Naseem v. State of Keralam
Naseem v. State of Keralam
LOK 2026 (11) Ker. 202
Equivalent citations: 2026 KER 89286
- Court
- High Court of Kerala
- Bench
- A. Badharudeen, J.
- Case No.
- Crl.M.C. No. 9520 of 2026
- For petitioner / appellant
- Sreeraj M.D., Advocate
- For respondent
- Dalbi Emmanuel A., Public Prosecutor
Provisions referred
Headnote
Criminal Law — Cancellation of bail — Bail conditions — Non-cooperation with investigation
The accused challenged cancellation of bail after he failed to appear before the investigating officer on the dates expressly fixed in the bail order. He argued that the subsequent filing of the final report made the appearance condition inoperative. (Paras 1–12, 17)
The Court held that disobedience of a specific condition requiring attendance for interrogation justified cancellation. The later final report did not excuse breaches committed while the condition was in force. It dismissed the petition, leaving the investigating officer free to arrest and proceed against the petitioner according to law. (Paras 16–17 and concluding order)
Acts, Sections and Scheme Provisions
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — Sections 480(5) and 528
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 — Section 439(2) (now BNSS 483)
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 — Sections 126(2), 296(b), 118(1), 110 and 324(5), read with Section 3(5)
Cases referred 8
- Ajwar v. Waseem 2024 INSC 438; 2024 KHC OnLine 6302; 2024 LiveLaw (SC) 392 Referred
- Sreeja Mannangath v. State of Kerala LOK 2022 (11) Ker. 86 : 2022 (7) KHC 109; 2022 KHC OnLine 883; 2022 (6) KLT OnLine 1129 Referred
- Godson v. State of Kerala LOK 2022 (8) Ker. 1013 : 2022 (4) KLJ 150 Referred
- P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh 2022 SCC OnLine SC 552; AIR 2022 SC 2183 Referred
- Deepak Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another 2022 KHC 6591 Referred
- X1, Victim SC No.211 of 2018 of POCSO Court v. State of Kerala and Others 2019 (3) KHC 26 Referred
- Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh LOK 2018 (2) SC 612 : (2018) 3 SCC 22 Referred
- Dolat Ram and Others v. State of Haryana LOK 1994 (11) SC 247 : (1995) 1 SCC 349 Referred
Order
Accused No. 1 in Crime No. 940/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station, Kollam has filed this Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 assailing Annexure A4 order viz., order dated 24.09.2026 in C.M.P. No. 2/2026, on the files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Kadakkal, thereby the learned Magistrate cancelled the bail granted to the petitioner, on finding that he had failed to comply with the specific condition imposed by the Magistrate Court.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the learned Public Prosecutor appearing for the respondent, the State of Kerala.
3. The petitioner is the first accused in Crime No. 940/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station, Kollam where the prosecution alleges commission of offences punishable under Sections 126(2), 296(b), 118(1), 110 and 324(5) read with Section 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, by the accused persons. In the said crime, the petitioner arrayed as accused No. 1 was arrested and detained in judicial custody and thereafter, as per Annexure A1 order passed by the learned Magistrate dated 19.08.2026, he was released on bail by imposing conditions. Condition No. (3) imposed in the bail order reads as under:-
“3. The petitioners shall appear before the Investigating Officer for interrogation on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026 from 10.00 am to 03.00 pm and on any other dates as required by Investigating officer by giving written notice to him.”
4. When the petitioner failed to appear before the Investigating Officer, as directed in condition No. (3), as above, and he found involved in another crime, viz., Crime No. 1041/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station, the prosecution side had approached the learned Magistrate to cancel the bail.
5. The learned Magistrate addressed the contentions, after hearing both sides in detail. Thereafter, even though subsequent involvement of the petitioner in Crime No. 1041/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station, which in fact, thereafter quashed by this Court as per Annexure A7 order in Crl.M.C. No. 8081/2026 on 12.11.2026, as the case was compromised, the learned Magistrate given sole importance to the violation of a vital condition, viz., condition No. (3), which was imposed with a view to effectuate meaningful investigation, was willfully disobeyed by the petitioner and for the said reason, the bail granted as per Annexure A1 was cancelled, as per the order impugned. The relevant portion of Annexure A4 order is as under:-
“The bail granted to A1 Nazeem in Crime No.940/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station is hereby cancelled under Section 480(5) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha, Sanhita, 2023, in view of his failure to comply with the specific condition imposed by this Court requiring his appearance before the Investigating Officer and the subsequent circumstances indicating misuse of the liberty granted to him, including his alleged involvement in Crime No.1041/2026 of Kadakkal Police Station during the subsistence of the bail.”
6. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, before passing the order, the petitioner was not heard and therefore, the order was passed in violation of the principles of natural justice. It is also submitted that the police is bound to issue notice for his appearance and in the instant case, no notice was issued. According to him, mere violation of bail condition, by itself is not a ground to cancel the bail, as cancellation of bail affects the personal liberty guaranteed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. It is submitted further that, in this case the final report already filed and therefore, the condition No. (3) now ceased to be in operation.
7. Whereas, it is submitted by the learned Public Prosecutor that none of the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner to unsustain the order impugned would sustain.
8. It is submitted further that as per condition no. (3), no restriction imposed as regards to appearance of the petitioner before the Investigating Officer on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026 from 10.00 a.m. to 3.00 p.m., and the court specifically directed to do so. But the same was grossly violated and for the said reason, the learned Magistrate had opted the extreme step of cancellation of bail and in the facts of the case, the same is only to be justified.
9. Coming to the crux of the matter, as already extracted, as per Annexure A1, the petitioner was released on bail by imposing conditions and condition No. (3) is that “the petitioners shall appear before the Investigating Officer for interrogation on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026 from 10.00 am to 03.00 pm and on any other dates as required by Investigating officer by giving written notice to him.”
10. The prosecution moved C.M.P. No. 2 of 2026 before the learned Magistrate specifically contending that the petitioner miserably failed to appear before the Investigating Officer on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026 between 10.00 a.m., and 3.00 p.m. The petitioner also has no case that he had appeared before the court in obedience to the direction issued by the learned Magistrate as per Annexure A1 order.
11. According to him, the petitioner had lodged a complaint before the Police Complaint Authority against the Station House Officer, before whom as per Annexure A1, the petitioner was directed to appear. Thus, it is submitted that filing complaint, copy of the same produced as Annexure A2, is the reason why the petitioner failed to appear before the Investigating Officer on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026. On perusal of Annexure A2 produced by the petitioner, the same was admittedly lodged on 05.09.2026 and as on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026, even no such petition filed. Thus the explanation offered by the learned counsel for non- appearance of the petitioner is absolutely false and baseless. Moreover, filing a complaint against a Station House Officer never be a sufficient reason for non- appearance before the Station House Officer, in obedience to the order of the court.
12. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner was not heard before cancelling the bail. But, the submission appears to be absolutely false, as in paragraph No. 3 of the order, the learned Magistrate, specifically recorded that ”heard the learned Assistant Public Prosecutor and the learned counsel appearing for the accused”. Therefore, this contention found to be an absolute lie. It is pointed out by the learned Public prosecutor that apart from present crime, the petitioner is a person having involvement in two more NDPS crimes and his status is that of an habitual offender.
13. The question to be considered in the facts and circumstances of the case is that whether the learned Magistrate is justified in cancelling the bail, as per Annexure A4 order.
14. Insofar as the legal question as to whether what are the contingencies under which bail can be cancelled the law is well settled. In the decision reported in [2022 (7) KHC 109 : 2022 KHC OnLine 883 : 2022(6) KLT OnLine 1129], Sreeja Mannangath v. State of Kerala, this Court considered the parameters governing cancellation of bail referring the decisions of the Apex Court and observed in paragraphs 8 to 15 as under:
“8. In the latest decision of the Apex Court reported in (2022 KHC 6496: 2022 (2) KLD 49 : 2022 KHC OnLine 6496 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 552 : 2022 (7) SCALE 411 : AIR 2022 SC 2183), P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Another, three bench decision of the Apex Court considered some of the circumstances where bail granted to the accused can be cancelled under S.439(1) (now BNSS 483) of the Cr.P.C.. It has been held as under: a) If he misuses his liberty by indulging in similar / other criminal activity; b) If he interferes with the course of investigation; c) If he attempts to tamper with the evidence; d) If he attempts to influence / threaten the witnesses; e) If he evades or attempts to evade Court proceedings. f) If he indulges in activities which would hamper smooth investigation; g) If he is likely to flee from the country; h) If he attempts to make himself scarce by going underground and / or becoming unavailable to the investigating agency; i) If he attempts to place himself beyond the reach of his surety; j) If any facts may emerge after the grant of bail which are considered unconducive to a fair trial. We may clarify that the aforesaid list is only illustrative in nature and not exhaustive.
9. The learned counsel for the second respondent placed a decision of this Court reported in (2022 (4) KLJ 150), Godson (Represented by, M. H. Hanis (Adv.) v. State of Kerala (Represented by, Prasanth M. P. (Sr.PP) & C. S. Hrithwik (Sr.PP), to contend that mere violation of the condition of bail not to involve in similar offences during the period of bail is not sufficient to cancel the bail granted by the Court. In Godson’s case (supra), this Court considered the decision of the Apex Court in Dolat Ram and Others v. State of Haryana, 1995 (1) SCC 349 : 1994 ICO 4306, Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2018 (3) SCC 22 : 2018 ICO 103 and in X1, Victim SC No.211 of 2018 of POCSO Court v. State of Kerala and Others, 2019 (3) KHC 26 : 2019 ICO 809.
10. In Dolat Ram‘s case (supra), the Apex Court has observed as follows:
“Rejection of bail in a non – bailable case at the initial stage and the cancellation of bail so granted, have to be considered and dealt with on different basis. Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order directing the cancellation of the bail, already granted. Generally speaking, the grounds for cancellation of bail, broadly (illustrative and not exhaustive) are interference or attempt to interfere with the due course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the concession granted to the accused in any manner. The satisfaction of the Court, on the basis of material placed on the record of the possibility of the accused absconding is yet another reason justifying the cancellation of bail. However, bail once granted should not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial. These principles, it appears, were lost sight of by the High Court when it decided to cancel the bail, already granted. The High Court it appears to us overlooked the distinction of the factors relevant for rejecting bail in a non – bailable case in the first instance and the cancellation of bail already granted.”
Thus, it is clear that abuse of concessions granted to the accused in any manner is a ground to cancel the bail.
11. In Dataram Singh‘s case (supra), it was observed by the Apex Court in the manner as follows: It is also relevant to note that there is difference between yardsticks for cancellation of bail and appeal against the order granting bail. Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an order directing the cancellation of bail already granted. Generally speaking, the grounds for cancellation of bail are, interference or attempt to interfere with the due course of administration of justice or evasion or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the concessions granted to the accused in any manner. These are all only few illustrative materials. The satisfaction of the Court on the basis of the materials placed on record of the possibility of the accused absconding is another reason justifying the cancellation of bail. In other words, bail once granted should not be cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during the trial.
12. In Dataram Singh‘s case (supra) also, abuse of concessions granted to an accused in any manner is a ground to cancel the bail.
13. In X1‘s case (supra), it was observed as under:
“9. But in a case where the victim or the witnesses specifically complains of threat and intimidation and the said aspects are projected either by victim or by the prosecution before the Bail Court through an application as referred to in Ext P5, then it is bounden duty of the Bail Court to consider the correctness or otherwise of the allegations in a summary manner after affording an opportunity of being heard to the prosecution as well as to the affected accused concerned whose bail is ought to be cancelled and if possible to the victim as well, in a case like this. In such process of enquiry, the Bail Court could call for the records if any in relation to those allegations and if a separate crime has been registered in that regard, the records in those crimes should also be perused by the Bail Court in order to make an enquiry in a summary manner as to the truth or otherwise of the allegations therein, and after affording reasonable opportunity of being heard to the prosecution, accused and the victim, the Bail Court is expected to discharge its solemn duty and function to decide on the correctness or otherwise of the allegations in such a summary manner and the evidentiary assessment thereof could be on the basis of the overall attendant circumstances as well as the attendant balance of probabilities of the case. Based on such a process, the Bail Court is obliged to take a decision whether the bail conditions have been so violated and if it is so found that the bail conditions has been violated then it is the duty of the Bail Court to cancel the bail, but certainly after hearing the affected party as aforestated. So also, if the said enquiry process reveals that the truth of the above said allegations has not been established in a convincing manner in such enquiry process, then the Bail Court is to dismiss the application to cancel the bail. But the Bail Court cannot evade from the responsibility by taking up the specious plea that since the very same allegations also form subject matter of a distinct crime then the truth or otherwise of the allegations is to be decided by the Criminal Court which is seisin of that crime through the process of finalisation of said impugned criminal proceedings by the conduct and completion of trial therein.”
14. In P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh‘s case (supra), the Apex Court referred the earlier decisions inclusive of Dolat Ram‘s case (supra). But the said decision in Dataram Singh‘s case (supra) was not considered. In fact, the judgment in Dataram Singh‘s case (supra) was rendered by a two Bench of the Apex Court. Similarly, the judgment in Dolat Ram‘s case (supra) also was rendered by two Bench of the Apex Court.
15. When the three Bench decision of the Apex Court in P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh‘s case (supra) held that misuse of liberty by the accused by indulging in similar / other criminal activity is a reason for cancellation of bail, the said ratio shall be the binding precedent. It is true that in Godson‘s case (supra), the judgment was rendered by this Court on 10/08/2022 and during the relevant time also, the decision in P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh‘s case (supra) rendered on 05/05/2022 would holdthe field. Therefore, the ratio in P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh‘s case (supra) rendered by the three Bench of the Apex Court shall govern the principles regarding cancellation of bail. The ratio has been followed in another three Bench decision reported in (2022 KHC 6591), Deepak Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another. Since the law is settled as discussed above, it has to be held that, if the accused misuses his liberty by indulging in similar/other criminal activity violating condition/conditions imposed in the bail order, the same is a supervening circumstances to cancel the bail.”
15. Recently, in the decision reported in 2024 KHC OnLine 6302 : 2024 INSC 438 : 2024 LiveLaw (SC) 392], Ajwar v. Waseem, the Apex Court considered this question after referring its earlier judgments and affirmed the principles in paragraphs 27 and 28 as under:
“27. It is equally well settled that bail once granted, ought not to be cancelled in a mechanical manner. However, an unreasoned or perverse order of bail is always open to interference by the superior Court. If there are serious allegations against the accused, even if he has not misused the bail granted to him, such an order can be cancelled by the same Court that has granted the bail. Bail can also be revoked by a superior Court if it transpires that the courts below have ignored the relevant material available on record or not looked into the gravity of the offence or the impact on the society resulting in such an order. In P v. State of Madhya Pradesh and Another(supra) decided by a three judges bench of this Court [authored by one of us (Hima Kohli, J)] has spelt out the considerations that must weigh with the Court for interfering in an order granting bail to an accused under S.439(1) (now BNSS 483) of the CrPC in the following words: “24. As can be discerned from the above decisions, for cancelling bail once granted, the court must consider whether any supervening circumstances have arisen or the conduct of the accused post grant of bail demonstrates that it is no longer conducive to a fair trial to permit him to retain his freedom by enjoying the concession of bail during trial [Dolat Ram v. State of Haryana, 1995 (1) SCC 349 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 237] . To put it differently, in ordinary circumstances, this Court would be loathe to interfere with an order passed by the court below granting bail but if such an order is found to be illegal or perverse or premised on material that is irrelevant, then such an order is susceptible to scrutiny and interference by the appellate court.”
28. CONSIDERATIONS FOR SETTING ASIDE BAIL ORDERS The considerations that weigh with the appellate Court for setting aside the bail order on an application being moved by the aggrieved party include any supervening circumstances that may have occurred after granting relief to the accused, the conduct of the accused while on bail, any attempt on the part of the accused to procrastinate, resulting in delaying the trial, any instance of threats being extended to the witnesses while on bail, any attempt on the part of the accused to tamper with the evidence in any manner. We may add that this list is only illustrative and not exhaustive. However, the court must be cautious that at the stage of granting bail, only a prima facie case needs to be examined and detailed reasons relating to the merits of the case that may cause prejudice to the accused, ought to be avoided. Suffice it is to state that the bail order should reveal the factors that have been considered by the Court for granting relief to the accused.”
16. Thus, the legal position is well settled. When a Court grants bail after imposing conditions, violation of any of the conditions in a bail order would lead to cancellation of bail by invoking power under Section 439 (2) (now BNSS 483) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 439 (2) (now BNSS 483) of the Code of Criminal Procedure reads as under:
“439. Special powers of High Court or Court of Session regarding bail. xxxx xxxx xxxx (2) A High Court or Court of Session may direct that any person who has been released on bail under this Chapter be arrested and commit him to custody. “
17. Here the bail was cancelled not merely on the ground of petitioner’s involvement in another crime, but for disobedience of the specific direction issued by the court to appear before the Investigating Officer to facilitate proper investigation. It is relevant to note that the petitioner admittedly did not appear before the Investigating Officer as directed on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026. If he had any hazards in the matter of appearance before the court on the said dates, his course of action would have been to approach the learned Magistrate and get an order to adjourn the dates or for other reliefs, in accordance with law. When there is a direction issued by a court granting bail to the accused to appear before the Investigating Officer on a particular day or some days, the accused is duty bound to obey the directions and he could not wriggle out from the said direction without approaching the court and getting it modified or lifted. Since as per condition No. (3), the learned Magistrate specifically directed appearance of the petitioner on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026, the contention raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner that no notice was issued for appearance is absolutely untenable and the argument appears to be childish. Here the specific direction in Annexure A1 order issued on 19.08.2026 was violated. Being so, the same is a strong ground to cancel the bail, even though cancellation of bail is a harsh order and should not be done in normal circumstances. Disobeying a specific condition imposed by the court that too in the matter of subjecting the accused for interrogation by the Investigating Officer on a particular date or specified number of dates, could not be viewed lightly, as the same have direct impact on the investigation to be carried out effectively. Failure to appear before the investigating officer even would adversely affect fair and meaningful investigation. The contention raised by the counsel for the petitioner is that now in view of filing of final report, condition No. (3) has become inoperative. Though this submission is true, that by itself is not a justification for the petitioner in not appearing before the Investigating Officer on 29.08.2026 and 30.08.2026 and on the said dates final report was not filed and the specific direction was in force. Thus the contentions raised by the petitioner to upset Annexure A4 order are unsustainable. In the said circumstances, the learned Magistrate is right in cancelling the bail, as per Annexure A4 order, and in such view of the matter, the said order would not require any interference.
Accordingly, this Crl.M.C. stands dismissed, with liberty to the Investigating Officer to arrest and proceed against the petitioner as per law.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/naseem-v-state-of-keralam/
