Jagjit Cotton Textile Mills v. Chief Commercial Superintendent N.R. & Others
Jagjit Cotton Textile Mills v. Chief Commercial Superintendent N.R. & Others
LOK 1998 (4) SC 217
Equivalent citations: 1998 (3) JT 297 : 1998 (3) Scale 209 : 1998 (4) SLT 608 : 1998 (4) Supreme 234 : 1998 (5) SCC 126 : AIR 1998 SC 1959 : 1998 AllLJ 1314
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- S.B. Majmudar, M. Jagannadha Rao, J.*
- Case No.
- Nos.7197, 7206, 7200-04, 7198-99, 7207-10, 7190- /93, CA Nos7514/95, 4266/96, T.C. (c) Nos.15-48, 48A-147/97, 1 & 2/98 & C.A. No. 2164 /98 @ S.L.P. (c) No. 7766/94 J U D G M E N T
Provisions referred
- Section 53, Indian Railways Act, 1890
- Article 14, Constitution of India
Cases referred 3
- Stone Co. v. M/S Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Co. Ltd. & Another LOK 1968 (7) SC 155 : AIR 1969 SC 193 Referred (Para 1)
- Ltd. v. Ashoke Silicate & Glass Works Referred (Para 1)
- Darshan Kumar v. Station Master Referred (Para 1)
Judgment
Leave granted in S.L.P (C) No.7766 of 1994.
These Civil Appeals and Transferred Cases raise common questions and can be disposed of together. The Civil Appeals rise out of judgments of the High Court of Allahabad and Rajasthan High Court. The transferred cases arise from the Delhi High Court and from Railway Claim Tribunal (Lucknow Bench). Counsel have referred to the documents contained in T.C. No.47 of 197 (Eastern coalfield Ltd. vs. Ashoke Silicate & Glass Works, Delhi ) for convenience, apart from the pleadings and documents in the other paper books. T.C. No 47 of 1997, referred to above, is a case filed as C.W.P. No.864 of 1985 in the Delhi High Court and transferred to this Court by virtue of orders in T.P.(c) No.713. of 1995. On transfer it was numbered in this Court as T.C. No. 47 of 1997.
The broad facts in all the cases are similar. The appellants/petitioners are all consignees of coal from the collieries. The issue relates to the right of the Railways to recover 'penal charges' relating to overloading of coal in goods wagons beyond the permissible carrying capacity' of each wagon, from the consignees. While the Railways claim that the said charges can be recovered from the appellants-consignees, the appellants, on the other hand, contend that the Railways ought not to have permitted overloading or, coal at the collieries railway-siding and that the consignor collieries and therefore the consignees cannot be made to pay these 'penal charges'. The petitioners/appellants not only seek refund of penal charges paid but a direction that in future, the Railways should be directed not to collect the same from the consignees.
The broad facts of the case can be gathered from the Delhi case T.C. No. 47 of 1997. The paper book in this case contains exhaustive pleadings and documents. The T. C. was initially filed as a writ petition in the Delhi High Court. The writ petitioner, Ashoka Silicate & Glass Works, Delhi is a consignee of coal. It obtained a letter of identification or sponsorship from the Commissioner of Food & supply, Delhi recommending the allotment of a particular quantity of coal year after year as per the petitioner's requirements. Thereafter the petitioner completed 'financial arrangements' through its agent M/S Ramsaran Das & Bros, who have their office in New Delhi. The said agent obtained a Form, which is basically a form for approval of the sponsored quantity of coal wither for every month in the year or for a particular month. The said programme was then submitted to the Collieries ( The Eastern Coalfields Ltd. which is a subsidiary of Coal India Ltd.) for their approval so that the Colliery could agree to supply accordingly. After receiving the approval from the Collieries, the said programme was submitted to the Director of Movements(Railway) who works under the Railway Board so that the requisite number of wagons could be allocated for supply of coal by the Collieries to the petitioner. Once the Programme is approved as above, the wagons would be brought and kept at the private railway siding of the Collieries for loading the coal. After the completion of loading, a forwarding note would be prepared by the Colliery. the wagons would be earmarked for different consignees and they move from the colliery to a focal point or booking point where the weigh bridge of the Collieries or Railways is located. The wagons constitute a 'rake' at the focal point and then each wagon would pass across the weigh bridge and the weight of the wagon loaded with coal would be verified and noted in the forwarding note and in the railway receipt. The Railways Act, 1890 and the Railways Act, 1989 contain provisions which require that the "average carrying capacity" of each wagon be marked on the wagon. Section 53 of the old Act refers to (i) the maximum carrying capacity, (ii) normal carrying capacity(and its variations ) and (iii) Rule 161A of the IRCA refers to the permissible carrying capacity. As of now, weight upto and excess of 2 tonnes (previously it was 1 tonne) – over and above the permissible carrying capacity of each wagon – is not subject to any penal charge. But beyond that, penal charges are levied and collected at the time of delivery of the coal from the consignee, or else the goods will not be released.
Invariably, the consignees in all the cases before us have obtained delivery of the coal including the coal which is in excess of the permissible carrying capacity of the wagon and have paid – apart from the normal rate for carriage- the penal charges also. In none of the cases before us has the consignee – who had the choice of rejecting the overloaded coal at the destination point – rejected the excess coal so overloaded while taking at the destination point.
The cases before us cover two periods, namely where the penal charges were levied and collected by the Railways when the Railways Act, 1890 was in force (upto 30.61990 ) and again where such charges were levied and collected after the Railways Act, 1989 came into force, i.e from 1.7.1990. There are certain difference in the respective provisions applicable under the old Act and the new Act which have been placed before us and we shall refer to them at an appropriate stage.
It is contended for the consignees – as revealed, from the Judgments of the Allahabad High Court in appeal that the relevant Rule 161A or the IRCA (Indian Railway Conference Association) in force during the period of the old Act of 1890 is consistent with section 53 of the old Act and hence liable to be declared void. It is in addition contended in this Court that Rule 161A is ultra-vires of the old Act inasmuch as under the old act, there is no provision corresponding to section 73 of the New Act, which permits such penal charges to be leied and collected for overloading, – from the consignor, consignee or endorsee, as the case may be. It is also contended that Rule 6 and 29 of the Special Tariff for Coal in the Eastern Railway permit only ordinary rate of tariff to be levied and hence Rule 161a is implitly excluded. Reliance is also placed on clause 187 of the Manual to infer that the liability for the penal charges is only on the consignor. Yet another contention based before us is that Rule 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Association and Section 73 of the new Act, in so far as they permit recovery of the penal charges from the consignee – who it is said is not a 'delinquent' – are arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The submission is that for no fault of the consignee, Rule 161A of the Indian Railways Conference Association and section 73 of the new Act permit recovery of penal charges from consignee, and therefore they are arbitrary and violative of Article 14. It is also contended for the appellant that the title to the goods has not passed to the consignee at the time when the colliery overloaded the goods into the wagons. The contract between the colliery and the consignee, no doubt, was 'F . O. R. – Railway Siding' but it is contended that inasmuch as title passed only after the overloading, and after Railway receipt is prepared later, the consignor alone is the 'delinquent' and is responsible to pay the penal charges. The consignee, it is said, has no choice except to take delivery of the overloaded goods. The consignee also contend that apart from directing refund of penal charges already collected, there should be a direction that in future the same should not be collected from the consignees.
On the other hand, it is contended for the Railways that the petitioners must go for a civil suit as held by the J & K High Court in Darshan Kumar vs. Station Master [AIR 1988 J & K p.74]. It is contended that these charges are compensatory charges though they are called 'penal' and that it is not necessary that there should be mens rea. Rule 161A of the Indian Railways Conference Association is not inconsistent with section 53 of the old Act. It is contended that the said Rule was issued by the Railway Board under the power delegated to it by notification issued by the Central Government on 24.3.1905 and 8.10.69(respectively with regard to power under section 54 and section 29) and that the letter dt. 7.5.1981 (Annexure-Q in TC No.47/97) shows that the Railway Board validity issued Rule 161A in Part (vol.1) of the Indian Railway Conference Association and that the said Rule is protected by sections 54(1) and 29(1) of the old Act. It is also contended that the Railways are entitled to Collect the penal charges from the consignee under Rule 161A inasmuch as in the second part of Rule 161A, there is no restriction as to the party from whom the penal charges are to be collected. So far as the new Act of 199 is concerned, it is contended that section 73 specifically permits the levy and collection of penal charge from the consignor, consignee or endorsee, as the case may be. In other words Rule 161A of the Indian Railway conference Association is now replaced by a statutory provision in the new Act. It is pointed out that the penal charges are not by way of penalty but are charges leved to compensate the Railways for the deterioration or damages done to the rails, bridges, wagons and the engines which are made to carry extra load over and above the permissible carrying capacity, consequent to the overloading. The penal charges are payable by the consignee, inasmuch as the consignee has taken delivery of the overloaded goods and benefited by using the same in its consumption processes. It does not lie in the mouth of such a person who is beneficiary of the overloading, to contend that it is liable only for the normal charges and not for the penal charges. Again under section 55 of the old Act and section 83 of the new Act, there is a lien in favour of the Railways which extends to the collection of the penal charges. It is also to be presumed that the consignee has passed on the burden to its consumers. (Mr . B. Sen, learned senior counsel, appearing in CA No. 7514 of 1995 arising from the Judgment of the Rajasthan High Court, however, contended that cement is a controlled commodity so as price is concerned and his clients could not have passed on the extra burden to consumers, similar argument was raised in C.A. No. 4266 of 1996).
In the above contentions, the following points arise for consideration:
(1) What is the distinction between the words 'maximum carrying capacity' used in section 53(1) of old Act (section 72(1) of new Act), 'normal carrying capacity used in section 53(2) (section 72(2) of new Act' and 'permissible carrying capacity' used in Rule 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Associationt (section 73 of the new Act)? (2) Whether Rule, 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Association is inconsistent with section 53 of the old Act? (3) Whether Rule 161A is ultra-vires of the Railways Act , 1890?
(4) Do Rules 6, 29 of Eastern Railways Coal Tariff confer any right on the consignees which excludes or overrides Rule 161A?
(5) Are the charges levied under Rule 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Association or under section 73 of the new Railways Act, 1989 (read with Railway (punitive charges for overloading of Wagons ) Rules, 1990 penal in nature or are also compensatory? Are they arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as they permit the Railways to recover the penal charges from the consignees who, according to the appellants/petitioners, are not responsible for the overloading of the coal beyond the permissible limits in the wagons at the colliery siding and are not 'delinquents'?
(6) What is the effect of delivery of the Railway Receipt to the consignee under the Railways Act, 1890 and the Railways Act, 1989 and does it have the effect of transferring all the cosignee, including the liability to pay penal charges at the time of delivery of the overloaded goods to the consignee?
(7) In any event, does the Railways not have a lien for collection of the penal charges from the consignee because of section 55 of the Railways Act, 1890 or section 83 of the Railways Act, 1989?
(8) Can the consignees (except the appellant in CA No. 7514 of 1995 and CA No. 4266 of 1996) seek refund from the Railways without pleading and proving that they have not passed on the burden of the penal charges to their consumers?
(9) Are the consignees entitled to any direction that the Railways should not, in future, collect these penal charges from the consignees?
Point 1:
At the outset, it is necessary to understand the distinction between the words 'maximum carrying capacity', 'normal carrying capacity' and 'permissible carrying capacity' used in various provisions. The penal charges under Rule 161A and section 73 of the new Act are leviable only for exceeding the 'permissible carrying capacity'.
Now Rule 161A which deals with overloading of coal was introduced w.e.f. 7.5.1981 and is contained in IRCA (Indian Railway Conference Association) Goods Tariff. The said rule was in force till the new Rules called "The Railways (Punitive charges for overloading of wagons) Rules, 1990 were framed under section 87 of the new Act (published in Gazette on 7.6.1990). Since 1981, Rule 161A has undergone minor changes concerning the extent to which extra-free-load is permissible etc. For the purposes of the point involved, these minor variations are not relevant and it is sufficient to refer to the Rule 161 A as it was originally introduced in 1981. It reads as follows:
"Rule 161 A: Penalty for loading
coal beyond permissible carrying
capacity of the wagons:
(1) In loading coal, consignors are
required not to exceed the
permissible carrying capacity of
the wagon used or any reduced
carrying capacity that may be
required in the circumstances
referred to in Rule 163. Should
overweight be discovered at the
booking point or en-route or at
destination, such overweight beyond
permissible carrying capacity of
the wagon used will,
notwithstanding anything contained
in this Tariff or in any other
Rules or instruction, be charged at
the normal wagon load rate if the
overweight is more than one tonne
and at smalls rate applicable to
coal traffic, if the overweight is
m ore than one tonne, for the
entire distance from the booking
point to the destination .
(2) The Railway Administration may
issue separate instructions in
regard to limits of weight beyond
which over-loaded wagons could not
be carried. Such instructions may
also specify the charges, penalties
and other consequences that would
ensue from loading beyond such
limits" .
Rule 161A(1) is, it will be noticed in two parts. The first part deals with the prohibition while the second part concerns the levy and collection of penal charges and does not specifically say from whom. The Rule uses the word 'permissible carrying capacity'.
We shall next refer to Section 53. It reads as follows:-
"Section 53: Maximum carrying
capacity for wagons: (1) The gross
weight of every wagon or truck
bearing on the axles when the wagon
or truck is loaded to its maximum
carrying capacity shall not exceed
such limit as m ay be fixed by the
Central Government for the class of
axle under the wagon or truck.
(2) Subject to the limit fixed
under sub-section (1), every
railway administration shall
determine the normal carrying
capacity for every wagon or truck
in its possession and shall exhibit
the words and figures representing
the normal carrying capacity so
determined in a conspicuous manner
on the outside of every such wagon
or truck.
(3)…………………………..
…………………….
(4) Notwithstanding anything
contained in sub-section (2) or
sub-section (3), where a railway
administration thinks it necessary
or expedient so to do in respect of
any wagon or truck carrying any
specified class of goods or any
class of wagons or trucks of any
specified type, it may, by
notification, vary the normal
carrying capacity for such wagon or
truck or such class of wagons or
trucks and, subject to such
conditions as it may think fit to
impose, determine for the same such
carrying capacity as may be
specified in the notification and
it shall not be necessary to
exhibit the words and figures
representing the carrying capacity
so determined on the outside of
such wagon or truck or such class
of wagons or trucks:
Provided that in no case the
gross weight of such wagon or truck
or such class of wagons or trucks
shall exceed the limit fixed under
sub-section (1) for the class of
axle under the wagon or truck."
The section uses the words 'maximum carrying capacity' , 'normal carrying capacity' and variation of normal carrying capacity. (The corresponding section under the new Act, 1989 is Section 72).
The above provisions of old section 53 were the result of the Railways (Amendment) Act, 1954 (Act 22 of 1954). The purpose of this section is made clear in the statement of object and Reasons of the amending Bill which preceded the said amending Act of 1954. It reads as follows:
"With view to secure better
utilisation of the available wagon
space, railways allow within the
limit of safety, loading of certain
classes of goods somewhat in excess
of the marked carrying capacity of
the wagons. Although such enhanced
carrying capacity is not exhibited
on the outside of the wagon
required by sub-section (1) of
Section 53 of the Indian Railways
Act, 1890, railways notify it
through circulars for the guidance
of the public. Freight charges are
also collected in such cases on the
increased artying capacity so
permitted.
As however, this practice is not
strictly in conformity with the
irovisions of section 53 of the
Indian Railways Act, 1890, the
present Bill seeks to amend this
section suitably to permit loading
wagons (when occasion so requires)
beyond the marked carrying capacity
without exhibiting the enhanced
capacity on the outside of the
wagons".
The variation of the normal carrying capacity as permitted by Section 53(4) are however subject to the proviso at the end of the sub-section which says that in no case shall he gross weight of such wagon or truck exceed the limit fixed under Section 53(1) for the class of axle under the wagon or truck. For example, excess upto 1 tonne over an d above the normal capacity was permitted without extra charge initially and now the said limit is raised to 2 tonnes.
Thus, it is to be noticed that while Section 53(1) of the old Act (Section 72(1) of the new Act) uses the words 'maximum carrying capacity', and Section 53 (2) of the old Act (section 72 (2) of the new Act) uses the words 'normal carrying capacity', Rule 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Association an Section 73 of the new Act (which empowers levy capacity'.
New inasmuch as penal charges under Rule 161A (or under Section 73 of the new Act) are leviable only for exceding the "permissible carrying capacity", it is, therefore, necessary to understand the significance of these words. That, to a large extent, is explained by the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the 1954 Amendment of the old act set out above. Section 16 if the old act(and Section 27 of the new Act) deals with the u of rolling stock. What design or type of rolling ck is to be used is to be decided by the Central Government, Ministry of Railways ( Railway Board), in consultation with its Research and Design Organisation. The maximum gross-weight bearing on the axles is determined by the Commissioner of Railway safety, when granting permission under section 16 of the old Act (Section 27 of the new Act). The Railways submit to the Commissioner the complete design particulars indicating the 'gross weight' and the 'gross weight bearing on each axle'. The 'gross weight', for which sanction is given by the Commissioner of Railway safety on behalf of the Central Government is the maximum and can in no cases be exceeded by any executive order of the Railway Board, without reference to the Commissioner. On the other hand, the 'normal' or 'marked' carrying capacity determined by the railway Administration under Section 53(2) is subject to the maximum referred to in Section 53(1). The normal carrying capacity specified in Section 53(2) can be varied by the railway administration in exercise of powers granted under Section 53(4) (inserted by the 1954 Amendment) but subject again to the maximum limited by section 53(1) as stated in the proviso below section 53(4). Any variation of the normal capacity as permitted by section 53(4) is "subject to such conditions as it (the Central Government) may think fit to impose" and even these conditions cannot override the limits prescribed under Section 53(1). Inasmuch as the enhanced capacity, if any, under Section 53(4) may not possibly be immediately exhibited on the outside of the wagon when occasion arises, it has become necessary to notify it for guidance of the public. Thus it is clear that the 'gross weight' and 'maximum carrying capacity' (Section 53 (1)(section 72(1) of new Act) are laid down by the Commissioner of Railway Safety on behalf of the Govt. of India while the 'normal carrying capacity' (Section 53(2))(section 72(2) of new Act) is marked on the wagons by the railway administration but is always below the limits prescribed in Section 53(1).
So far as the words 'permissible carrying capacity' which occur in Rule 161A of the Indian Railway Conference Association and section 73 of the new Act are concerned, the said words obviously refer the average carrying capacity' mentioned in Section 53(2) (Section 72(2) if new Act) or such enhanced permissible limits of carrying capacity as may be fixed under Section 53(4) of the old Act (or Section 72(4) of the new Act). This view of ours is clearly strengthened by the definition of "permissible carrying capacity" in Rule 2(d) of the 1990 Rules. Rule 2(d) says as follows:
Rule 2(d) 'Permissible carrying
capacity' means the normal carrying
capacity determined under sub-
section (2) or (3) of section 72 or
where a railway administration has
determined a varied carrying
capacity under sub-section (4) of
section 72, such varied carrying
capacity, whichever is higher."
This permissible carrying capacity cannot, as already state, exceed the upper limits prescribed by the Commissioner of Railway Safety under Section 53(1) of the old Act (Section 72(1) of the new Act). (See also Johari's commentary on Railways Act, 1989 (1991 Ed.) pp.124,241,242).
The above meaning of the words will be helpful in understanding the discussion under Points 2 to 8. Point 2:
The first contention for the appellants is that Rule 161A is inconsistent with section 53(1) of the Act. It will be noticed that while section 53(1) prohibits overloading in excess of the maximum carrying capacity, Rule 161A permits loading beyond the permissible carrying capacity and the charging therefore. Obviously the contention is based upon a misconception of equating the permissible carrying capacity with the maximum carrying capacity, which words are distinct and different as explained by us under Point 1. Rule 161A does not enable the consignors, as Wrongly thought by the petitioners, to load the wagon beyond the maximum carrying capacity. The penal charges under Rule 161A are attracted if the weight goes above the permissible carrying capacity which is always under section 53(1). Therefore the contention itself is based on wrong premises. In addition, the High Court of Allahabad has pointed out that Rule 161a is in fact designed to achieve the objects covered by section 53(1) (2) and (4). There are , therefore, unable to find any inconsistency between Rule 161A and section 53 of the old Act. For the aforesaid reasons, this contention is rejected.
Point 3:
The question is whether Rule 161A of the Tariff is ultra-vires of the old Railways Act, 1890, Counsel for the consignees argued that the Rule is traceable to the rule making power under section 47(1)(g) and is limited by the punishment provided in section 47(2) read with section 93 of the old Act. It is argued that section 47(1)(g) enables rules to be made generally "for regulating the travelling upon, and the use, working and management of the railway" and section 47(2) says that breach of rules may be punished by fine not exceeding Rs. 160 and that section 93 states that railway companies, contravening section 53 with regard to 'maximum load' to be carried in any wagon, could be directed to pay Rs.20 for every day of the contravention. Hence it is argued that no penalty under section 161A can be imposed. It is also contended that Rule 161A has not been published in the Gazette as required by section 47(3).
It is, however, contended for the Railways that for purposes of Rule 161A of the IRCA, the rule making power of Section 47(1)(g) is not relevant in this context that Rule 161A is protected by section 29(1) and Section 54(1) of the old Act. We shall therefore, reer to section 29(1) and section 54(1) to find out if this contention of the Railways is well founded. Section 29 reads as follows:
"Section 29: (1) The Central
Government may, be general or
special orders fix maximum and
minimum rates for the whole or any
part of a railway, and prescribe
the conditions in which such rates
will apply.
(2) The Central Government
may, by a later order, fix the
rates of any other charges for the
whole or any part of a railway and
prescribe the conditions on which
such rates of charges shall apply."
Under section 3(13) of the old Act, 'rate' is defined as including "any fare, charge or other payment for the carriage of any passenger, animals or goods." In our view, 'other payment' could be by way of a penal charge as levied by Rule 161A.
Again section 54(1) states that the railway administration may impose conditions not inconsistent with the Act or with any general rules made thereunder, "With respect to the receiving, forwarding or delivery of any animal or goods."
Thus both sections 29(1) and 54(1) in our view protect Rule 161A. But it is argued that Rule 161A is in Part 1(Vol.1) of the IRCA and that it is only Part 1(Vol.2) that is issued under the authority of the Central Government as stated on the cover page of the IRCA Rules. This point requires a deeper investigation.
It is true the cover page of IRCA Rules states that only Rules in Part 1(Vol.2) are issued under the authority of the Central Government and not the rules in Part 1(Vol.1). We, however, find from the letter dated 7.5.1981 (Annexure-Q in T.C. 47/97 of Ashoka Silicate & Glass Works i.e. W.P. No.864 of 1985) that the said Rule 161A was issued by the Railway Board in the Ministry of Railways, Government of India, and communicated to all General Managers in the Railways and all Non-Government Railways(including Port Trust Railways). Question is whether when the Railway Board issued Rule 161A and included the same in IRCA Part 1 (Vol.1), the said rule could be statutory though not issued by the Central Government as in the case of Rules in Part 1 (vol.2)?
In this connection, the notifications of the Central Government delegating its powers under section 54 and section 29 to the Railway Board are important. The Notification of the Government of India (No.14-21, No.81) dated 24.3.1905 (Act IV of 1905) and issued in the name of the Government-General shows that the Railway Board was invested with powers of the Central Government under various sections including section 54 of the old Act. Again Notification (No.TRC/1079/69/11) dated 8.10.69 issued by the Central Government under section 2 of the Indian Railway Board under section 29 of the old Act of 1890 (published in gazette on 18.10.69) of the Central Government.
The effect of the above delegation is that Rule 161A of IRCA Rules, Part 1 (Vol.1) – which is traceable to section 29 or section 54 of the old Act – is clearly issued by the Railway Board as per its letter dated 7.5.1981 in exercise powers delegated to it by the Central Government. In other words, though it may be true from the cover page of IRCA Rules that Part 1(Vol.2) alone is issued under authority of Central Government, it is established that Rule 161A in Part 1(Vol.1) has the authority of the Railway Board, the delegate of the Central Government. Therefore, the contentions of the appellants/petitioners that Rule 161A is traceable to section 47(1)(g), that the rule is not published in the Gazette as required by section 47(4) and that only fine or penalty as stated in section 47(2) or section 93 of the old Act could be imposed, are wholly unsupportable.
We may incidentally point out that in the High Court the question of vires of Rule 161A was not specifically raised and the only point argued was that Rule was inconsistent with section 53. However, as the point has been argued before us, we have considered the same and we find no substance in the point. Point 3 is held against the appellants/petitioners.
Point 4:
To Contend that Rule 161A is excluded by other rules, reliance is placed by the appellants/petitioners on Rules 6 and 29 of Eastern Railway Coal Tariff Part 1, as impliedly excluding Rule 161A. Rule 6 carries the heading 'charges payable in respect of the overloading the excess coal and re-loading the same and the demurrage charges payable therefor. Therefore, it is clear that this rule does not cover penal charges for overloading coal beyond the permissible limits and cannot be said to exclude Rule 161A. Coming to Rule 29, it reads as follows:
"Rule 29: Wagons not be loaded in
excess of maximum weight
prescribed: Consignors in loading
are required not to exceed the
maximum weight prescribed for a
wagon. Should overweight be
ascertained on weighment, the load
will be reduced. In case of
consignments weighed in route, any
overloading, however, detected at
destination is liable in the same
rate as the remainder of the
consignment."
It is true Rule 29 deals with coal but we may point out that Rule 161A also deals exclusively with coal and was specifically introduced to deal with overloading coal beyond the permissible carrying capacity. It will be noticed that Rule 29 deals with loading beyond the maximum weight prescribed by section 53(1) (see discussion in Point 1), while Rule 161A deals with penal charges for loading in excess of the permissible carrying capacity asa stated in section 53 (2) and section 53(4). Rule 29 was introduced to clarify that for carriage of the excess coal the rate to be charged is the normal rate. The Rule was not intended to deal with the penal charge. Finally, one more strong reason against the petitioner's contention is that Rule 161A contains a non-obstante clause. The non-obstante clause in Rule 161A reads as follows:
"notwithstanding anything contained
in this Tariff or in any other Rule
or instructions"
Therefore, the said clause would, in any event, override Rules 6 and 29 of the Eastern Railway Coal Tariff, Part I, even if they are to cover the same field. for all the above reasons, we hold on Point 4 that Rule 161A is neither excluded by Rule 6 nor by Rule 29 of the Eastern Railway Coal Tariff.
Points 5 and 6:
These two points are more substantial. Elaborate submissions were made buy counsel on both sides on them.
We have already set out the facts showing the manner in which, according to the consignees, the goods are loaded at the Collieries siding, weighed thereafter when the train passes over the weigh bridges and how the railway receipt is latter issued. Counsel on both sides concentrated on the question as to whether title to goods passed to the consignee before the goods were loaded or whether title did not pass till the railway receipt was issued after the overloading and detection of extra load. This was done to find who was at fault at the time of overloading.
An endeavour was made by the learned counsel for the Railways, on the basis of the judgment of this court is Kuchwar Lime and Stone Co. Vs. M/S Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Co. Ltd. & Another [ AIR 1969 SC 193] to contend that the title in the goods passed to the consignee the moment allotment orders were passed by the Coal Commissioner under Colliery Control Order, 1945 and it was contended, as stated in that decision, that the Colliery when it loaded the goods in the wagons acted as the 'agent' of the consignee. It was argued for the Railways, that if at the time of overloading the title had passed and the colliery was only the agent of the consignee, then the Railway could recover the penal charges from the consignee. This argument could not, if any, however, be pursued further because, during the relevant time when the goods in question before us were loaded, the Coal Commissioner was not in the picture so far as certain types of coal were concerned and, the collieries and the consignees were dealing with each other as principals i.e. as sellers and buyers. This clear from the subsequent notifications under the Coal Control Order, 1945 set out in the recent judgment of this Court in Coal India Ltd. & another vs. Continental Transport and Construction Corporation & Others [1997 (9) SCC 258].
Yet another endeavour was made by the learned counsel for the Railways to contend that the contract between the collieries and the consignees was not merely an F.O.R. contract but was "F.O.R. – Railway Siding" at the Colliery – what in English law is called Free Along Side (F.A.S.) contract and that title in regard to unascertained goods in such cases passed to the consignee as soon as the goods were brought to the private Railway siding at the colliery and were identified or earmarked for loading to the particular consignee in whose favour the wagons in question were allotted. Reference in this connection was made on behalf of the Railways to the meaning of FAS contracts in Halsbury's Laws of England (4th Ed., 1984) (Vol.41 , Sale of Goods para 940) and to Benjamin on Sale (5th Ed. 1997) (para 21.010, 21.011). It is stated in Benjamin as follows"
"An f.a.s. contract is one by which
the seller undertakes to deliver
goods free alongside a ship
designated by the
buyer…………………………
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/jagjit-cotton-textile-mills-v-chief-commercial-superint/
