Magan Bihari Lal v. State of Punjab
Magan Bihari Lal v. State of Punjab
LOK 1977 (2) SC 152
Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 1091 : 1977 CAR 183 : 1977 (83) CriLJ 711 : 1977 CrLR(SC) 130 : 1977 (2) SCC 210 : 1977 SCC(Cr) 313 : 1977 (2) SCR 1007 : 1977 UJ 235
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- P.N. Bhagwati, J.*; Syed Murtaza Fazalali, J.
- Case No.
- CrimitIal Appeal No. 22 of 1976
- For petitioner / appellant
- (Appeal by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dated the 12th September 1975 of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Criminal Revision No. 314 of 1973). R.L. Kohli, for the appellant.
Cases referred 2
- Ishwari Prasad v. Md. Referred (Para 1964)
- Kumar v. Subodh Kumar Referred (Para 1964)
Judgment
We made an order on 28th January, 1977
immediately after the conclusion of the hearing of the
appeal and by that order, we allowed the appeal and set
a'side the order of conviction and sentence recorded against
the appellant. We now proceed to give our reasons for
making that order.
The appellant was tried and convicted by the Judicial
Magistrate, 1st Class, Ludhiana for offences under sections
468, 411 and 420 read with section 109 of the Indian Penal
Code. He carried an appeal to the Sessions Court but the
appeal was unsuccessful. A further revision application
followed but that too was rejected by the High Court. Hence
the present appeal by special leave..
The facts giving rise to the prosecution are set out in
great detail in the judgment of the High Court and hence it
is not necessary to reiterate them. It is enough to state
that 354 black iron sheets worth Rs. 17,701.91 were des-
patched by Hindustan Steel Plant from Munda near Bhilai to
M/s. Shiv Rattan Mohatta at Bikaner in Wagon No. SEKC 4075.
The Railway Receipt in respect of this consignment was sent
to M/s Shiv Rattan Mohatta through the State Bank of Bikaner
and M/s Shiv Rattan Mohatta took delivery of the Railway
Receipt against payment to the Bank. The consignment,
however, did not reach Bikaner and on enquiries being made,
it was found by the Railway authorities that the wagon
containing the goods had reached Agra en route Bikaner but
at some point of time before it reached Agra, the labels
attached to the wagon were either changed or removed and the
entry in the vehicle summary guidance was also tempered with
and Changed to Ex. LAR indicating that the wagon was des-
patched from Lalitpur and its destination was Ludhiana. The
result was that wagon, instead of going to Bikaner, was
carried to Ludhiana and it reached there on 1st August,
1964.
The prosecution case was that round about this time,
one person. styling himself .as Umedi Lal, resident of Agra,
approached a firm called M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. which was
carrying on business as dealers in iron sheets in Ludhi-
ana. Umedi Lal produced a Railway Receipt Ex. PW 10/A
before Joginder Lal and Ram Nath, partners of this firm and
offered to sell the goods covered by this Railway Receipt to
M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. This Railway Receipt was a forged
document written out on a blank form stolen from the Railway
Receipt Book maintained at a railway station called Banmore.
Joginder Lal went to Ludhiana Railway Station with this
Railway Receipt on 2nd August, 1964 for taking delivery of
the goods and presented the Railway Receipt to Teja Singh
Sodhi, who was the Goods Clerk on duty at the goods-sheet.
Teja Singh entertained some doubt about the genuineness of
the Railway Receipt and he told Joginder Lal that the Rail-
way Receipt appeared to be defective. In view of this,
Joginder Lal, according to the prosecution, returned the
Railway Receipt to Umedi Lal on the following day when he
came to enquire about the receipt of the goods. Umedi Lal
then went to the railway station accompanied by one Shoja
Ram, who was a Washing Soap dealer in Ludhiana, and present-
ed the Railway Receipt to Teja Singh Sodhi for taking deliv-
ery of the goods. Curiously enough, though only a day
before, Teja Singh-Sodhi had entertained doubt about the
genuineness. of the Railway Receipt, his doubts suddenly
seemed to have vanished and he delivered the consignment of
354 black iron sheets which had come in wagon No. SEKG
40765 to Umedi Lal. It does not appear from the record us to
where this consignment of 354 black iron sheets was kept by
Umedi Lal, but out of it, 200/250 iron sheets Were taken to
the premises of M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. for sale On commis-
sion basis. Joginder Lal and Ram Nath were, however, ac-
cording to the prosecution, advised by some broker that
since iron sheets were controlled items, they should insist
on production of a bill showing purchase of these iron
sheets by Umedi LaI. Joginder Lal and Ram Nath according
asked Umedi Lal to produce
the bill in connection with the purchase of these iron
sheets, but Umedi Lal pleaded his inability to do so on the
ground that these iron sheets represented 'surplus goods
remaining after execution of a works contract by his firm of
M/s Bansidhar & Sons of Lalitpur. When this talk took place
between Joginder Lal and Ram Nath on the one hand and Umedi
Lal on the other, Umedi Lal was, according to the prosecu-
tion, accompanied by the appellant who was at the material
time employed as a Guard in the Northern Railway. Since
Joginder Lal and Ram Nath refused to purchase the iron
sheets, Umedi Lal removed the same in three carts and passed
a receipt in, respect of the same in favour of M/s Jindal
Khemka & Co. The prosecution case was that at this time
also Umedi Lal was accOmpanied by three or four persons who
included the appellant.
It appears that since M/s Shiv Rattan Mohatta did not re-
ceive delivery of the iron sheets consigned to them in Wagon
No. SEKC 40765, they lodged a claim with the Railway Admin-
istration and this led to enquiries being made by the Rail-
way Administration. Ultimately, the Railway Administration
filed a first information report with the Special Police
Establishment, Ambala Branch, and following upon the first
information report, the police started investigation.
During the course of investigation, the police entertained
suspicion against the appellant and they obtained from 'the
appellant specimen handwritings PW 27/37 to PW 27/57 for the
purpose of comparing them with the handwriting on the Rail-
way Receipt Ex. PU 10/A which was a forged document. The
Police also requested the Railway authorities to direct the
appellant and one Ameeruddin, who was also an employee of
the Railway Administration, to subject themselves to test
identification parade at the hands of the Special Railway
Magistrate, Patiala. The appellant and Ameeruddin accord-
ingly went to Patiala and they were taken to the Central
Jail and there, a test identification parade was held, at
which Joginder Lal failed to identify the appellant but Ram
Nath, after some hesitation, managed to identify him. The
specimen handwritings of the appellant Exs. PW 27/ 37 to PW
27/57 were sent, along with the Railway Receipt Ex. PW
10,'A, to B. Lal, Government Examiner of Questioned Docu-
ments and B. Lal gave his opinion that the writing marked at
A1 on the Railway Receipt Ex. PW 10/A and the specimen
handwritings PW 27/37 to 27/57 were all by One and the same
person. The appellant was, on the basis of this material,
put up for trial before the Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class,
Ludhiana. The learned Magistrate convicted the appellant
and his conviction was maintained in appeal as well as
revision. The question is whether the material on record
was sufficient to justify the conviction of the appellant.
We have carefully gone through the evidence but we find
it difficult to sustain the conviction of the appellant.
The only two pieces of evidence against the appellant are
the evidence of B. Lal, the handwriting expert, who identi-
fied the handwriting on the forged Railway Receipt Ex. PW
10/A as that of the same person who wrote the specimen
signatures Exs. PW 27/37 to PW 27/57 and the evidence show-
ing the presence of the appellant with Umedi Lal at Ludhiana
when the talk took place between Umedi Lal on the one
hand and Joginder Lal and Ram Nath on the other in connec-
tion with the sale of the iron sheets. We do not think that
these two pieces of evidence are at all satisfactory and in
any event on conviction can be rounded on them.
In the first place, it may be noted that the appellant was
at the material time a Guard in the employment of the Rail-
way Administration with his Headquarters at Agra and he had
nothing to do with the train by which Wagon No. SEKG .40765
was despatched from Munda to Bikaner, nor with the train
which carried that wagon from Agra to Ludhiana. He was not
a Guard on either of these two trains. There was also no
evidence to connect the appellant with the theft of the
blank Railway Receipt at Banmore Station. It is indeed
difficult to see how the appellant, who was a small employee
in the Railway Administration,. could have possibly come
into possession of the blank Railway Receipt from Banmore
Station which was not within his jurisdiction at any time.
It is true that B. Lal, the handwriting expert, deposed that
the handwriting on the forged Railway Receipt Ex. PW 10/A
was that of the same person who wrote the specimen handwrit-
ings Ex. 27/37 to 27/57, that is the appellant, but we
think it would be extremely hazardous to candemn the appel-
lant merely on the strength of opinion evidence of a hand-
writing .expert. It is now well settled that expert opinion
must always be received with great caution and perhaps none
so with more caution than the opinion of a handwriting
expert. There is a profusion of precendential authority
which holds that it is unsafe to base a conviction solely on
expert opinion without substantial corroboration. This
rule has been universally acted upon and it has almost
become a rule of law. It was held by this Court in Ram
Chandra v. State(1) that it is unsafe to treat expert hand-
writing opinion as sufficient basis for conviction, but it
may be relied upon when supported by other items o[ internal
and external evidence. This Court again pointed out in
Ishwari Prasad v. Md. Isa(2) that expert evidence of hand-
writing can never be conclusive because it is, after all,
opinion evidence, and this view was reiterated in Shashi
Kumar v. Subodh Kumar (3) where it was pointed out by this
Court that expert's evidence as to handwriting being opinion
evidence can rarely, if ever, take the place of substantive
evidence and before acting on such evidence, it would be
desirable to consider whether it is corroborated either by
clear_ direct evidence or by Circumstantial evidence. This
Court had again occasion to consider the evidentiary value
o[ expert opinion in regard to handwriting in Fakhruddin v.
State(4) and it uttered a note of caution pointing out that
it would be risky to found a conviction solely on the evi-
dence of a handwriting expert and before acting upon such
evidence. the court must always try to see whether it is
corroborated by other evidence, direct or circumstantial.
It is interesting to note that the same view is also echoed
in the judgments of English and American courts. Vide
Gurney v. Langlands(5) and Matter of Alfred
(1) AIR 1957 SC 381. (2) AIR 1963 SC 1728
(3) AIR 1964 SC 529 (4) AIR1967 SC 1326
(5) 1822, 5B & Qld 330
Fogter's Will(1). The Supreme Court of Michigan pointed out
in the last mentioned case: Every one knows how very unsafe
it is to rely upon any one's opinion concerning the nice-
ties of penmanship–Opinions are necessarily evil" and may
be valuable, but at best this kind of evidence, vii". We
need not subscribe to the extreme view expressed by the
Supreme Court of Michigan, but there can be no doubt that
this type of evidence being opinion evidence, is by its very
nature, weak and infirm and cannot of itself form and
the basis for a conviction. We must, therefore, try to see
whether,in the present case, there is, apart from the evi-
dence of the hand. writing expert B. Lal, any other evidence
connecting the appellant with the offence.
The only other evidence which was sought to be relied
upon on behalf of the prosecution was that showing the
presence of the appellant with Umedi Lal at Ludhiana when
there was talk between Umedi Lal on the one hand and Jogind-
er Lal and Ram Nath on the other in regard to the sale of
the iron sheets. But this evidence is wholly unsatisfactory
and does not inspire any confidence at all. In the first
place, it is difficult to see why the appellant should have
one with Umedi Lal to Ludhiana for the purpose of selling
the iron sheets. The appellant was a mere railway Guard and
even if it be assumed for the purpose of argument that his
service were utilised for the purpose of forging the railway
receipt Ex. PW 10/A, there is no reason why he should have
been persuaded to accompany Umedi Lal to Ludhiana. It is
true that the appellant was on leave from 1st August,
1964 to 16th August, 1964 but from that circumstance, it
does not follow that he had gone to Ludhiana in connection
with the sale of the iron sheets. Even according to the
prosecution, the appellant was in Ludhiana only on 6th
August, 1964 and that would not necessitate the appellant
taking such a long leave from 1st August, 1964 to 16th
August, 1964. The leave taken by the appellant from 1st
August, 1964 to 16th August, 1964would not necessarily
support the inference that the appellant was present in
Ludhiana on 6th August, 1964. The appellant might have
taken this long leave for some other purpose. Moreover, it
may be noted that Joginder Lal could not identify the appel-
lant at the rest identification parade held at the Central
Jail, PatiaIa. Ram Nath, of course, did identify the appel-
lant but that was after some hesitation. 'The Special Rail-
way Magistrate (PW 39) stated in cross-examination that Ram
Nath took some time in identifying the appellant. The
appellant in fact raised an objection before the Special
Railway Magistrate, prior to the test identification parade,
that he had a. doubt that he had been shown to the witnesses
by the police. The identification made by Ram Nath at the
test identification parade can therefore. inspire any confi-
dence in the mind of the Court. Moreover, it is diffi-
cult to imagine how Ram Nath who is supposed to have seen
the appellant for the first time on 6th August, 1964 on a
stray occasion could identify him at a test identification
parade held after about two and a half years on 25th Febru-
ary, 1967. It not as if the appellant had any direct talk
with Rain Nath on this
solitary occasion. The appellant was supposed to have
merely accompanied Umedi Lal along with one or two other
persons and it is impossible to believe that Ram Nath could
have remembered his fact after such a long period as two and
a half years. We are not' at all satisfied that the appel-
lant was with Umedi Lal when the latter is supposed to have
negotiated with Joginder Lal and Ram Nath in connection
with the saIe of the iron sheets.
It is indeed strange that the police could not trace
Umedi Lal or even Bhoja Ram. Bhoja Ram, according to the
prosecution evidence, was frequently going to the Railway
Station for taking delivery of goods on behalf of M/s Jindal
Khemka & Co. and yet he could not be caught hold of by the
police. That is indeed a sad commentary on the efficiency
of the police. We fail to understand why the police did not
try to find out what happened to the iron sheets–where they
went from the shop of M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. If the
prosecution story is true, these iron sheets were removed
by Umedi Lal from the shop of M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. and
they must have been removed by some cartmen. We find it
difficult to believe that the police could not have pursued
the matter and traced the iron sheets by making enquiries
from the cartmen. It is also intriguing why the police did
not try to find out the where. abouts of Bhoja Ram. SureIy
he could not have disappeared into the thin air. It is not
right for us to speculate but we cannot help feeling that
M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. were not absolutely innocent in so
far as this transaction is concerned. Umedi Lal was a
stranger to both Joginder Lal and Ram Nath and yet, accord-
ing to the prosecution case, Umedi Lal handed over the
forged Rail. way Receipt PW 10/A to Joginder Lal for the
purpose of taking delivery of the goods without insisting on
payment and even without settling the bargain. The Railway
Receipt Ex PW 10/A was found to be defective by Teja Singh
Sodhi, Goods Clerk on 2nd August, 1964 and yet on the next
day, strangely enough, he was, for some inexplicable reason,
persuaded to accept the same Railway Receipt and deIivered
the iron sheets against it at the instance of Bhoja Ram, who
was a person frequently acting on behalf of M/s Jindal
Khemka & Co. Then again, Joginder Lal and Ram Nath are
supposed to have returned the iron sheets to Umedi Lal
because some broker told them that they should insist on the
production of a bill of purchase by Umedi Lal which Umedi
Lal was unable to do. This also appears to be a rather
'ngenuous story made up by Joginder Lal and Ram Nath for the
ose of showing as if the iron sheets did not remain with
them. indeed strange why they should have taken a receipt
from Umedi ,7hen the latter removed the goods from their
shop. The iron belonged to Umedi Lal and if Umedi Lal took
them back from der Lal and Ram Nath, there was no reason why
the latter d have insisted on taking a receipt from him.
Presumably the .t was fabricated for the purpose of support-
ing their case that id not keep the iron sheets with them,
because otherwise they have nO account for them. It does
appear to us prima facie edi Lal was a fictitious person and
the iron sheets were taken of by M/s Jindal Khemka & Co. for
themselves on the
strength of the forged Railway Receipt PW 10/A. But some
how or the other, due to police inaction, they appear to
have escaped and a small man like the appellant seems to
have been made a scape-goat.
We are of the view that the prosecution has totally
failed to bring some the charge against the appellant and
hence our order dated 28th January, 1977 setting aside the
order of conviction and sentence recorded against the appel-
lant and acquitting him of the offences charged against
him.
S.R. Appeal allowed.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/magan-bihari-lal-v-state-of-punjab/
