G. Saminathan v. State represented by Sub Inspector of Police
G. Saminathan v. State represented by Sub Inspector of Police
LOK 2026 (7) SC 313
Equivalent citations: 2026 INSC 772 : AIR 2026 SC 3861
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- B.V. Nagarathna & Ujjal Bhuyan; JJ.
- Case No.
- S.L.P (Criminal) No. 10294 of 2025
Provisions referred
- Penal Code (IPC) - Sections 406 (now BNS 316) and 420 (now BNS 318)
Headnote
Criminal Law – Quashing of Proceedings - Contractual Disputes vs. Criminal Liability - Abuse of Process - Mutual Exclusivity of Offences.
The High Court errs in refusing to quash criminal proceedings when the dispute is essentially civil in nature, and the allegations in the FIR and chargesheet do not satisfy the essential ingredients of Sections 406 (now BNS 316) and 420 (now BNS 318) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). A mere breach of contract cannot give rise to criminal prosecution for cheating or criminal breach of trust unless a fraudulent or dishonest intention is proven to exist from the very inception of the transaction. Criminal proceedings cannot be used as a shortcut for civil remedies or to settle scores in a commercial dispute. Initiating such proceedings constitutes an abuse of the process of law, warranting interference under Section 482 (now BNSS 528) of the CrPC. Offences under Section 406 (criminal breach of trust) and Section 420 (now BNS 318) (cheating) IPC are mutually exclusive and cannot be sustained simultaneously on the same set of facts involving the same property.
Full text locked
The full judgment is being updated in the library. Contact the Librarian on WhatsApp for a copy.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/g-saminathan-v-state-represented-by-sub-inspector-of-police/
