Skip to content

Gopalakrishnan v. State of Kerala

Gopalakrishnan v. State of Kerala

LOK Law Journal

LOK 2026 (10) Ker. 234

Equivalent citations: 2026 KER 81212

Court
High Court of Kerala
Bench
A. Badharudeen, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Crl.M.C. No. 8444 of 2022
For petitioner / appellant
Petitioner: Mathew Kuriakose, K.R. Arun, T.G. Sunil (Perumbavoor) and Moni George, Advocates.
For respondent
Respondent: Biju K., Senior Public Prosecutor.

Criminal LawPrevention of Corruption

Tags

WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

Headnote

Criminal Procedure — Section 482 — Quashing — Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 — Sections 13(2) And 13(1)(d) — Forgery Of Service Book And Leave Records By School Clerk — Death Of Audit Witness — Proof Of Documents Through Other Witnesses — Delay In Detection

A school clerk and the Headmistress were charged with converting leave without allowance into leave on medical grounds by forging the service book, leave applications and attendance register, so that the clerk obtained Rs.3,16,068/- in arrears. The clerk sought to quash the case, pleading delay and the death of the witness whose audit verification led to the case.

Held

  1. Where the statements of three former Headmasters prima facie show that the accused clerk forged entries in the service book, leave applications and attendance register to convert leave without allowance on non-medical grounds into leave on medical grounds and so obtained Rs.3,16,068/-, the prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act and the Indian Penal Code cannot be quashed under Section 482 of the Code. (Paras 8–10)
  2. The death of the witness who prepared the audit documents does not make the prosecution meaningless. The documents can be proved through persons who know their contents or who are familiar with the handwriting and signature of the deceased; here the second witness, who took part in the inspection, would suffice to prove the audit report. (Para 11)
  3. Delay in detecting forgery and falsification of records by public servants is no ground to quash the proceedings, since such misappropriation is normally traced only when auditors or other officers verify the registers. (Para 12)
  4. Criminal miscellaneous case dismissed and the interim stay vacated; the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Kollam directed to complete the trial in C.C. No. 8/2025 within three months. (Para 13)

ORDER

A. Badharudeen, J.

Accused No. 1 in C.C. No. 43/2016 on the files of the Enquiry Commissioner & Special Judge, Thiruvananthapuram, now pending as C.C. No. 8/2025 on the files of the Enquiry Commissioner & Special Judge, Kollam has filed this criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 (now BNSS 528) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking the following relief:-

“On these and other grounds to be urged at the time of hearing, it is most humbly prayed that, this Hon’ble Court may be pleased to quash Annexure A Charge Sheet cum Final Report in Crime No. 2/2008/PTA of VACB, Pathanamthitta & Annexure B Court Charge dated 20/09/2022 and further proceedings in C.C. No. 43/2016 on the files of the Court of the Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thiruvananthapuram as against the petitioner/1st Accused.”

2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Public Prosecutor in detail.

3. Here the prosecution alleges commission of offences punishable under Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Sections 468 (now BNS 336), 471 (now BNS 340), 420 (now BNS 318), 477(A) (now BNS 343) and 120(B) (now BNS 60) of the Indian Penal Code, by accused Nos. 1 and 2.

4. The specific allegation of the prosecution is that first accused while working as a Clerk of P.G.M. High School for Boys, Parakkodu, from 03.06.1998 to 30.09.2003 and the second accused while working as the Headmistress of the same school from 01-04-1996 to 31-03-1999 and as such being public servants entered into criminal conspiracy and in pursuance of that, the second accused sanctioned 27 spells of leave without allowance (LWA), without medical certificate as LWA on medical ground, to the first accused, from 08-07-1993 to 10-03-1993 and the first accused converted 8 spells of LWA for personal affairs from 09-11- 1989 to 10-03-1993 to LWA on medical ground by making alterations in the sanctioned leave applications, service book and making forged entries in the attendance register and on the basis of that the accused persons by abusing their official position as public servants and by corrupt and illegal means, obtained pecuniary advantage of Rs. 3,16,068/- and thereby committed the above offences.

5. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner/first accused, the prosecution against the petitioner/first accused is not sustainable, as nothing could be gathered from the prosecution records to show his involvement in the commission of the alleged offences. According to him, in Paragraph No. 4 of the petition, he has raised a specific contention that he had retired from service on superannuation on 30.09.2003. The crime was registered on 23.01.2008. However, Annexure A chargesheet was filed only on 09.05.2011 and the Special Court framed charge only on 20.09.2022. In the meanwhile the CW1, V.N. Vishwambharan Nair died two years back. It is based on the verification of records allegedly done by CW1 V.N. Vishwambharan Nair, the crime was happened to be registered against him and the 2nd accused. Vishwambharan was in inimical terms with CW7, M.R. Rajagopalan Nair, who was the Headmaster of the school from 01.04.1999 till 31.05.2003, pursuant to an alleged incident of Rajagopalan Nair assaulting the son of Vishwambharan, who was studying in the very same school. The actions from the side of Vishwambharan and his team were with the intention of harassing Rajagopalan Nair by making hindrance in getting his service benefits and retirement benefits; and in that attempt he and the 2nd accused were infact made scape goats. Now due to the inordinate delay occasioned in the proceedings pursuant to Annexure A final report and due to the death of Vishwambharan in the meanwhile, he had lost the opportunity to cross examine the said crucial witness and to elicit the truth before the court. In that view of matter, the petitioner is highly prejudiced and aggrieved by the delay occasioned in the proceedings and on that ground itself the proceedings are liable to be quashed.

6. According to him, as of now witness No. 1, who prepared the report and find the anomaly, is no more. It is also submitted that the petitioner is now aged 79 years and the crime was registered at a much belated stage after the retirement of the petitioner in the year 2003. Therefore, he pressed for the prayers sought for in the petition.

7. Whereas the learned Public Prosecutor strongly opposed the contentions and submitted that in the instant case, the offences alleged against accused Nos. 1 and 2 could be found prima facie from the materials available. In this connection, he has placed a report filed by the Investigating Officer, with reference to Paragraph Nos. 6 to 11.

“6. Investigation revealed that Al (petitioner herein) had obtained undue and illegal pecuniary advantage of Rs 3,16,068/- by accounting the leaves that he had availed as leave without allowance without any medical certificate as leave without allowance on medical grounds, thereby counting it for calculation of continuous service and monetary benefits. CW3, CW4 and CW5 who were Headmasters during various periods spanning the employment of A1 at the school have all pointed out the alterations and forgery committed by him in the service book and leave applications. CW 3, Santhakumari, former Headmistress has deposed that five spells of leave out of six spells availed by A1 (petitioner herein) during her period were taken without medical certificate and that the leave entries in the service book and leave applications were forged later to show that the leaves were applied and taken on medical ground. CW4, P.V Varghese, former Head Master has deposed that, A1 (petitioner herein) had availed 5 spells of leave during his period, out of which 4 spells of leave were approved on leave without pay and allowances on the ground of personnel affairs, but entries in the service book and leave applications were forged later and that alterations were made by Al in his own handwriting. CW4 has recognized the handwriting of A1 in the forged entries. CW5, N Gopalan Nair, former Head Master has deposed that during his period Al (petitioner herein), was absent from duty for a long period of time and that he had made “red line markings” on the attendance book for that period of absence and that red line markings were forged later and signed or leaves marked by A1. CW5 has also recognized the handwriting of A1 in the forged documents.

7. Since investigation of the case established that the accused persons had committed the offences alleged against them and chargesheet was laid before the Hon’ble Court of Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge, Thiruvananthapuram to prosecute the accused for the offences of 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of PC Act-1988 and 120(b), 420,468,471,477(A) of IPC. The charge sheet was admitted to the Court records as CC 43/2016.

8. It may kindly be noted that an audit was conducted by the concerned department and a Preliminary Enquiry was conducted by the Vigilance and Anti corruption Bureau before registering the Vigilance case. Officers of the Education department as well as staff of the school and former Headmasters of PGM Boys High School, who had sanctioned the leave without allowances to A1 were all examined as part of the investigation. Hence it can be seen that the contention that the investigation is conducted improperly and illegally is only for the sake of argument and not based on the slightest bit of truth.

9. Investigation of the case has irrefutably revealed that it was the petitioner herein who had derived undue and illegal pecuniary advantage of RS.3,16,068/-by way of wrongfully deriving arrear pay and allowances by counting periods of leave, which is not eligible for being counted for calculating service benefits. It is evident that the Government has lost an amount of Rs. 3,16,068/- due to the act of the accused persons. By alleging foul play and attributing the reason of his being charged with misappropriation of Government money to rivalry between officers, the petitioner is trying to raise a flimsy allegation with the hope of putting an iota of doubt in the mind of the Hon’ble Court.

10. The petitioner alleges that he has lost the opportunity to cross examine CW1, V.N Viswambharan who is a crucial witness, since the said witness had passed away. Eventhough W1 had passed away the audit notes written by W1 had been seized as part of investigation and presented before the trial court. Moreover, W1 did not work in isolation during audit. The audit was conducted by a team headed by W2. W1 only conducted an indepth inspection as follow up and assisted W2 as W2 had found major discrepancies relating to the sanctioning of salary arrears to A1 (petitioner herein) during the preliminary audit. The petitioner has the opportunity to cross examine W2 and elicit whatever truth he desires to elicit during trial.

11. Further, it is pertinent to note that Smt. Radhamoni who was the Headmistress during the period of commission of the offence is also an accused in the case. A2, Smt. Radhamoni was the Headmistress of PGM Boys High school from 01.04.1996 to 31.03.1999. The petitioner had availed leave without allowance on 27 occasions during the period from 08-07-1993 to 03-07-1997. During the tenure of A2, he had availed leave for 7 spells only. A perusal of the service book of the petitioner would reveal that all the 27 leave applications have been sanctioned by A2 on a single date i.e., on 10.07.1997. A2 has sanctioned leave to the petitioner for the periods during which she was not in charge of the school on 20 occasions. All the above mentioned leaves have been entered in the service book at a single stretch spanning 6 pages. The other occasions on which he had availed LWA have been altered in his service book as leave availed on medical ground by way of forgery. Hence it is evident that he had access to the service book through A2. The attendance registers of PGM Boys High school for the said periods would reveal that the red line marked across the attendance column of the petitioner has been scrapped and attendance and leave have been marked on several occasions. The former Headmasters of the school Smt. Santha Kumari (CW3), P.V Vargheese (CW4) and Sri. Gopalan Nair (CW5) etc. have identified the handwriting of the petitioner in the forged entries. Hence the argument that there is no possibility of the petitioner who was only a clerk, getting access to the service book and other records and that the prosecution did not explain how he got access to those records as alleged is also baseless as the Headmistress had colluded with him in making the manipulations in the concerned registers.”

8. On scrutiny of the materials available on par with the contentions raised, the statement given by CW3, CW4 and CW5, who were the Headmasters of the school during the relevant periods, when the first accused was employed therein, given statement that he had committed forgery in the service book and leave applications with a view to convert, leave without allowance (LWA) on ‘non-medical grounds’ as one on ‘medical grounds’. Apart from that, the statement of CW3 would show that the first accused had availed five spells of leave out of six spells during her period were taken without medical certificate and that the leave entries in the service book and leave applications were forged later to show that the leave applications put up in this regard were granted on medical ground. CW4, P.V. Varghese, former Headmaster has given statement that, the first accused had availed 5 spells of leave during his period, out of which 4 spells of leave were approved on leave without pay and allowances on the ground of personnel affairs, but entries in the service book and leave applications were forged later and that alterations were made by the first accused in his own handwriting. CW4 has recognized the handwriting of the first accused in the forged entries. According to CW5, N. Gopalan Nair, former Headmaster, during his period the first accused, was absent from duty for a long period of time and that he had made “red line markings” on the attendance book for that period of absence and that red line markings were forged later and signed or leave marked by the first accused. CW5 has also identified the handwriting of the first accused in the forged documents.

9. Thus this is a case wherein, witness statements and the prosecution materials available would prima facie, show forgery and falsification of records with intention to cheat and defraud and also to misappropriate public money by the petitioner which, in fact, not entitled by him. It is relevant to note that an audit was conducted by the concerned department and a Preliminary Enquiry was conducted by the Vigilance and Anti corruption Bureau before registering the Vigilance case. Officers of the Education department as well as staff of the school and former Headmasters of PGM Boys High School, who had sanctioned the leave without allowances to the petitioner were questioned as part of the investigation and their statements got recorded.

10. That this is a case wherein the prosecution materials in abundance would show obtainment of Rs.3,16,068/- is illegal pecuniary advantage by the first accused with the aid of the second accused, who was the Headmistress by the converting normal LWAs into LWAs on medical grounds, in fact, LWAs on medical grounds for such a long period, even otherwise, could not be availed.

11. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner since the first witness, V.N. Vishwambharan had passed away, the prosecution would be meaningless. This argument appears to be so childish and without reasoning. When a material witness, who prepared documents dies, then also the documents can be tendered in evidence by the examining the persons, who otherwise had knowledge regarding the contents of documents or through a person, who is having familiarity with the handwriting and signature of the deceased person, as an alternative mode of proof. In the instant case, witness No. 2 also participated in the in-depth inspection and assisted the witness No. 1 and therefore, the evidence of witness No. 2 would suffice the requirement of proof of the audit report against the petitioner.

12. Another argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that this crime was detected at a belated stage. It is true that persons bonafidely employed as government servants bestowed with duties to serve the public, when engage in misappropriation by falsifying and forging records, the said forgery and falsification could not be normally found easily, particularly, in a school, where the clerical staff may be one or two. Therefore, only when an opportunity would be available for the competent officers of the Audit Department or other officials to verify the relevant registers and documents to find out any irregularities, illegalities or malpractices and misappropriation, the same could be able to be traced out. In the instant case, this really is the reason for the delay in tracing out the misappropriation and the petitioner would not get the benefit out of it, on any grounds. This is a case where a person who availed LWA for a period of eight years, for which he did not get any service benefit, viz., either salary, allowances or the same could not be calculated for the qualifying service for pension and DCRG, by falsifying and forging records, not only obtained Rs.3,16,068/- and more towards pensionary benefits as could be seen from the copy of the writ petition judgment filed by him along with this Crl.M.C. Thus, it is noticeable that, in this case, after considering the various aspects involved herein, the learned Special Judge framed charge for the offences alleged as early on 20.09.2022 and at the verge of trial, this Crl.M.C. has been filed on 21.11.2022 and proceedings got stayed. Since the prosecution records would clearly show that the petitioner/first accused committed the offences prima facie, the matter to be tried based on the charge already framed. Thus the prayers in the petition to quash the proceedings found to be not allowable.

13. In the result, this Crl.M.C. is dismissed and the interim stay granted stands vacated. Since the case is of the year 2016, the learned Enquiry Commissioner & Special Judge, Kollam, where now this matter has been pending as C.C. No. 8/2025 is directed to expedite the trial and finish the same, within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

The Registry is directed to forward a copy of this order to the learned Special Judge concerned, for information and compliance forthwith.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/gopalakrishnan-v-state-of-kerala-2026/