 : (1976) 8 UJ 810 Overruled

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

This appeal on certificate, by the

Commissioner of Income-tax, is against the judgment

of the Calcutta High Court whereby the High Court

answered in a reference under the Income-tax Act

the following question in favour of the assessee-

respondent and against the revenue:

"Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of

the case, the Tribunal was right in holding that

in making the reassessment under section 147(b)

of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the Income-tax

Officer could not depart from the method of

computation permitted in Rule 33 of the Income-tax

Rules and followed in the original assessment, and

adopt an alternative method of computation also

permitted under the said Rules (corresponding to

Rule 10 of the Income-tax Rules, 1962) ?"

The matter relates to the assessment year

1959-60, the corresponding financial year for which

ended on March 31, 1959. The assessee is a non-

resident company carrying on business as construc-

tion engineers. The Income-tax Officer made the

original assessment on May 31, 1960 on a total

income of Rs. 21,49,169. On November 5, 1962 the

Income-tax Officer initiated proceedings under

section 147(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (herein-

after referred to as the Act) and completed the

assessment on February 29, 1964 on a total income

of Rs. 69,85,097.

At the time of the original assessment the

assessee filed the return of income along with the

auditor's certificate of the trading results of

the various contracts. One of those contracts was

in respect of work at Durgapur with the Hindustan

Steel Ltd. In respect of that work

the assessee filed a provisional estimate of income

which was arrived at "by calculating the income

that could be attributable in relation to the tax

deducted under section 18(B) by the Hindustan Steel

Ltd." The Income-tax Officer computed the income

from that contract at Rs. 5,33,164. The income

from the other contracts was computed at Rs,

16,16,005 "as per audited statements."

In the reassessment proceedings the Income-tax

Officer purported to find as under:

(i) That the assessee's outlay in India to the

total outlay in various contracts represented a

fair index of operations carried out in India and

as such 60 per cent of the profits attributable to

sterling payments and claimed to be exempt related

to operations in India and fell to be included in

the assessee's total income;

(ii) that the figure of depreciation required

to be changed; and

(iii) that some portion of the income had to be

assessed under section 4(1)(A) on receipt basis.

The total income of the assessee, as already mentioned, was

determined as a result of reassessment to be Rs. 69,85,097.

In arriving at the figure of the total income the Income-tax

Officer estimated the income in respect of Durgapur contract

to be Rs. 5,33,164 as had been done in the original assess-

ment. Regarding the other contracts, the Income-tax Officer

determined the income of the assessee in reassessment pro-

ceedings to be Rs. 64,51,933. The difference in the income

computed at the time of the original assessment and at the

time of reassessment was due to the fact that the Income-tax

Officer at the time of original assessment adopted one

method of computation under rule 33 of the Income-tax Rules,

1922 while the Income-tax Officer making reassessment adopt-

ed another method under that rule.

On appeal it was submitted before the Appellate Assist-

ant Commissioner on behalf of the assessee that the action

of the Income-tax Officer in reopening the assessment under

section 147(b) was without jurisdiction and that the

Income-tax Officer had no jurisdiction to change the

method of computation as originally adopted in the revised

proceedings. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner held that

the proceedings under section 147(b) were bad and that the

Income-tax Officer could not adopt an alternative method of

computation in the reassessment proceedings. He, therefore,

allowed the appeal. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner at

the same time observed that the Income-tax Officer would be

justified in computing the income to be Rs. 22,23,231 and

that the assessee had no objection to such a revision.

In appeal before the Tribunal the department urged

that the Appellate Assistant Commissioner was not justified

in holding that the Income-tax Officer (i) had no jurisdic-

tion to start proceedings under section 147(b) of the Act;

and (ii) that the Appellate Assistant

Commissioner had erred in allowing deductions in the income

of the assessee. The Tribunal held on the first ground that

proceedings under section 147(b) had been validly initiat-

ed. Regarding the second ground, the Tribunal observed in

agreement with the Appellate Assistant Commissioner that the

mode of computation adopted in the original assessment was

one permitted under rule 33 of the Income-tax Rules 1922 and

that the mode adopted in reassessment was another alterna-

tive method. The tribunal held that both the methods being

permissible, it could not be said that any mistake was

committed in computing the income at the time of the origi-

nal assessment on a particular basis adopted with reference

to rule 33. In the opinion of the Tribunal, the Income-tax

Officer could not in reassessment proceedings depart from

the method of computation adopted in the original assess-

ment. The Tribunal directed that the reassessment be made

"adopting the same method of computation as in the original

assessment subject to any adjustments which may be justified

such as excess depreciation being charged in the account and

so on."

At the instance of the revenue, the question reproduced

above was referred to the High Court. The High Court, while

answering the question against the revenue, referred to the

connotation of the words "escaped income" and observed

" …. it means an income which the asses-

see has succeeded in getting away with or has

eluded observation or search or notice of the tax

authorities. In other words, it cannot mean an

item of income which has not been taxed by purusing

a method approved by law. In the instant case,

the excess income was not taxable under the third

method but it has become taxable by following

another method sanctioned by the same rule, namely,

rule 33. This is not, therefore, a case of escaped

income which has not been brought into the orbit of

taxation in the reassessment proceedings."

In appeal before us learned Additional Solicitor

General has assailed the judgment of the High Court and has

contended that the High Court was in error in holding that

the instant case was not one of income escaping assessment.

As against that, Mr. Ray on behalf of the assessee-

respondent has canvassed for the correctness of the view

taken by the High Court.

Before dealing with the contentions advanced, it may be

apposite to refer to the relevant provisions. According to

section 4(1 )(c) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922, subject

to the provisions of that Act, the total income of any

previous year of any person includes all income, profits and

gains from whatever source derived which if such person is

not resident in the taxable territories during such year,

accrue or arise or are deemed to accrue or arise to him in

the taxable territories during such year. Sub-section (1)

of section 42 of the Act of 1922, inter alia, provides that

all income, profits or gains accruing or arising, whether

directly or indirectly, through or from any business connec-

tion in the taxable territories, shall be deemed to be

income

accruing or arising within the taxable territories, and

where the person entitled to the income, profits or gains is

not resident in the taxable territories, shall be chargeable

to income-tax either in his name or in the name of his

agent. According to sub-section (3) of section 42, in the

case of a business of which all the operations are not

carried out in the taxable territories, the profits and

gains of the business deemed under this section to accrue or

arise in the taxable territories shall be only such profits

and gains as are reasonably attributable to that part of the

operations carried out in the taxable territories.

The assessee-respondent in the present case carried on

business as construction engineers both in India and other

parts of the world. The Income-tax Officer, it seems, found

that the provisions of section 42 of the Act of 1922 did not

provide sufficient criteria for computing the profits and

gains of business deemed to accrue or arise in India. Resort

was accordingly had to rule 33 of the 1922 Rules. The above

rule has been made to meet such an eventuality, and reads as

under:

"In any case in which the Income-tax Officer is

of opinion that the actual amount of the income,

profits or gains accruing or arising to any person

residing out of the taxable territories whether

directly or indirectly through or from any business

connection in the taxable territories or through or

from any property in the taxable territories, or

through or from any asset or source of income in

the taxable territories, or through or from any

money lent at interest and brought into the taxable

territories in cash or in kind cannot be ascer-

tained, the amount of such income, profits or gains

for the purposes of assessment to income-tax may be

calculated on such percentage of the turnover so

accruing or arising as the Income-tax Officer may

consider to be reasonable, or on an amount which

bears the same proportion to the total profits of

the business of such person (such profits being

computed in accordance with the provisions of the

Indian Income-tax Act) as the receipts so accruing

or arising bear to the total receipts of the busi-

ness or in such other manner as the Income-tax

Officer may deem suitable."

Shorn of the parts with which we are not concerned,

the rule provides that in any case in which the

Income-tax Officer is of the opinion that the

actual amount of income, profits or gains accruing

or arising to any person residing out of the taxa-

ble territories, whether directly or indirectly,

through or from any business connection in the

taxable territories cannot be ascertained, the

amount of such income, profits or gains for the

purpose of assessment to income-tax may be calcu-

lated

(i) on such percentage of the turnover so

accruing or arising as the Income-tax Officer may

consider to be reasonable, or

(ii) on an amount which bears the same propor-

tion to the total profits of the business of such

person (such

profits being computed in accordance with the

provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act) as the

receipts so accruing or arising bear to the total

receipts of the business, or

(iii) in such other manner as the Income-tax

Officer may deem suitable.

The above rule makes it clear that if other condi-

tions mentioned in the rule are satisfied, it would

be open to the Income-tax Officer in computing the

income, profits or gains to apply one of the three

methods mentioned in the rule. It is the common

case of the parties, and that is also the underly-

ing assumption of the question referred to the High

Court, that the Income-tax Officer in making the

original assessment adopted one method while the

Income-tax Officer making reassessment adopted

another method contemplated by rule 33. The ques-

tion with which we are concerned is whether it

would be a case of income escaping assessment if

the Income-tax Officer adopts a method of computa-

tion which is permissible under the law but which

method results in lower tax liability compared to

the other method which too is permissible in law.

According to the learned Additional Solicitor

General, the adoption of a method even though

permitted by rule 33 which results in lower tax

liability of the assessee compared to the other

method mentioned in the rule would warrant the

conclusion that income has escaped assessment and

as such section 147 of the Act of 1961 would get

attracted. After giving the matter our earnest

consideration, we find it difficult to accept the

above contention. It was open, as already men-

tioned, to the Income-tax Officer at the time of

making the original assessment to adopt one of the

three methods mentioned in rule 33 for computing

the taxable income of the assessee. Discretion was

vested by rule 33 in the Income-tax Officer for the

purpose of making his choice of the methods, and

the same was to be exercised in a proper and judi-

cious manner. There is nothing before us to show

that the discretion was not exercised by the said

officer in a proper or judicious manner. It is

also not suggested that the Income-tax Officer was

actuated by some oblique motive. From the mere fact

that the method selected by him was such as result-

ed in lower tax liability of the assessee compared

to the liability which would have resulted from the

adoption of other method, it would not follow that

the discretion was not exercised in a proper and

judicious manner. The taxing authorities exercise

quasi judicial powers and in doing so they must act

in a fair and not a partisan manner. Although it

is part. of their duty to ensure that no tax which

is legitimately due from an assessee should remain

unrecovered, they must also at the same time not

act in a manner as might indicate that scales are

weighted against the assessee. We are wholly unable

to subscribe to the view that unless those authori-

ties exercise the power in a manner most beneficial

to the revenue and consequently most adverse to the

assessee they should be deemed not to have exer-

cised it in a proper and judicious manner.

The order made by the Income-tax Officer at the time of

the original assessment was a legally correct order and was

not vitiated

by any error. The absence of an error in that order would

justify the inference that the present is not a case of

income escaping assessment. There is necessarily an element

of error in cases of income escaping assessment mentioned in

section 147(b) of the Act of 1961. Such error resulting in

income escaping assessment becomes manifest in the light of

information coming subsequently into the possession of the

Income-tax Officer. Where, as in the present case, the

order making the original assessment was a legally correct

order and was not vitiated by any error, the case would not

be one which would fall within the ambit of section 147(b)

of the Act of 1961 or section 34(1)(b) of the Act of 1922.

We may add that the Income-tax Officer ordering reassess-

ment' does not sit as a court of appeal over the Income-tax

Officer making the original assessment. Nor is it open to

the Income-tax Officer ordering reassessment to substitute

his own opinion regarding the method of computing the income

for that of the Income-tax Officer who made the original

assessment, especially when the method of computation adopt-

ed at the time of original assessment was permissible in

law. The fact that the adoption of a different method of

computation would have resulted 'in higher yield of tax

would not in such a case justify the reopening of the as-

sessment.

It has been argued on behalf of the appellant that

reassessment under section 147(b) would be justified where

in the original assessment income liable to tax has escaped

assessment due to oversight, inadvertence or a mistake

committed by the Income-tax Officer. The present however,

we find, is a case which does not fall in any of those

categories.

We would, therefore, uphold the judgment of the High

Court and dismiss the appeal with costs.

V.P.S. Appeal dis-

missed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/commissioner-of-income-tax-west-bengal-1-calcutta-v-s/