Skip to content

R.M. Gurjar v. High Court of Gujarat

R.M. Gurjar v. High Court of Gujarat

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1992 (8) SC 119

Equivalent citations: 1992 (21) ATC 364 : AIR 1992 SC 2000 : 1992 (65) FLR 682 : 1992 (4) JT 586 : 1992 LIC 2042 : 1992 (2) LLN 997 : 1993 (2) SLJ 57 : 1992 (5) SLR 533 : 1992 (2) Scale 148 : 1992 (4) SCC 10 : 1992 (3) SCR 775 : 1992 (2) UJ 318 : 1992 (2) ATR 555 : 1992 SCC(L&,S) 752 : 1992 LabIC 2042 : 1992 SCC (4) 10 JT 1992 (4) 586

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Kuldip Singh, J.*; A.S. Anand, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 2107 of 1977
For petitioner / appellant
S.K. Dholakia and P.C. Kapur, for the Appellants.
For respondent
Anip Schthey and Ms. Rashmi Dhariwal, for the Respondents.
WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

Cases referred 2

  1. State of Gujarat v. R.C. Mashruvala LOK 1977 (1) SC 215 : [1977] 2 SCC 12 Referred (Para 1)
  2. Division Bench in Ramesh C. Mashruvala v. State Referred (Para 1)

Judgment

KULDIP SINGH, J.

R.M. Gurjar and D.N. Jadhav were working as junior clerks in the Civil Courts under the administrative control of District Judge, Broach, Gujarat. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against them on the charge that they falsely identified three persons before a Judicial magistrate. At the enquiry both of them admitted the charge and prayed for mercy. The District Judge by the order dated June 5, 1974 imposed the penalty of withholding their future promotions with permanent effect. The High Court in exercise of its powers under rule 23 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1971 (the Rules) enhanced the penalty and imposed the punishment of removal from service. It is not disputed that the High Court enhanced the penalty after affording opportunity to the two officials in accordance with law. Gurjar and Jadhav challenged the order of their removal by way of a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the High Court. The learned single Judge after considering the relevant provisions including the historical background of various constitutional reforms appears to have been of the view that the source of power to pass the impugned order lay in the constitutional control of the High Court under Article 235. However, the difficulty which came in the way of the learned single Judge to hold so was on account of the judgment of a Division Bench in Ramesh C. Mashruvala v. State, (16 G.L.R. 277) wherein the Division Bench had given a restricted interpretation to Article 235 and had confined its applicability to persons in the judicial service of the State only. Accordingly, the learned single Judge, referred the following two questions to be decided by a larger Bench:

"(1) Whether the High Court on its administrative

side has jurisdiction to enhance the penalty

imposed by the District Judge upon a member of the

ministerial staff of the subordinate Court in

exercise of the powers of review conferred by rule

23 of the Gujarat Civil Services (Discipline and

Appeal) Rules, 1971?

(2) Whether the control vested in the High Courts

under Article 235 of the Constitution is

exercisable only over members of the judicial

service of the State as defined in Article 236 (b)

or whether the ministerial officers and servants on

the establishment of the subordinate courts are

also ultimately subject to such control?"

While the reference was pending before the Full Bench, the decision in Mashruvala case was set aside by this Court in State of Gujarat v. R.C. Mashruvala, [1977] 2 SCC 12 and it was held that the Registrar of the Small causes Court was judicial officer in the judicial service of the State and came within the scope and intend of Articles 235 and 236 of the Constitution of India.

The Full Bench of the High Court speaking through the Acting Chief Justice primarily dealt with question No. 2 and came to the conclusion that the "control" under Article 235 of the Constitution of India extends to the ministerial officers and servants on the establishment of the subordinate Courts also. The second question was, accordingly, answered against the petitioners. On the interpretation of Article 235 and the rules the first question was also decided against the petitioners. This appeal by way of special leave is against the judgment of the Full Bench of the High Court.

From the judgment of the Full Bench it transpires that though the Bench entered into lengthy discussion on the interpretation of the constitutional provisions contained in chapter VI of the Constitution it did not elaborately deal with the relevant rules which have a direct bearing on the first question. We, therefore, consider it desirable at this stage, to first deal with the relevant provisions of the Gujarat Civil Service (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1971. The relevant rules are extracted hereunder:

Rules 7,18,21 and 23 of the Rules are as under:

"7(1)………….

(2)…………

(3) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-rules

(1) and (2), Heads of Departments and Heads of Offices

may impose any of the penalties mentioned in rule 6

upon any Government servant of subordinate or

inferior service serving under them whom they have

power to appoint.

(4)…………

18. Orders against which appeal lies – (1) Subject

to the provisions of rule 22, a Government servant

may prefer an appeal against all or any of the

following orders, namely:-

(i) an order of suspension made or demand to have

been made under rule 5.

(ii) an order imposing any of the penalties

specified in rule 6 whether made by the

Disciplinary Authority or by any appellate

or reviewing authority.

(iii) an order enhancing any penalty, imposed under

rule 6.

(iv)………….

(d) has the effect of his non-promotion to a higher

post, or

18(2) An appeal referred to in sub-rule (1) shall

lie to an officer immediately superior to the

officer who made the order:

…………………………..

21(1)………..

(2) In the case of an appeal against an order

imposing any of the penalties specified in rule 6,

or enhancing any penalty imposed under the said

rule, the appellate authority shall consider :

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/r-m-gurjar-v-high-court-of-gujarat/