Skip to content

Rangaswami, Textile Commissioner v. Sugar Textile Mi

Rangaswami, Textile Commissioner v. Sugar Textile Mi

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1977 (1) SC 272

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 1516 : 1977 (2) SCC 578 : 1977 SCC(Cr) 386 : 1977 (2) SCR 825 : 1977 UJ 605

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Y.V. Chandrachud, J.*; P.K. Goswami, J.; P.N. Shingal, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeals Nos. 1545- 1546 of 1972
For petitioner / appellant
Appeals by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dated the 4-8-1971 of the Gujarat High Court in S.C.A. Nos. 972 and 1527 of 1970 respectively. V.P. Raman, Addl. Sol. Gen., S.N. Prasad .and Girish Chandra, for the Appellant.
WhatsApp
Print

Judgment

CHANDRACHUD, J.

Under the power conferred by Section 3

of the Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946, the

Central Government issued an Order called "The Cotton Tex-

tiles (Control) Order, 1948". Clause 20 of that Order, as

amended, reads thus :–

"20(1) The Textile Commissioner may from

time to time issue directions in writing to

any manufacturer or class of manufacturers

or the manufacturers generally regarding the

classes or specifications of cloth or yarn,

and the maximum or the minimum quantities

thereof, which they shall or shall not pro-

duce during such periods as may be specified

in the directions, and they shall comply with

such directions.

20(2) In the exercise of the powers

conferred upon him by sub-clause (1) the

Textile Commissioner shah have regard to the

capacity of the producer to produce cloth and

yarn of different descriptions or specifica-

tions and to the needs of the general pub-

lic."

The question for our determination in these appeals is

whether, if the Textile Commissioner decides to issue appro-

priate directions to any manufacturer or class of manufac-

turers, it is obligatory upon him to specify therein the

period for which the directions will remain in operation.

As hold by this Court in State of Uttar Pradesh

v. Jogendra Singh,(1) it is well settled that the word "may"

is capable of meaning "must" or "shall" in the light of the

context and that where a discretion is conferred upon a

public authority coupled with an obligation, the word "may"

which denotes discretion should be construed to mean a

command. Considering the purpose of the relevant empower-

ment and its impact on those who are likely to be affected

by the exercise of the power, we are clear that the power

conferred on the Textile Commissioner to issue directions is

coupled with the duty to specify the particular period for

which the directions shall be operative. Directions of the

kind envisaged by clause 20 are influenced and justified by

exigencies which render it imperative that the directions be

reviewed from time to time. That becomes feasible only if

the directions as limited expressly to a determinate period

of"

(1) [1964] 2 S.C.R. 197 at 202.

(Chandrachud, J.)

time at the end of which a fresh review of facts and circum-

stances becomes obligatory. There is a fear that a direc-

tion not limited in point of time may continue to operate

even after it has outlived its utility for the reason merely

that the need to review it is not clearly perceived. Be-

sides, the manufacturers must know, in order that they

may organize their business in their own interest as well as

in the interest of the community at large, as to how long

any particular embargo is going to be operative.

Accordingly, we affirm the judgment of the High Court

though on the ground only that the impugned Notification in

so far as it prohibits the printing of any border or heading

on sarees etc. for an indefinite period is ultra vires

clause 20 of the Cotton Textiles (Control) Order, 1948,

since the aforesaid clause casts an obligation or a duty

upon the Textile Commissioner to specify the period

during which the prohibition shall remain in force. We

express no opinion on the other points, including Point No.

6 urged before the High Court for its consideration.

The appeals are accordingly dismissed. The appellants

will pay one set of costs of these appeals to the respond-

ents.

S.R. Appeals dis-

missed.

5–206SCI/77

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/rangaswami-textile-commissioner-v-sugar-textile-mi/