Skip to content

Mangal Oram v. State of Orissa

Mangal Oram v. State of Orissa

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1977 (1) SC 204

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 1456 : 1977 (2) SCC 46 : 1977 (2) SCR 666 : 1977 UJ 177

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; Ranjit Singh Sarkaria, J.; Jaswant Singh, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeals Nos. 1237 and 1238/72. From the Judgment and Order dated 8-11-71 of the Orissa High Court in O.J.C. Nos. 339 and 385 of 1968
For petitioner / appellant
Gobind Das, (Mrs.) S. Bhandare, M.S. Narasimhan, A. K. Mathur, A.K. Sharma and (Miss) Malini Paduval, for the Appellants.
WhatsApp
Print

Referred in 1

  1. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v. The Industrial Development & Investment Co. Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. LOK 1996 (9) SC 61 Referred (Para 117)

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

This judgment would dispose of three civil

appeals Nos. 1237 and 1238 of 1972 and 1730 of 1973 against

the judgment of Orissa High Court. The first two appeals

have been filed on certificate, while the third appeal has

been filed by special leave.

We may first deal with civil appeals 1237 and 1238. On

February 22, 1954 a notification was issued under sub-sec-

tion (1) of section 3 of the Orissa Development of Indus-

tries, Irrigation, Agriculture, Capital Construction and

Resettlement of Displaced Persons (Land Acquisition) Act,

1948 (Orissa Act XVIII of 1948) (hereinafter

referred to as the Act) by the Government of Orissa for the

acquisition of 78 square miles of land for the "development

of industries,. namely, establishment of a steel plant and

allied and ancillary industries". The steel plant mentioned

in the notification subsequently' came to be known as the

Rourkela steel plant. Another notification! was issued on

February 9, 1955 for the acquisition of further four square

miles of land for the above purpose. It may be mentioned

that according to section 5 (1) of the Act, when a notice of

acquisition is served or is published under section 4, the

land shall vest absolutely in the State Government free from

all encumbrances on the date the' notice is served or pub-

lished in the gazette. The appellants, who were owners of

some of the acquired lands, filed writ petitions before the'

High Court challenging the validity of the acquisition.

The High Court dismissed both the petitions.

In appeal before us, Mr. Gobind Das on behalf of the

appellants has contended that the State Government was not

competent to acquire the land in question under the Act for

the establishment of a steel plant. Our attention is invit-

ed in this connection to sub-section (1 ) of section 3 of

the Act which provides inter alia that whenever it appears

to the 'State Government that it is necessary or expedient

to acquire speedily any land for the purpose of the devel-

opment of industry, a notification to that effect shall be

published in the gazette stating the area and the boundaries

of the land proposed to be acquired. The argument of Mr.

Gobind Das is that the acquisition of the land for the

establishment of a steel plant cannot be said to be for the

purpose of the development of the industry. It is not

denied by the learned counsel that a steel plant constitutes

an industrial undertaking and that the object of establish-

ing a steel plant is not different from the purpose of the

development of the industry as ordinarily understood. It

also cannot be disputed that Rourkela steel plant consti-

tutes a big milestone in the industrial development of the

country. The contention of Mr. Gobind Das, however, is that

the words "development of industries" have a limited meaning

as defined in the Act and the establishment of a steel plant

cannot be considered to be for development of industries.

The definition of "development of industries" has been given

in section 2(c) of the Act. According to the definition,

development of industries means and includes the construc-

tion of the Hirakud Dam and other dams and reservoirs,

Hydro-Electric Projects and such other schemes or projects

as the State Government may by notification from time to

time, specify in this behalf. We have already mentioned

above that the first notification for the acquisition of

land was issued on February 22, 1954. Two days before that

notification, on February 20. 1954 the Governor of Orissa

issued a notification in pursuance of clause (c) of section

2 of the Act. In that notification, it was stated that the

project for the establishment of a steel plant and allied

and ancillary industries in the block of villages round

about Rourkela. shall be included within the meaning of

the expression "development of industries", as defined in

clause (c) of section 2 of the Act. In the face of this

notification, we are of the opinion that the establishment

of the steel plant and ancillary industries at Rourkela

should be held to answer to the definition of "development

of industries", as given in the Act. We are unable to subs-

cribe to the submission of Mr. Gobind Das that the schemes

and projects which could be the subject-matter of a notifi-

cation under section 2(c) must be such as are similar to

Hirakud Dam or other HydroElectric projects. Clause (c) of

section 2 confers wide powers on the State Government to

notify any scheme or project as it may consider appropriate

for the development of industries and we find nothing in

that clause that the scheme or project which can be the

subject matter of a notification must be one similar to

Hirakud Dam or other dams or reservoirs or hydro-electric

projects.

It is then argued by Mr. Gobind Das that part of the

lands which were acquired for the purpose of-steel plant and

ancillary industries are being used as a civil township. It

is contended that the acquired land could only be used for

the steel plant and ancillary industries and not for a civil

township. This contention is equally devoid of force. The

establishment of a steel plant necessarily postulates the

construction of residential quarters for the workmen to be

employed in the' plant. In addition to that, lands would

be needed for shopping areas, for schools for the children

of the employees, for play-grounds, for hospitals and for

residential quarters of persons opening their shops cater-

ing to the needs of the employees of the steel plant.

Lands would likewise be need for post offices, banks, clubs,

parks, cinemas, roads, police stations as also for cremation

and burial of the dead. Land would also be needed for a

variety of other purposes and civic amenities. A township

is a necessary adjunct and concomitant of a big steel plant.

The fact, therefore, that part of the land which was ac-

quired has been used for civil township would not, in our

opinion, affect the validity of the acquisition of the land.

In civil appeal 1237 of 1972, Mr. Gobind Das has also

advanced an argument that possession of the land was not

taken from the appellant. We, however, find that the judg-

ment of the High Court shows that no such contention was

advanced before the High Court when the writ petition giving

rise to this appeal was argued. In the circumstances, we

are not inclined to permit the appellant to raise this

contention for the first time in appeal before us.

Civil appeal 1730 of 1973 arises out of writ petition

to challenge the validity of a notification dated march

19, 1958 under section '4 of the Land Acquisition Act

for the acquisition of 31.06 acres of land for expansion of

rail facilities to serve the steel plant at Rourkela. A

writ petition to challenge this notification was filed on

February 3, 1973. The contention which was advanced before

the High Court and has been repeated before us with a view

to challenge the validity of the acquisition of this land is

that fourteen years after the acquisition of the land, the

railway authorities for whom the land was acquired have

transferred 3.21 acres of land to the Notified Area Commit-

tee, Rourkela. The above submission, in our opinion, is

without merit. According to the affidavit filed on behalf

of the respondents, the above mentioned area is sought to be

transferred to the Notified Area Committee because the

Notified Area Committee is the appropriate body to construct

and maintain the

link road, bus and taxi stands and shops surrounding the

railway station. The averments contained in the affidavit

thus go to show that 3.21 acres of land is not being used

for a purpose extraneous from that for which the land was

initially acquired. Apart from that, we find that this

Court has recently held in the case of Gulam Mustafa & Ors.

v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. (1) that there is no princi-

ple of law by which a valid, compulsory acquisition stands

voided because long later the requiring authority diverts it

to a public purpose other than the one stated in the decla-

ration.

All the three appeals consequently fail and are dis-

missed but in the circumstances without costs.

Appeals dismissed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/mangal-oram-v-state-of-orissa/