Skip to content

Recovery Officer, Lakhimpur v. Ravindra Kaur

Recovery Officer, Lakhimpur v. Ravindra Kaur

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1996 (12) SC 410

Equivalent citations: 1997 (1) Supreme 560 : 1996 (9) Scale 37 : 1997 (2) SCC 682

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
N.P. Singh, S.B. Majmudar, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeals Nos. 3238-40 of 1979
WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

  • Section 91, Uttar Pradesh Co-Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965

Order

In these appeals Recovery Officer functioning under the U.P. Co-operative Societies Act, 1965 and others have brought in challenge the judgment and order of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in different writ petitions moved by the contesting respondents. The High Court allowed the writ petitions of the contesting respondents concerned and quashed the recovery proceedings initiated against them in so far as they related to the execution order under Section 91 of the Uttar Pradesh

Co-Pradesh Co-operative Societies Act, 1965 (hereinafter referred to as `the Act') by attachment and sale of the lands of the contesting respondents. It is not in dispute between the parties that the original writ petitioners being members of the co-operative societies concerned had taken loans for seeds and manure etc. From these societies functioning under the Act. When the contesting respondents did not repay the loans, the co-operative societies which advanced the loans sought to enforce the statutory charge on the properties of the writ petitioners as created by Section 39(a) of the Act. Recovery proceedings for enforcing the said charge were initiated under Section 91 read with Section 39(a) by the appellant Recovery Officer. The contesting respondent writ petitioners moved the High Court challenging these recoveries. It was contended before the High Court by the contesting writ petitioner-lonees that as the loans were taken for procuring seeds and manure etc. charge under Section 39(a) attached to the crops produced in the lands of the contesting respondents by utilising seeds and manure procured out of the loan amounts but the said charge did not fasten on the other properties and lands of the writ petitioners and, therefore, proceedings under Section 91 against the lands of the writ petitioners were illegal and liable to be queshed.

The High Court accepted the said contention and allowed the writ petitions by holding, on construction of Section 39 read with Section 91 of the Act that for realisation of loans advanced for the objects mentioned in Section 39 (a) of the Act, sale of the lands belonging to the writ petitioners could not be effected unless the concerned societies obtained decrees of court of competent jurisdiction as required by the provision to Section 39. Writ Petitions were accordingly allowed.

The aforesaid decision of the High Court is challenged by the appellant on the ground that the High Court had erred in not properly construing the provision in Section 39 (a) read with Section 91 of the Act. In order to appreciate the aforesaid contention, it is necessary to have look at the relevant provision. Section 39 reads as under :-

"S.39.- First charge of co-

operative society on certain

assets. – Notwithstanding anything

contained in the Provincial

Insolvency Act, 1920 (Act V of

1920), or in the Code of Civil

Procedure, 1908 (Act V of 1908), or

in any other enactment resisting to

land tenure for the time being in

force, any debt or outstanding

demand due to a co-operative

society by any member, past or

present, or standing against the

estate of any deceased member,

shall subject to any claim of the

Central Government or the State

Government arising from a loan

granted by it before, but not

after, the grant of the loan by the

society, or in respect of land

revenue or any sum recoverable as

arrears of land revenue, be a first

charge –

(a) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of the supply of, or any

loan to provide the means for,

seed, menure, labour subsistence,

fodder for cattle or any other

thing incidental to the conduct of

agricultural operations, upon the

crops and agricultural produce of

such members;

(b) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of any loans to provide

the means for paying the rent or

revenue of the land or for

irrigation facilities, upon the

land whose rent or revenue has been

so paid or, as the case may be, on

which the irrigation facilities

have been provided;

(c) if such debt or demand in due

in respect of supply of, or any

loans to provide the means for the

purchase of cattle, or other

livestock, or for the purchase,

repair or maintenance of

agricultural implements, transport

equipments or equipment for dairy

or for other activities relating to

animal husbandry, or for making,

replacing or purchasing of

farmhouse or shed for cattle or for

other livestock or for making,

repairing or purchasing of

warehouse for storage of

agricultural produce, then upon the

farm-produce of such members and

also upon the cattle, livestock so

purchased, or upon the equipments,

warehouse, farm-house or shed so

purchased, repaired, maintained or

made wholly or partially out of any

such loan, and if the borrower is a

land-holder, then upon his land

also, at any time within three

years from the date on which the

last installment of such loan

becomes repayable;

(d) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of the supply of, or any

loan for the purchase of raw

material, industrial implements,

plant and machinery, workshops,

warehouse or business premises,

upon the raw material or other

things so supplied or purchased by

such member ad in the case of a

debt or demand in respect of the

supply, or for the purchase of raw

materials also upon the articles

manufactured from such raw

material;

(e) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of any loan for the

purchase or redemption of land,

upon the land so purchased or

redeemed;

(f) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of any loan for the

purchase or construction of any

house or building or any portion

thereof, or in respect of the

supply of materials for such

constructions upon the house or

building or materials so purchased

or constructed or supplied; and

(g) if such debt or demand is due

in respect of any loan of Rs.500 or

more for reclaiming or protecting

land or for effecting improvement

on land or for preparation of land

for orchard or plantation or for

purchase of cattle, agricultural

implements, machinery, upon the

land so sought to be reclaimed,

protected, improved or prepared, or

upon the land for the use of which

the implements or machinery are

sought to be purchased and in case

of purchase of cattle, upon any

land of the borrower :

Provided that along with the charge

created under this section all

other property of the indebted

member including any amount payable

to him by a society shall be

liable to attachment and sale in

execution of a decree in favour of

the society irrespective of the

object of the loan."

The next relevant section is Section 91 which reads as under :-

"S.91.- Enforcement of charge :-

Notwithstanding anything contained

in Chapter IX, or any other law for

the time being in force, but

without prejudice to any other mode

of recovery provided in this Act,

the Registrar or any other gazetted

officer subordinate to him and

authorised by him in this behalf

may, on the application of a co-

operative society and on being

satisfied of existence of the debt

or outstanding demand make an order

directing the payment of such debt

or outstanding demands due to the

society by any member or past or

deceased member, by sale of the

property or any interest therein,

which is subject to a charge under

Section 39 :

Provided that no order shall be

made under this section, unless the

member, past member or the nominee,

heir or legal representative of the

deceased member, has been served

with a notice of the application

and has failed to pay the debt or

outstanding demand within one month

from the date of service".

A conjoint reading of the aforesaid two provisions clearly shows that before a charge can be enforced under Section 91 by way of recovery proceedings, it has to be shown that the concerned property of the debtor was subjected to a statutory charge under Section 39 and it is such a charged property which can be sold in the summary manner as laid down by Section 91 for realising the payment of debt of the members due to the outstanding demand of the society against such members. Consequently, it has to be found out whether the proposed sale of the property is referable to any charge which is settled on such property under Section 39. Section 91 lays down the procedure for enforcement of the charge which is referable to Section 39. All that Section 91 does is to provide a mode for enforcing the said charge. Once a charge is found to have been created on the concerned property as per Section 39, then it would create an eveoutable right in favour of the society and a corresponding obligation on the part of the lonee to satisfy his dues from the sale of the charged property. When we turn to Section 39, we find that only clause (a) of the said section would get attracted on the facts of the present case. Clause (a) creates a statutory charge on the crops or produce of the land which result out of the utilisation of the seeds or manure loan which is said to have been taken by the concerned member. Therefore, the charge attaches to the produce of the land and not on the land itself out of which the said produce is realised. In this connection, we may usefully refer to clauses (b), (c), (e) and (g) of Section 39 which create charge on land of the debtor member under circumstances contemplated by theses clauses. It is not the case of the appellants that any such charge on writ petitioners' lands was created under these clauses. Learned counsel for the appellants fairly stated that clause (a) of Section 39 cannot be effectively pressed in service because charge was not created on the land on account of the fact that the loan was taken by the concerned member for purchasing seeds or manure. However, his submission was that charge on all other properties of the debtor was created in favour of the society by the proviso to Section 39. A mere look at the proviso shows that it would encompass in its fold all other properties of the indebted member provided there is a decree in favour of the society. Then irrespective of the object of the loan such a decree-holder society can proceed against any other property of the judgment-debtor by attachment and sale on execution of the decree. The proviso does not contemplate creation of any charge on these properties, it contemplates execution of the decree for a given sum of money and such a decree could be executed by attachment and sale of any of the properties of the judgment-debtor even though not subjected to any charge under Section 39. Proviso has nothing to do with creation of charge. Statutory charge is contemplated by clauses (a) to (g) of Section 39 only. The very opening words of the proviso show that along with the charge created under this section meaning thereby under Section 39 clauses (a) to (g) respectively any other property i.e. not subjected to charge also can be proceeded against if the society has an executable decree against the debtor. All other properties mentioned in the proviso mean those which are not the subject-matter of the charge. It cannot, therefore, be said that proviso enlarges the scope of Section 39 (a) to (g) and creates a further statutory charge. It must, therefore, be held that the High Court was justified in taking the view that under the proviso no further charge is created on other property of the lonee. Once that conclusion is reached. Section 91 dealing with enforcement of the charge goes out of picture. As the lands of the writ-petitioners were not the subject-matter of any charge under Section 39, there was no occasion for Recovery Officer to proceed under Section 91 for enforcement of such non-existing charge on the lands. Till the society obtained executable decrees on the basis of the loan amounts there would arise no occasion for the society to get attachment and sale of other uncharged property of the judgment-debtor by resort to the proviso to Section 39. It is also pertinent to note that execution of decree is contemplated by Section 92 and not by Section 91. Section 92 reads as under :-

"S.92. -Execution of certain orders

and awards. – Every award made

under Section 91, and capable of

execution in the manner provided

below, and every order so capable

of execution made by the Registrar

under Section 67 or sub-section (2)

of Section 68 or under Section 91,

or by the liquidator under Section

74 or by an appellate authority on

appeal under Section 97 or 98 or on

review under Section 99 or as an

interlocutory order under Section

100 or a certificate for recovery

issued under Section 95-A shall, if

not carried out, be executed –

(a) in the manner provided by law

for the time being in force for the

recovery of arrears of land

revenue:

Provided that an application for

the recovery of any such sum is

made to the Collector and

accompanied by a certificate signed

by the Registrar or any person

authorised by him in this behalf :

Provided further that such

application is made within 12 years

from the date fixed for payment in

the order or award and if no such

date is fixed, from the date of the

order or award, as the case may be;

or

(b) by the Registrar or any other

person subordinate to him and

empowered by him in this behalf, by

attachment and sale or sale without

attachment of any property of the

person or the co-operative society

against who the order or award has

been made; or

(c) by the civil court having

jurisdiction over the matter as if the order or award were the decree of that court."

For all these reasons, therefore, it must be held that the High Court was justified in quashing the steps taken by the appellants for sale of the lands belonging to the respondents. We make it clear that our aforesaid conclusion is reached in the context of the loans advanced under Section 39(a) of the Act. It would be open to the appellants to pursue other remedies available for realisation of the loan amounts advanced to the respondents writ-petitioners in accordance with law. These appeals fail and are dismissed with no order as to costs.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/recovery-officer-lakhimpur-v-ravindra-kaur/