M. K. Kunhimohammed v. P. A. Ahmedkutty
M. K. Kunhimohammed v. P. A. Ahmedkutty
LOK 1987 (9) SC 12
Equivalent citations: 1987 (2) KLT SN 53 (Case No.76) : 1988 (64) CC 7 : AIR 1987 SC 2158 : 1987 (2) CCC 833 : 1987 (3) JT 465 : 1987 (2) Scale 442 : 1987 (4) SCC 284 : 1987 (3) SCR 1149 : 1988 CRLR 46 : 1987 (2) ACJ 872 : 1987 SCC(Cri) 703 : 1987 SCC (4) 284 JT 1987 (3) 465
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- E.S. Venkataramiah, J.; K.N. Singh, J.
- Case No.
- SLP(C) No. 7534 of 2011
Provisions referred
Cases referred 10
- Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation, Ahme-dabad v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai and Another LOK 1987 (5) SC 111 : [1987] 3 SCC 234 Referred (Para 1)
- Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavji Keshavji Modi & Ors. [1982] 1 SCR 560 Referred (Para 1)
- Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Transport Insurance Co. [1971] Supp. SCR 20 Referred (Para 1)
- P.B. Kader & Ors. v. Thatchamma and Ors. AIR 1970 Kerala 241 Referred (Para 1)
- K.R. Sivagami, Proprietor, Rajendran Tourist v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi Referred (Para 1)
- New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mahmood Ahmad Referred (Para 1)
- National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shanim Ahmad Referred (Para 1)
- Tara Pada Roy v. Dwijendra Nath Sen Referred (Para 1)
- Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern Referred (Para 1)
- Manjusri Raha & Ors. etc. v. B.L. Gupta & Ors. Referred (Para 1)
Referred in 2
- Chairman, Rajasthan State Road Transport Petitioners Corporation & Ors. v. Smt. Santosh & Ors. LOK 2013 (5) SC 1011 Referred (Para 17)
- State of Punjab v. Bhajan Kaur LOK 2008 (5) SC 89 Referred (Para 10)
Judgment
Northern India Transport Insurance Co., [1971] Supp. SCR 20; Manjusri Raha & Ors. etc. v.B.L. Gupta & Ors. etc., [1977] 2 SCR 944; P.B. Kader & Ors. v. Thatchamma and Ors., AIR 1970 Kerala 241; K.R. Sivagami, Proprietor, Rajendran Tourist v. Mahaboob Nisa Bi and others, [1981] ACJ 399; Madras Motor and General Insurance Co. Ltd. by its successor: The United Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. and others v.V.P. Ba-lakrishnan and others, [1982] ACJ 460; New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Mahmood Ahmad and others, [1984] ACJ 390; Shiva-hari Rama Tiloli and another v. Kashi Vishnu Agarwadekar and others, [1985] ACJ 494; National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shanim Ahmad and others, [1985] ACJ 749; Tara Pada Roy v. Dwijendra Nath Sen and others, [1986] ACJ 299; Noor Mohammad and another v. Phoola Rani and others, [1984] ACJ 518; Raghib Nasim and another v. Naseem Ahmad and others, [1986] ACJ 405 and Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation, Ahme-dabad v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai and Another, [1987] 3 SCC 234, referred to.
&
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 7534 of 1987.
From the Judgment and Order dated 4.11. 1986 of the Kerala High Court in M.F.A. No. 64 of 1982.
E.M.S. Anam for the Petitioner.
The Order of the Court was delivered by
VENKATARAMIAH, J. The petitioner was the owner of a bus bearing No. KLD- 9327 which was being run as a stage car-riage. On 24.7.1978 while the said bus was carrying passen-gers it met with an accident and Saheeda, who was one of the passengers in the bus, died as a consequence of the said accident. The accident took place, according to the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, due to the negligence on the part of the driver of the vehicle who had been employed by the petitioner. The Tribunal found that the compensation payable by the petitioner to the legal representatives of Saheeda was Rs.56,800. It, however, held that the liability of the insurer to indemnify the petitioner was limited to Rs.5,000 as the policy specifically limited the insurer's liability to what had been provided by section 95(2)(b)(ii)(2) and (4) of Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (herein-after referred to as the Act'). Aggrieved by the decision of the Tribunal the petitioner filed an appeal before the High Court of Kerala. The said appeal was dismissed. This peti-tion is filed under Article 136 of the Constitution for special leave to appeal against the judgment of the High Court.
The contention of the petitioner before this Court is that the insurer was liable to indemnify the petitioner upto a limit of Rs.75,000 under section 95(2)(b)(ii)(2) of the Act and that the further limit mentioned in section 95(2)(b)(ii)(4) of the Act was inapplicable to the case of the petitioner. The relevant part of section 95 of the Act during the relevant time read as follows:
"95(2). Subject to the proviso to sub-section
(1), a policy of insurance shall cover any
liability incurred in respect of any one
accident up to the following limits, namely–
(a) where the vehicle is a goods
vehicle, a limit of fifty thousand rupees in
all, including the liabilities, if any, aris-
ing under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
(8 of 1923), in respect of the death of, or
bodily injury to, employees (other than the
driver), not exceeding six in number, being
carried in the vehicle;
(b) where the vehicle is a vehicle
in which passengers are carried for hire or
reward or by reason of or in pursuance of a
contract of employment ,–
(i) in respect of persons other than
passengers carried for hire or reward, a limit
of fifty thousand rupees in all;
(ii) in respect of passengers,–
(1) a limit of fifty thousand
rupees in all where the vehicle is registered
to carry not more than thirty passengers;
(2) a limit of seventy-five thou-
sand rupees in all where the vehicle is regis-
tered to carry more than thirty but not more
than sixty passengers;
(3) a limit of one lakh rupees in all
where the vehicle is registered to carry more
than sixty passengers; and
(4) subject to the limits aforesaid,
ten thousand rupees for each individual pas-
senger where the vehicle is a motor cab, and
five thousand rupees for each individual
passenger in any other case;
(c) save as provided in clause (d),
where the vehicle is a vehicle of any other
class, the amount of liability incurred;
(d) irrespective of the class of the
vehicle, a limit of rupees two thousand in all
in respect of damage to any property of a
third party.
Section 95 of the Act sets out the requirements of the policies of insurance which must be taken by the owners of motor vehicles and the limits of liabilities thereunder. A policy of insurance should subject to the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 95 of the Act cover any liability incurred in respect of any one accident upto the limits specified in sub-section (2) of section 95 of the Act. Clause (a) of section 95(2) of the Act during the relevant time provided that where the vehicle was a goods vehicle the policy should cover the liability upto Rs.50,000 in all including the liabilities, if any, arising under the Work-men's Compensation Act, 1923 in respect of death of or bodily injury to the workmen (other than the driver) not exceeding six in number being carried in the vehicle. This clause came up for consideration before this Court in Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavji Keshavji Modi & Ors., [1982] 1 SCR 560. In that case this Court held that clause (a) of section 95(2) of the Act qualified the extent of the insurer's liability by the use of the unambiguous expression "in all" and since that expression was specially introduced by an amendment, it must be allowed its full play. The legislature must be presumed to have intended what it had plainly said. But clause (a) did not stand alone and was not the only provision to be considered for determining the outside limit of the insurer's liability. It was necessary to give effect to the words 'any one accident' which formed part in the opening part of sub-section (2) of section 95 of the Act. The Court, therefore, held that if more than one person was injured during the course of the same transaction each one of the persons must be deemed to have met with an accident. Accordingly, the Court held that each of the persons who was entitled to claim compensation under clause (a) of sub-section (2) of section 95 of the Act was entitled to claim a sum of Rs.50,000 which was the limit prescribed by the said clause on the date on which the accident, referred to in that case, occurred. The Court, however, distinguished the decision of this Court in Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Transport Insurance Co., [1971] Supp. SCR 20 which was a case in which clause (b) of sub-section (2) of section 95 of the Act had arisen for consideration. In doing so the Court observed thus:
"The judgment of the Punjab High
Court was brought in appeal to this Court in
Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern
India Transport Co. For reasons aforesaid, the
judgment in that case is not an authority on
the interpretation of clause (a) of section
95(2). After setting out the relevant provi-
sions of section 95(2) at pages 24 and 25 of
the Report, Hegde J. speaking for himself and
Jaganmohan Reddy, J. concluded:
'In the present case we are dealing
with a vehicle in which more than six passen-
gers were allowed to be carried. Hence the
maximum liability imposed under section 95(2)
on the insurer is Rs.2,000 per passenger
though the total liability may go upto
Rs.20,000.'
Towards the end of the judgment, it
was observed that reading the provision con-
tained in sections 95 and 96 together ' ….
it is clear that the statutory liability of
the insurer to indemnify the insured is as
prescribed in s. 95(2). Hence the High Court
was right in its conclusion that the liability
of the insurer in the present case only ex-
tends upto Rs.2,000 each, in the case of
Bachan Singh and Narinder Nath.' In view of
the limit on the insurer's liability in re-
spect of each passenger, the argument on the
construction of the words 'any one accident'
had no relevance and was therefore neither
made nor considered by the Court. Different
considerations may arise under clause (b), as
amended by Act 56 of 1969, but we do not
propose to make any observations on that
aspect of the matter, since it does not di-
rectly arise before us."
Section 95(2)(b) as it existed before its amendment in 1982 dealt with the limits of the liability of an insurer in the case of motor vehicles in which passengers were carried for hire or reward or by reason of or in pursuance of a contract of employment. Sub-clause (i) of section 95(2)(b) provided that in respect of death of or injury to persons other than passengers carried for hire or reward a limit of Rs.50,000 in all was the limit of the liability of the insurer. Sub-clause (ii) dealt with the liability in respect of death of or injury to passen-gers. Under that sub-clause there were two specific limits on the liability of the insurer in the case of motor vehi-cles carrying passengers. The first limit related to the aggregate liability of the insurer in any one accident. It was fixed at Rs.50,000 in all where the vehicle was regis-tered to carry not more than thirty passengers, at Rs.75,000 in all where the vehicle was registered to carry more than thirty but not more than sixty passengers and at Rs. 1,00,000 in all where the vehicle was registered to carry more than sixty passengers. The said sub-clause proceeded to lay down the other limit in respect of each passenger by providing that subject to the limits aforesaid as regards the aggregate liability, the liability extended up to Rs. 10,000 for each individual passenger where the vehicle was a motor cab and Rs.5,000 for each individual passenger in any other case. Neither of the two limits can be ignored. In the present case the vehicle in question being a bus carrying passengers for hire or reward registered to carry more than thirty but not more than sixty passengers the limit of the aggregate liability of the insurer in any one accident was Rs.75,000 and subject to the said limit the liability in respect of each individual passenger was Rs.5,000. We find it difficult to hold that the limit prescribed in section 95(2)(b)(ii)(4) was only the minimum liability prescribed by law. The amount mentioned in that provision provides the maximum amount payable by an insurer in respect of each passenger who has suffered on account of the accident. This appears to us to be a fair construction of section 95(2) of the Act as it existed at the time when the accident took place. Our view receives support from at least two decisions of this Court.
In Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Transport Insurance Co. (supra) the motor vehicle involved was a passenger bus. On account of an accident which took place on account of the negligence of the driver of the said vehicle two persons died on the spot. Their legal represen-tatives claimed compensation before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. The Tribunal found that the legal represen-tatives of each of the two persons who had died on account of the accident, were entitled to compensation of Rs. 18,000 and directed that the entire sum should be paid by the insurance company. On appeal by the legal representatives as well as by the insurance company the High Court enhanced the compensation payable to the legal representatives of each of the two deceased persons to Rs.36,000 and also allowed the appeal of the insurance company and limited its liability to the tune of Rs.2,000 in respect of each of the two deceased persons in accordance with section 95(2)(b) of the Act as it stood at the relevant time which provided that where the vehicle was a vehicle in which passengers were carried for hire or reward or by reason of or in pursuance of a contract of employment in respect of persons other than passengers carried for hire or reward, a limit of Rs.20,000 and in respect of passengers a limit of Rs.20,000 in all and Rs.2,000 in respect of an individual passenger if the vehicle was registered to carry more than six persons excluding the driver. The Court ob-served that since in the said case the vehicle was one in which more than six persons were allowed to be carried the maximum liability imposed under section 95(2) of the Act on the insurer was Rs.2,000 per passenger though the total liability might go upto Rs.20,000 in a given case where large number of persons had suffered on account of the accident. Accordingly the Court affirmed the judgment of the High Court insofar as the question of the liability of the insurer was concerned.
Clause (b) of section 95(2) of the Act again came up for consideration before this Court in Manjusri Raha & Ors. etc. v. B.L. Gupta & Ors. etc. [1977] 2 SCR 944. In that case also the motor vehicle which was involved in the accident was a bus carrying passengers on a route in the State of Madhya Pradesh. The Court followed the decision in the case of Sheikhupura Transport Co. Ltd. v. Northern India Trans-port Insurance Co., (supra) and limited the liability of the insurer to Rs.2,000 as provided by the Act at that time. The Court found itself in complete agreement with the observa-tions made by the Kerala High Court in P.B. Kader & Ors. v. Thatchamma and Ors., AIR 1970 Kerala 241, and approved the following observations made by the Kerala High Court:
"It is sad that an Indian life should
be so devalued by an Indian law as to cost
only Rs.2,000, apart from the fact that the
value of the Indian rupee has been eroded and
Indian life has become dealer since the time
the statute was enacted, and the consciousness
of the comforts and amenities of life in the
Indian community has arisen, it would have
been quite appropriate to revise this fossil
figure of Rs.2,000 per individual, involved in
an accident, to make it more realistic and
humane, but that is a matter for the legisla-
ture; and the observation that I have made is
calculated to remind the law-makers that
humanism is the basis of law and justice."
The Court also suggested on its own that instead of limiting the liability of the insurance companies to a specified sum of rupees as representing the value of human life, the amount should be left to be determined by a Court in the special circumstances of each case, even in the case where passenger vehicles were responsible for the incident. Fazal Ali, J. who delivered the judgment in the above case further observed at pages 950-95 1 thus:
"While our Legislature has made laws to cover
every possible situation, yet it is well nigh
impossible to make provisions for all kinds of
situations. Nevertheless where the social need
of the hour requires that precious human lives
lost in motor accidents leaving a trail of
economic disaster in the shape of their unpro-
vided for families call for special attention
of the law makers to meet this social need by
providing for heavy and adequate compensation
particularly through insurance companies. It
is true that while our law makers are the best
judges of the requirements of the society, yet
it is indeed surprising that such an important
aspect of the matter has missed their atten-
tion. Our country can iII-afford the loss of a
precious life when we are building a progres-
sive society and if any person engaged in
industry, office, business or any other occu-
pation dies, a void is created which is bound
to result in a serious set back to the indus-
try or occupation concerned. Apart from that
the death of a worker creates a serious eco-
nomic problem for the family which he leaves
behind. In these circumstances it is only just
and fair that the Legislature should make a
suitable provision so as to pay adequate
compensation by properly evaluating the pre-
cious life of a citizen in its true perspec-
tive rather than devaluing human lives on the
basis of an artificial mathematical formula.
It is common knowledge that where a passenger
travelling by a plane dies in an accident, he
gets a compensation of Rs.1,00,000 or like
large sums, and yet when death comes to him
not through a plane but through a motor vehi-
cle he is entitled only to Rs.2,000. Does it
indicate that the life of a passenger travel-
ling by plane becomes more precious merely
because he has chosen a particular conveyance
and the value of his life is considerably
reduced if he happens to choose a conveyance
of a lesser value like a motor vehicle? Such
an invidious distinction is absolutely shock-
ing to any judicial or social conscience and
yet s. 95(2)(d) of the Motor Vehicles Act
seems to suggest such a distinction. We
hope and trust that our law-makers will give
serious attention to this aspect of the matter
and remove this serious lacuna in s. 95(2)(d)
of the Motor Vehicles Act."
These observations were quoted with approval by this Court in the course of its judgment in Motor Owners Insur-ance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavji Keshavji Modi & Ors., (supra) and while doing so the Court observed that the above observa-tions were still languishing in the cold. storage of pious wishes. Immediately after the decision in the Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavji Keshavji Modi & Ors. (supra) Parliament took steps to amend sub-clause (ii) of clause (b) of section 95(2) of the Act by Act 47 of 1982. After the said amendment subclause (ii) of clause (b) of section 95(2) of the Act reads thus:
"95(2)(b). Where the vehicle is a vehicle in
which passengers are carried for hire or
reward of by reason of or in pursuance of a
contract of employment–
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/m-k-kunhimohammed-v-p-a-ahmedkutty/
