Skip to content

Khushiram Behari Lal & Co. v. Assessing Authority, Sangrur & Anr.

Khushiram Behari Lal & Co. v. Assessing Authority, Sangrur & Anr.

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (10) SC 82

Equivalent citations: AIR 1976 SC 2372 : 1977 (39) STC 34 : 1976 (4) SCC 322 : 1977 (1) SCR 752 : 1976 TaxLR 2078

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; Jaswant Singh, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 442 of 1974
For petitioner / appellant
(From the Judgment and Order dated the 17th of August, 1970 of the Punjab & Haryana High Court in Civil Writ No. 413/62). V.C. Mahajan and O.P. Sharma, for the Appellant.
WhatsApp
Print

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

This is an appeal on certificate against the

judgment of the Punjab 'and Haryana High Court whereby the

High Court held that the appellant-firm had failed to prove

that it had stood dissolved on a date prior to the date of

assessment, viz., March 12, 1962.

The appellant-firm carries on business as commission

agents of cotton and food grains. In respect of the year

1959-60, the appellant did not submit any return under the

Punjab General Sales Tax Act. A notice was thereupon

issued to the appellant-firm and the

case was fixed for July 1, 1960. The appellant challenged

the validity of the assessment proceedings by means of a

writ petition in the High Court. The High Court during the

pendency of the petition, stayed the proceedings. Ulti-

mately, it seems, the writ petition was dismissed and the

assessment proceedings were resumed on November 30, 1961.

Various dates were fixed thereafter. February 17, 1962 was

fixed as the final date of hearing. On that date, intima-

tion was given on behalf. of the appellant that the appel-

lant-firm had ceased to do any work since February 1961. It

was also represented that a formal document had been exe-

cuted on August 8, 1961. The assessing authority despite

that intimation proceeded to make an order of assessment

dated March 12, 1962. The appellant thereupon filed anoth-

er petition under article 226 of the Constitution in the

Punjab High Court, praying for the quashing of the assess-

ment order. It was stated on behalf of the appellant that

the appellant-firm had been dissolved before the date of

assessment order and as such, the sales tax authorities

could not make an order for assessment. The High Court

dismissed the petition on the ground that the assessment

proceedings had been initiated long before the alleged date

of dissolution of the firm. The appellant thereafter came

up to this Court in appeal against the said decision of the

High Court. This .Court set aside the judgment of the High

Court, following its decision in the case of State of Punjab

v. M/s Jullundur Vegetables Syndicate.(1) The case was

remanded to the High Court as no definite finding had been

given by the High Court regarding the dissolution of the

appellant-firm and about the fact as to whether the said

dissolution had taken place before the date of the order of

assessment, namely, March 12, 1962.

After remand, the High Court called upon the sales tax

officer to make an enquiry and submit a report on the point

as to whether the appellant-firm had been dissolved on

August 8, 1961 as alleged by the appellant. The sales tax

officer thereafter made an enquiry and submitted a report

that the appellant-firm had not proved its dissolution on

August 8, 1961 or before the date of assessment order. The

High Court, 'after receipt of the report, itself examined

the matter and came to the conclusion that on the material

on record brought by the appellant, it had not been proved

that the appellant-firm had stood dissolved on a date

prior to March 12, 1962. It is the correctness of the

above decision of the High Court which has now been assailed

before us by the appellant in this appeal.

We have heard Mr. Mahajan on behalf of the appellant and

find no cogent ground to take a view different from that of

the High Court. The High Court, in the course of its judg-

ment, has pointed out that though the assessment order was

made on March 12, 1962 a large number of hearings took place

between March 8, 1961, the alleged date of dissolution and

March 12, 1962. At no hearing, was any intimation given

by the appellant to the assessing authority that the firm

had stood dissolved. All that was intimated on February

17, 1962 was that the firm had ceased to do work in February

1961 and

(1) 119661 2 S.C.n. 457.

that a formal document had been executed on August 8, 1961.

It was also not the case. of the appellant that all the six

partners of the appellant firm, had signed that document.

Another factor which weighed with the High Court was that

though intimation is required to be given under section 16

of the Punjab General Sales Tax Act regarding the dissolu-

tion of a firm within thirty days of such dissolution no

such intimation was given by the appellant-firm until April

2, 1962, i.e., nearly eight months after the alleged date of

dissolution.

In our opinion, the facts and circumstances referred to

by the High Court throw a considerable doubt. upon the

correctness of the statement made on behalf of the appel-

lant-firm' that it had stood dissolved on August 8, 1961.

It has to be borne in mind that the High Court was dealing

with the matter on the writ side. In a writ petition, the

SCOpe for interference with a finding of the departmental

authorities is much more restricted and the court can nor-

mally interfere only if the finding is based upon no evi-

dence or is based upon extraneous or irrelevant evidence

or is otherwise perverse. The same cannot be said of the

finding of the sales tax authority embodied in its report

sent to the High Court in the present case. We see no

sufficient ground to interfere with the judgment of the High

Court. The appeal fails and is dismissed. There will be

no order as to costs.

P.B.R. Appeal

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/khushiram-behari-lal-and-company-v-assessing-authority/