Skip to content

Prithvi Raj Taneja v. State of Madhya Pradesh

Prithvi Raj Taneja v. State of Madhya Pradesh

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1977 (1) SC 184

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 1560 : 1977 (1) SCC 684 : 1977 (2) SCR 633

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; Ranjit Singh Sarkaria, J.; Jaswant Singh, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 1827 of 1970
For petitioner / appellant
(From the Judgment and Decree dated 28-4-1970 of the Madhya Pradesh High Court (Gwalior Bench) in First Appeal No. 133 of 1968). S.N. Andley and Uma Dutta, for the appellants.
For respondent
Ram Panjwani and H.S. Harihar, for the respondents.
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 1

  1. Smt. Padma Uppal etc. v. State Referred (Para 1)

Referred in 3

  1. Atma Singh (Died) Through LRs. v. State of Haryana LOK 2007 (12) SC 73 Referred (Para 4)
  2. Rao Narain Singh (Dead) By L.Rs v. Union of India LOK 1993 (4) SC 62 Referred (Para 1)
  3. Periyar And Pareekanni Rubbers Ltd. v. State Of Kerala LOK 1990 (9) SC 61 Referred (Para 4)

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

This is an appeal on certificate by Prithvi

Raj Taneja (now deceased and represented by his legal repre-

sentatives) against the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High

Court whereby the High Court partially accepted the appeal

filed by the appellant regarding the quantum of compensa-

tion for the acquisition of land.

A plot of land measuring 27 bighas and 17 biswas

situated in Ashok Nagar, district Guna, belonging to the

appellant was acquired for the construction o,f a police

station and residential quarters for

policemen. A bigha, it is stated, is equivalent to 2,500

square yards. The land sought to be acquired measured 68,658

square yards. Notification under section 4 of the Land

Acquisition Act for the acquisition of the land was issued

on April 7, 1961. The Land Acquisition Officer as per award

dated June 13, 1961 awarded compensation for the land at the

rate of Rs. 100 per bigha. In addition to that, he awarded

a sum of Rs. 1,175 for large trees and Rs. 1,380 for small

trees standing on the land. The appellant was also awarded

Rs. 1,000 as compensation for a well which had been sunk in

the. land, and Rs. 800 for a house standing on the land In

all, the appellant was awarded a sum of Rs. 7,616. including

solatium at the rate. of fifteen per cent by the Land Acqui-

sition Officer.

The appellant wanted compensation for the land at the

rate of Rs. 10 per square yard. He accordingly had the

matter referred to the District Judge. Learned Additional

District Judge determined the market value of the land in

question to be Rs. 900 per bigha. Regarding the well, the

Additional District Judge awarded compensation of Rs. 3,000

as against the amount of Rs. 1,000 which had been awarded by

the Land Acquisition Officer. In other respects, the

award of the Land Acquisition Officer was upheld. Computing

solatium at the rate of 10 per cent, the. total amount

awarded by District Judge to the appellant was Rs. 32,285

besides interest at the rate of six per cent per annum.

The appellant not being satisfied with the award of the

Additional District Judge took the matter in appeal to the

High Court. The High Court awarded compensation to the

appellant at the rate of Re. 1. per square yard for the land

in question. The High Court also awarded Rs. 2,500 for

the loss of earnings to the appellant. The rate of solatium

for compulsory acquisition was increased by the High Court

from ten per cent to, fifteen per cent. In all, the appel-

lant was held entitled to a compensation of Rs. 88,381

besides interest at the rate of six per cent per annum.

The appellant thereupon obtained a certificate of fit-

ness for appeal to this Court under article 133(1)(a) of the

Constitution, as it stood at that time.

In appeal before us, Mr. Andley on behalf of the appel-

lant has argued that more than half of the land in dispute

is within. the municipal limits of Ashok Nagar Municipality,

while the remaining land was also likely to be included

within those limits shortly. It is further stated that

the land in question abutts Ashok Nagar-Isagarh Road and is

situated near the tehsil building and the. railway station.

Learned counsel has also referred to the fact that small

plots of land adjoining the land in dispute were sold at

rates of Rs. 9 and Rs. 8 per square yard during the years

1958 to 1960. In this respect, we find that the High Court

has considered most of the above circumstances and has come

to the conclusion that Re. 1 per square yard represents

fair market value of the land in dispute. The High Court has

also referred to the special circumstances under which the

small plots were sold and their price was fixed. We agree

with the High Court that the price

paid for small plots of land cannot provide a safe

criterion for determining the amount of compensation for a

vast area of land. We may in this context refer to a recent

judgment in the case of Smt. Padma Uppal etc. v. State of

Punjab & Ors. C) wherein this Court observed that it is

well settled that in determining compensation the value

fetched for small plots of land cannot be applied to the

lands covering a very large area and that the large area of

land cannot possibly fetch a price at the same rate at which

small plots are sold.

Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act provides that in

mining the amount of compensation to, be awarded for the

land acquired under the Act, the Court shall take into.

account inter alia the market value of the land at the date

of the publication of the notification under section 4 of

the Act. The market value means the price that a willing

purchaser would pay to a willing seller for the property

having due regard to its existing condition with all its

existing advantages and its potential possibilities when

laid out in the most advantageous manner excluding any

advantage due to the carrying out of the scheme for which

the property is compulsorily acquired. In considering

market value the disinclination of the vendor to part with

his land and the urgent necessity of the purchaser to buy

should be disregarded. There is an element of guess-work

inherent in most cases involving determination of the

market value of the acquired land. But this in the very

nature of things cannot be helped. The essential thing is

to keep in view the relevant factors prescribed by the Act.

If the judgment of the High Court reveals that it has taken

into consideration the relevant factors, the assessment of

the market value of the acquired land should not be dis-

turbed (see Thakur Kanta Prasad Singh (dead) by L. rs. v.

State of Bihar(2). After having been taken through the

material on the record, we find no infirmity in the judgment

of the High Court as might induce us to disturb its find-

ing. The appeal consequently fails and is dismissed but

in the circumstances without costs.

Appeal dismissed.

(1) [1977] 1 S.C.R. 329,

(2) A.I.R. 1976 S.C. 2219.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/prithvi-raj-taneja-v-state-of-madhya-pradesh/