Jagat Singh v. Karan Singh and Rs
Jagat Singh v. Karan Singh and Rs
LOK 1987 (3) SC 244
Equivalent citations: AIR 1987 SC 1279 : 1987 (1) CCC 963 : 1987 (2) JT 31 : 1987 (1) Scale 580 : 1987 (2) SCC 349 : 1987 (2) SCR 616 : 1987 (2) UJ 39 : 1987 SCC (2) 349 JT 1987 (2) 31
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- M.P. Thakkar, J.; B.C. Ray, J.
- Case No.
- Civil Appeal No. 1403(N) of 1973
- For petitioner / appellant
- S .N. Singh and T.N. Singh, for the Appellant.
- For respondent
- Rameshwar Nath and Ravinder Nath, for the Respondents.
Judgment
,
THAKKAR, J. The controversy in this appeal centers around the interpretation of Section 6(4) of the Tehri Garhwal Buhmi Sambandhi Adhikar Niyam, enacted by the erst-while State of Tehri Garhwal which continued to remain in force even after its merger in the State of Uttar Pradesh.
The trial court came to the conclusion that the peti-tioner was entitled to become the 'kahikari' (subtenant) of the respondents who were 'maurusidars' (head tenants) of the land in question by virtue by the said provision and decreed the plaintiff's suit. The lower appellate court and the High Court took a contrary view and dismissed the suit. The original plaintiff has preferred the present appeal by special leave and has contended that the interpretation placed by the trial court was the correct interpretation of the relevant provision and that the Lower Appellate Court and the High Court were in error in taking the contrary view.
The facts in so far as material are not in dispute. All the Courts have concurred in the finding that the petitioner was a 'sapinda' of Jeet Ram, the original 'khaikari' (sub-tenant) who died issueless. From the age of about 12 or 13 years the appellant had started living with deceased Jeet Ram. He was sharing food and shelter with Jeet Ram and was engaged in cultivating the land in question along with Jeet Ram during his life time. He had lived as a member of Jeet Ram's family and at the time of the death of Jeet Ram the obsequies were performed by him. Thereafter he was looking after the widow of Jeet Ram.
These facts having been firmly established the trial court upheld the appellant's right to become 'khaikari' (sub-tenant) of the respondents in respect of the land in question in the context of the right conferred by Section 6(4) of the Act. The said provision is in Hindi:
"MRIT KHIAKAR KAR BHAI YA SAPINDA WARISH
(BHAI, BHATEEJA AADI) KEWAL US DASHA MEN
ADHIKARI HOGA JOB KI WAH US MIRT KHAIKAR KE
SATH JEEVIT SAMAY MEN ABIBHAKT KUL KI REETI SE
USKE SHAREEK RAHA HO."
Translated in English, it reads as under:-
"Brother or Sapinda (brother, newhew etc.) of
the deceased sub-tenant will be entitled if he
was jointly living with the deceased during
his life time in the manner of a joint
family."
An analysis of the aforesaid provision reveals that in order to establish the claim to be recognized as a 'khaikari' under the said provision, one must establish that:-
(1) He is a 'sapinda' of the deceased sub-
tenant such as the brother or nephew.
(2) He must have been living as a member of
the family with the deceased during his life-
time in the manner of a member of the joint
family.
The Trial Court took the view that inasmuch as the petitioner was admittedly a sapinda of deceased Jeet Ram and inasmuch as he had been living jointly with the deceased during his life-time, had been sharing of food and shelter with him and had even performed the obsequies of Jeet Ram, he fulfilled the conditions prescribed by the said provision and was entitled to become a sub-tenant of the head tenant. The Lower Appellate Court and the High Court have taken the view that it is not suffi-cient for the appellant to have shared the food and shelter and carried on the agricultural operations with the de-ceased. It must be shown that he was in fact a member of the joint family. The High Court has made sought support from the reasoning that section 6(4) is applicable not only to Hindus but also to Muslims and Christians. With respect to the High Court this assumption is altogether unwarranted. The expression 'sapinda' employed in section 6(4) is a clear pointer to the conclusion that the said section is designed to apply only to Hindus. The expression 'sapinda' is pecul-iar to traditional Hindu Law and it would be altogether inapposite in the context of citizens of Muslim or Christian faith. Failure to realize this aspect impelled the High Court to take a view contrary to the view taken by the trial court as is evident from the following passage:
"As the provisions of section 6 (4) of the
Tehri Garhwal Bhumi Sambandhi Adhikar Niyam
are applicable not only to Hindus but also to
Muslims and Christians etc. who may be living
in Tehri Garhwal, the words "Joint Hindu
Family" were not used and instead the words
"ABHI BHAKT KUL KEE REETI SE USKE SAATH
SHAREEK RAHA HO" were used. These words when
applicable to a Hindu must mean a person who
was a member of a Joint Hindu Family of the
deceased Khaikar in this case Jeet Ram."
It appears that the Lower Appellate Court and
the High Court altogether missed to grasp the
intendment and purpose of the provision. In
the absence of such a provision an issueless
tiller would experience great hardship for
there would be nobody to assist him in his
work in his lifetime, look after him in his
old age, and to take care of his widow after
his death. That is why even if a separated
brother or nephew were to live with him during
his life-time, share the food and shelter with
him, and assist him in cultivation, just as a
member of the Undivided Hindu Family would be
expected to do, the benefit of becoming a
sub-tenant is made available to him. Otherwise
there was no point in providing that unless a
'sapinda' lived with him 'as if he was a
member of the joint family' he would not be
entitled to such a right. In fact the provi-
sion has evidently been enacted with a view to
relieve the distress of an issueless agricul-
turist, who is separate from his joint
family, so that any one of his sapindas living
with him as a member of the family, assisting
him in agriculture, and looking after him,
would be entitled to become a 'khaikar' on his
demise. The expression 'JEEVIT SAMAY, MEN
ABIBHAKT KUL KI REETI SE USKE SHAREEK RAHA HO'
clearly provides a clue to the intention of
the legislature to benefit such a person who
has lived with the issueless khaikar and
shared with him food, shelter, labour, as also
joys and sorrows along with him 'as if' he was
a member of the joint family without in fact
being one. The prospect of acquiring such a
right would provide motivation to look after
and render services to the issueless land
holder for it would be unreasonable to expect
him to do so selflessly, the world being what
it is.
We are therefore of the opinion that the
lower appellate court and the High Court have
entirely misunderstood the provision in hold-
ing that only a member of an Undivided
Family could claim the benefit of section
6(4). If such were the case there was no need
to make such an elaborate provision. It would
have been sufficient to say that a member of
his joint family alone could claim such a
right.
We are satisfied that the trial court was
right in upholding the claim of the appellant
whereas the lower appellate court and the High
Court were in error in taking a contrary view.
The appeal is, therefore, allowed. The judg-
ment and order of the lower appellate court
and the High Court are set aside. The judgment
and decree passed by the trial court are
restored.
There will be no order regarding costs.
P.S.S.
Appeal allowed.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/jagat-singh-v-karan-singh-and-rs/
