Skip to content

M/s Faridabad CT. Scan Centre v. D.G. Health Services

M/s Faridabad CT. Scan Centre v. D.G. Health Services

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1997 (9) SC 151

Equivalent citations: AIR 1997 SC 3801 : 1997 (4) CLT 16 : 1997 (72) ECR 801 : 1997 (95) ELT 161 : 1997 (8) JT 171 : 1997 (6) SLR 540 : 1998 (5) Supreme 287 : 1997 (6) Scale 148 : 1997 (7) SCC 752

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
, Sujata V. Manohar, B. N. Kirpal, CJI
Case No.
SLP(C) No. 23964 of 1996
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 4

  1. Union of India[Railway Board] & Ors. v. J. V. Subhaiah and Ors. (1996 Referred (Para 16)
  2. Union of India[Railway Board] & Ors. Vs. J. v. Subhaiah and Ors. (1996 Referred (Para 16)
  3. Sujata v. Manohar Referred (Para 1)
  4. Mediwell Hospital & Health Care Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India & Ors. (supra) Referred (Para 16)

Referred in 2

  1. Union Of India v. Kartick Chandra Mondal LOK 2010 (1) SC 152 Referred (Para 16)
  2. Shanti Sports Club & another v. Union of India LOK 2009 (8) SC 257 Referred (Para 51)

Earlier decisions overruled or doubted 1

  1. Mediwell Hospital and Health Care Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Union of India and others LOK 1996 (12) SC 1712 : AIR 1997 SC 1623 : (1997) 57 ECC 197 : (1997) 68 ECR 750 : (1997) 89 ELT 425 : (1997) 1 JT 270 : (1996) 9 SCALE 368 : (1997) 1 SCC 759 : (1996) 10 SCR 228 Supp : (1997) 1 UJ 323 : (1997) AIRSCW 424 Overruled

Judgment

Present:

Hon'ble the Chief Justice

Hon'ble Mrs. justice Sujata V. Manohar

Hon'ble Mr. Justice B. N. Kirpal Pradeep jain and Ms. Manjula Gupta, Adv, for the Petitioner. N. K. Bajpai and W.A. Qadri, Adv. for the Respondents

O R D E R The following Order of the Court was delivered:

This Petition for special leave was dismissed by an order dated 16.12.96 passed by a bench of Two Judges – Verma, J. (as he then was) and Kirpal, j. In view, however, of a judgement of another Bench of two Judges (K. Ramaswamy and G.B. Pattanaik, JJ.), in a similar matter Mediwell Hospital & Ors,(1997<1) SCC 759) the order of 16.12.96 was recalled by the order of 8.8.97. The reasons for recall as set out in the order of 8.8.97 are:-

"After we had dismissed

S.L.P.(c) No. 23964 of 1996 on

16. 12.96, another 2-Judge Bench

appears to have granted relief in a

similar matter which may give

impression that the view taken

therein different. It is,

therefore, appropriate that the

possible ambiguity or uncertainty

on the question of law should be

removed by judgement of a 3-judge

bench. We, therefore , recall our

order dated 16.12.1996 dismissing

the special leave petition and

direct that the special leave

petition be listed for hearing

before a 3-Judge Bench. The papers

be placed before the Hon'ble C.J.I.

for constituting the Bench.

Accordingly, we have heard the parties. In the case of Mediwell Hospital & Health Care Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India & Ors. (supra), this court on the merits of the view taken by the Bench in this case while passing the order of dismissal. In para 10 of that judgement it is recorded as follows:

"Thus a diagnostic centre run by a

private individual purely on

commercial basis may not be

entitled to the exemption under the

notification issued by the Central

Government. The conclusion of the

Central Government as well as that

of the High Court on this score,

therefore, may not be held to be

incorrect."

The court, however, granted relief to the appellant in that case on the ground that several other individual diagnostic centres not attached to any hospital had been granted the exemption under the notification in question and hence there should not be any discrimination against the appellant under Article 14. The relief was granted entirely on the basis of Article 14.

We fail to see how Article 14 can be attracted in cases where wrong orders are issued in favour of others. Wrong orders cannot be perpetuated with the help of Article 14 on the such wrong orders were earlier passed in favour of some other persons and, therefore, there will be discrimination against them. In fact, in the case of Union of India[Railway Board] & Ors. Vs. J. V. Subhaiah and Ors. (1996 (2) SCC 258), the same Learned judge in his judgement has observed in para 21 that the principle of equality enshrined under Article 14 does not apply when the order relied upon is unsustainable in law and is illegal. Such an order cannot form the basis for holding that other employees are discriminated against under Article 14. The benefits of the exemption notification, in the present case, cannot, therefore, be extended to the petitioner on the ground that such benefit has been wrongly extended to others. With respect, the decision in Mediwell hospital (supra) does not lay down the correct law on this point.

In the premises, the special leave petition is dismissed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/m-s-faridabad-ct-scan-centre-v-d-g-health-services/