Messrs Gujchem Distillers India Ltd. v. State of Gujarat
Messrs Gujchem Distillers India Ltd. v. State of Gujarat
LOK 1992 (2) SC 172
Equivalent citations: AIR 1992 SC 1256 : 1992 (2) JT 20 : 1992 (1) Scale 447 : 1992 (2) SCC 399 : 1992 (1) SCR 675 : 1992 (1) UJ 704 : 1992 SCC (2) 399 JT 1992 (2) 20
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- S. Mohan, J.*; P.B. Sawant, J.
- Case No.
- Civil Appeal No. 350 of 1974
- For petitioner / appellant
- M.H.Baig, Rajiv Shakdhar, R.Sasi Prabhu (for M/s S.A. Shroff & Co.), for the Appellants.
- For respondent
- P.S. Poti, Bimal Roy Jad. Anip Sachthey and Ms. Rashmi Dhariwal, for the Respondents.
Provisions referred
- Rules 13, 16 and 16(4), Kerala Rectified Spirit Rules, 1972
Cases referred 10
- Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of U.P. & Ors. [1989] Supp. 1 SCR 623 Referred (Para 1)
- Southern Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals v. State of Kerala LOK 1981 (9) SC 13 : AIR 1981 SC 1863 Referred (Para 1)
- Sh. Bileshwar Khand Udyog Khedut Sahakari Mandali Ltd. v. The State of Gujarat & Anr.) Referred (Para 1)
- Government of Madras v. Zenith Lamp Referred (Para 1)
- State of Rajasthan v. Sajjanlal Referred (Para 1)
- H.R.E., Madras v. Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar Referred (Para 1)
- Cooverjee B.Bharucha v. The Excise Commissioner Referred (Para 1)
- Trichur & Ors., etc. v. State of Kerala Referred (Para 1)
- Bengal v. Subodh Gopal Bose & Ors. Referred (Para 1)
- Kameshwar Prasad & Ors., v. The Referred (Para 1)
Referred in 2
- M/s. Gupta Modern Breweries v. State of Jammu & Kashmir & Ors. LOK 2007 (4) SC 192 Referred (Para 15)
- State of Madhya Pradesh v. M/s. K.C.T. Drinks LOK 2003 (3) SC 49 Referred (Para 6)
Judgment
This is an appeal by certificate granted by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad under articles 132(1) and 133 (1)(a) of the Constitution of India. It is directed against the judgment dated 29/30th August, 1973 in special Civil Application No. 163 of 1973.
The facts leading to this appeal are briefly as under:-
The Appellant is a company registered under Indian Companies Act. It is engaged in the business of manufacturing resins, chemicals, sodium carboxy methyl, cellulose and certain other chemicals. Industrial alcohol is one of the raw materials used by the appellant company.
Though, till the year 1969, the appellant was purchasing industrial alcohol from the market, it installed its own distillery from may 1970 at Bilimora, within the State of gujarat. This was for the purpose of manufacturing industrial alcohol from molasses.
On July 3rd, 1969 the second respondent, the Director of Prohibition and excise, Gujarat State, Ahmedabad issued a licence to the appellant for manufacturing spirit. In accordance with the conditions No. 2 and 3 of the licence, the 2nd respondent appointed a staff of 9 persons. The said staff consisted of one Inspector, one Sub-Inspector, one Nayak, one jamadar and five constables to supervise the manufacture of spirit in the
appellant's distillery plant. The appellant was also required to provide residential accommodation to the supervisory staff within the factory premises. On July 3rd, 1969 the 2nd respondent asked the appellant to deposit the supervisory charges. From time to time, these supervisory charges were also deposited in accordance with the directions of 2nd respondent.
It requires to be stated at this stage that the levy of supervisory charges, is traceable to section 58(A) of Bombay Prohibition Act of 1949. The Section says:
"Sec.58(A) : The State government may be general
or special order direct that the manufacture,
import, export, transport, storage, sale,
purchase, use collection or cultivation of any
intoxicant, denatured spirituous preparation, hemp,
mhowra flowers, or molasses shall be under the
supervision of such Prohibition and Excise or
Police Staff as it may deem proper to appoint, and
that the cost of such staff shall be paid to the
State Government by person manufacturing,
importing,exporting,transporting, storing,selling,
purchasing, using, collecting or cultivating the
intoxicant, denatured spirituous preparation
hemp, mhowra flowers or molasses:
Provided that the State Government may exempt any
class of persons or institution from paying the
whole or any part of the cost of such staff."
Section 143 of the said Act confers power for making rules. Rules have been framed called Bombay Prohibition (Manufacture of Spirit) (Gujarat)Rules, 1963. These rules inter alia regulate the working of distilleries, manufacturing spirit. Rule 2 provides for the licence. Condition Nos.2 and 3 of the licence require payment of the supervisory staff and for provision of quarters for the residential accommodation of the staff respectively.
The appellant filled Civil Application No. 163 of 1973 in the High court of Gujarat challenging the constitutional validity of Section 58(A) of the Act. By the impugned judgment,, the said petition was dismissed.
Hence, the present civil appeal.
The arguments of the appellant briefly stated will boil down to this. It has been categorically laid down in Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of U.P. & Ors., [1989] Supp. 1 SCR 623 that in respect of industrial alcohol, the states have no power to impose the impost as is sought to be done in the instant case. The theory of privilege as adumbrated by the High court can no longer be sustained in view of the judgement.
Even otherwise, there is no quid pro quo.
In countering the submissions, it is argued on behalf of the State that Synthetics and Chemicals Ltd. etc. (supra) dealt merely with the vend fees. That is not the case here. The maintenance of the Staff contemplated under Section 58(A) of the Act is primarily for the purpose of ensuring that while dealing with industrial alcohol, no attempt shall be made to divert nonpotable alcohol. Therefore, by regulatory measures, the States sees to it that industrial alcohol is not diverted for the use as potable alcohol. Such a regulatory measure is perfectly valid as seen from Southern Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals v. State of Kerala, AIR 1981 SC 1863. This decision was noted with approval in Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. Etc. (Supra). However, such a power was sustained though not on police power but as a regulatory measure.
As regards the services rendered, the appellants are precluded from contending that the services did not make the impost, since the High Court has noted that it was not contended before it that there was not sufficient quid pro quo between the quantum of impost and the services rendered to the manufacturer or businessman.
We are relieved of the necessity of deciding the correctness of these submissions by a detailed judgment, since identical points were raised in Civil Appeal No. 503 of 1974 (Sh. Bileshwar Khand Udyog Khedut Sahakari Mandali Ltd. v. The State of Gujarat & Anr.) to which one of us (Mohan, J.) was a party. The said Civil Appeal has been dismissed considering these aspects and upholding the validity of Section 58(A). The said judgment will squarely cover this case as well. We fully concur with the reasons contained therein. In Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. etc. (supra) concerning the power to make regulations in order that non-potable alcohol may not be diverted for use as potable alcohol, the following observations are found at page 681:
"The position with regard to the control of
alcohol industry has undergone material and
significant change after the amendment of 1956 to
the IDR Act. After the amendment, the state is
left with only the following powers to legislate
in respect of alcohol:
(a) it may pass any legislation in the nature of
prohibition of potable liquor referable to entry 6
of list II and regulating powers.
(b) it may lay down regulations to ensure that
non-potable alcohol is not diverted and misused as
a substitute for potable alcohol.
(c) the State may charge excise duty on potable
alcohol and sales tax under entry 52 of list II,
However, sales tax cannot be charged on industrial
alcohol in the present case, because under the
Ethyl Alcohol (price Control) Orders, sales tax
cannot be charged by the State on industrial
alcohol.
(d) however, in case State is rendering any
service, as distinct from its claim of so-called
grant of privilege, it may charge fees based on
quid pro quo."
In this connection, we may also usefully refer to southern Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals (supra). This case related to the constitutional validity of Sections 12-A, 12- B,14(e) & (f), 68-A of Kerala Abkari Act (1 of 1077) and Rules 13 and 16 of the Kerala Rectified Spirit Rules, 1972.
One of the contentions raised was that the provision contained under Section 14 (e) of the Act for the collection of supervisory charges was clearly invalid inasmuch as:
(a) They are in conflict of Rule 45 of Central Excise Rules and,
(b) They could not be sustained as fee as there was no quid pro quo.
In the said judgment at page 1875, para.27 Southern Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals (supra) reads as under:
" A fee may be charged for the privilege or
benefit conferred,
or service rendered or to meet the expenses
connected there-with. A fee my be, levied to meet
the cost of supervision and may be, something more.
It is in consideration for the privilege, licence
or service".
Again in para 29, it was stated thus:
"There is a broad co-relationship between the fee
collected and the cost of the establishment under
Section 14(e) of the Act it is provided that the
commissioner, with the previous approval of the
Government may prescribe the size and nature of the
establishment necessary for supervision of a
manufactory and the cost of the establishment and
other incidental charges in connection with such
supervision be realised from the licensee. There
can be no doubt that the supervisory staff is
deployed in a bonded manufactory by the Government
for its own protection to prevent the leakage of
revenue, but there is no denying the fact that a
licensee undoubtedly receives a service in return.
The cost of the establishment levied under Section
14(e) of the Act is to be collected from
the licensee in the manner provided by Rule 16(4)
of the Kerala Rectified Spirit Rules, 1972,relevant
part of which reads:
"(4) All the transactions in the spirit store shall
be conducted only in the presence of an Excise
Officer not below the rank of an Excise Inspector.
Such officer shall be assisted by at least two
Excise Guards. The cost of establishment of such
officer and the guards shall be payable by the
licensee in advance in the first week of every
month as per counter-signed challan to be obtained
from such officer. The rate at which the cost of
establishment is to be paid by the licensee shall
be fixed by the Commissioner from time to time and
intimated to the licensee in writing….."
There is admittedly no provision made in the
Central Rules for the recovery of supervisory
charges, perhaps because as the Court observed in
the Hyderabad Chemicals and Pharmaceutical's case
(AIR 1964 SC 1870) (supra) it was felt that the
duty on medicinal and toilet preparations
containing alcohol
would be sufficient to defray the cost of such
supervision. But the absence of such a provision
in the Central Rules, as we have already indicated,
does not deprive the State from making a provision
in that behalf. It is true that the supervisory
charges are in the nature of a compulsory exaction
from a licensee and the collections are not
credited to a separate fund, but are taken to the
consolidated fund of the State and are not
separately appropriated towards the expenditure
incurred in redering the service. However, as
observed in Government of Madras v. Zenith Lamp &
Electricals Ltd., [1973] 2 SCR 973; (AIR 1973 SC
724) followed in State of Rajasthan v. Sajjanlal
Panjawat,[1974] 2 SCR 741; (AIR 1975 SC 706) that
by itself is not decisive, by reason of ART. 266 of
the Constitution. It is equally true that normally
a fee is uniform and no account is taken of the
paying capacity of the recipient of the service,
but absence of uniformity will not make it a tax if
co-relationship is established [see Commissioner
H.R.E., Madras v. Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar of
Shirur Mutt and Government of Madras v.Zenith Lamp
and Electricals Ltd., AIR 1954 SC 282 and AIR 1973
SC 724 (supra)]. The cost of supervision would
necessarily vary with the nature and extent of the
business carried on by a licensee. Therefore, the
supervisory charges can be sustained even if they
are regarded as a fee for services rendered by the
State or its instrumentalities."
In dealing with Synthetics Chemical case (supra) the following observations were made:
"Learned Advocates-General for the States of
Gujarat and Kerala have also made their
submissions, and referred to several decision and
the concept of police power, and contented that
imposition of a fee would be the most effective
method of regulating intoxicating liquor other than
alcohol. According to the Advocate-General of
Kerala, that would be justified as the reasonable
measure in regard to intoxicating liquor. According
to him, it has been accepted by courts all along
that the 'police power' of the State enables
regulations to be made regarding manufacture,
transport, possession
and sale of intoxicating liquor. Such police power
could be exercised as to impose reasonable
restriction as to effectuate the power. He
referred to the observations of this Court in
Cooverjee B.Bharucha v. The Excise Commissioner and
the Chief Commissioner, Ajmer & Ors., [1954] SCR
873 which quoted the passage from Crowley v.
Christensen,(1890) 24 Lawyers' Edn. 620. Reference
was also made to Hari Shanker's case (supra). Where
this Court quoted Vol. 38 of the American
Jurisprudence where it was stated that the higher
the fee is imposed for a licence, better is the
regulation. Reliance was also placed on P. N.
Kaushal's case (supra). It was contended that it
has been accepted by this Court that the police
power is excercisable for regulation of an activity
of a legislature within the permissible field or
impost as regulatory measure. It may be valid
though it may neither be fee nor a tax in the
limited sense of the term. See the observations of
this court in Southern Pharmaceuticals & Chemicals.
Trichur & Ors., etc. v. State of Kerala &
Ors.,etc.[1982] 1 SCR 519 at 537 . Regarding
regulatory measures in connection with medicinal
preparations containing alcohol it was observed by
this Court that the impugned provisions had to be
enacted to ensure that the Rectified spirit is not
misused under the pretext of being used for toilet
and medicinal preparations containing alcohol. Such
a regulation is a necessary concomitant of the
police power of the State to regulate such trade or
business which is inherently dangerous to public
health. The American doctrine of police power is
not perhaps applicable as such in India, but power
of sovereignty to regulate as part of the power of
the competent legislature to effectuate its aim are
there.
It is true that that in the State of West
Bengal v. Subodh Gopal Bose & Ors., [1954]V SCR 587
at 601-604 and Kameshwar Prasad & Ors., v. The
State of Bihar & Anr., [1962] 3 Suppl.SCR 369 the
concept of police power was accepted as such, but
this doctrine was not accepted in India as an
independent power but was recognised as part of the
power of the State to legislate with respect to the
matters enumerated in the State and Concurrent
Lists, subject to constitutional limitations. It
was that the American jurisprudence of police
power as distinguished from specific legislative
power is not recognised in our Constitution and is,
therefore, contrary to the scheme of the
Constitution. In interpreting the provisions of our
Constitution, we should go by the plain words used
by the Constitution makers and the importing of
expression like 'police power', which is a term of
variable and indefinite connotation can only make
the task of interpretation more difficult. It was
contended that in enacting a law with respect to
intoxicating liquor as part of the legislative
power measures of social control and regulation of
private rights are permissible and as such may even
amount to prohibition.
We are of the opinion that we need not
detain ourselves on the question whether the States
have the police power or not. We must accept the
position that the States have the power to regulate
the use of alcohol and that power must include
power to make provisions to prevent and or check
industrial alcohol being used as intoxicating or
drinkable alcohol. The question is whether in the
grab of regulations a legislation which is in pith
and substance, as we look upon the instant
legislation, fee or levy which has no connection
with the cost or expenses administering the
regulation, can be imposed purely as regulatory
measure. Judges by the pith and substance of the
impugned legislation, we are definitely of the
opinion that these levies cannot be treated as part
of regulatory measures. in this view of the matter
we do not detain ourselves with examining the
numerous American decisions to which our attention
was drawn by learned counsel very elaborately and
thoroughly."
This is an added reasoning to uphold the validity of Section 58(A).
Turning to the second argument about the absence of quid pro quo, we need only extract the following from the judgment of the High Court:
"Section 58(A) of the Bombay Prohibition Act
creates a statutory duty of supervision and
incidentally provides for recovering from a
manufacturer or a businessman the cost of
supervision which is primarily necessitated by the
manufacturer
or businessman having been permitted under a
licence to carry on lawfully a business or
industrial activity which would otherwise have been
unlawful. We need not go into the details of this
aspect because it has not been contended before us
that if the levy under Section 58A is held to be a
fee, there is no sufficient quid pro quo between
the quantum of the impost and the services rendered
to the manufacturer or businessman."
In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed with cost.
V.P.R. Appeal dismissed.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/messrs-gujchem-distillers-india-ltd-v-state-of-gujarat/
