State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Sham Lal
State of Jammu and Kashmir v. Sham Lal
LOK 1996 (5) SC 108
Equivalent citations: AIR 1996 SC 2208 : 1996 SCC(Cr) 737
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- A.S. Anand, J.; Majmudar S.B., J.
- Case No.
- Criminal Appeal No. 675 of 1996
Order
Leave granted.
On discovering that there had been embezzlement worth crores of rupees, by way of misappropriation and misutilisation of government funds meant for purchase of food grains and other essential commodities by the employees of Jammu & Kashmir Cooperative Supply and Marketing Federation Ltd. (JAKFED for short), the Commissioner/Secretary to the Government, Agriculture Production Department filed a complaint with the Crime Branch of the Police in 1994. FIR 40/1994 came to be registered on the basis thereof. Subsequently, the complaint/FIR was transferred to the Vigilance Organisation by the Government and the Vigilance Department registered FIR No. 3/95 on its basis for offences under Section 5(2) PCA and some other offences under the RPC and took up the investigation in hand. During the preliminary stage of investigation by the Vigilance Department, the respondents Filed a writ petition in the High Court for quashing of FIR 3/95 and as interim relief sought the stay of investigation into the criminal case. Notice was issued and the learned single Judge also passed an ex-parte order staying further investigation till the 'next date'. The State, appellant herein, filed a counter to the writ petition as well as objections to the stay petition.
On 12.7.95 the writ petition came up for hearing before the learned single Judge. Request for adjournment of the case was made on behalf of learned counsel for the writ petitioners, which appears to have been opposed on behalf of the State. The hearing of the writ petition was adjourned. Since, the earlier stay order was to last till the 'next date', arguments were, however, heard on the question of extension of the stay order. The learned single Judge after taking into account the objections and arguments raised at the bar was pleased to refuse extension and he vacated the stay order dated 27.5.95. During the course of the order, the learned single Judge observed:
"This is a matter where an unusual
relief is being claimed by the
petitioners for staying the very
investigation in an FIR which
involves commission Of offences
under the Prevention of Corruption
Act and the Penal Code. In my view,
the extension of the stay order
passed on 26th May 1995, by which
investigation process in the FIR
was ordered to be stayed, is likely
to defeat the ends of justice and
the purpose for which the FIR was
lodged. The process of
investigation relating to the
commission of serious offences
cannot, in the ordinary course be
allowed to be stalled. It is always
however, open to a party, at a
stage after the completion of the
investigation that he may approach
a court of competent jurisdiction
for an appropriate relief, if he
feels that he is aggrieved in any
manner by the result of the
investigation.
It is because of the aforesaid
reasons that, evenwhile I propose
to adjourn the case because of the
request of Shri Mohd. Aslam Bhat, I
am not inclined to extend the
further operation of the interim
directions of this court dated 26th
May 1995. In that view of the
matter, therefore, I direct that
the aforesaid interim directions
shall stand vacated forthwith."
The writ petitioners, respondents herein, challenged the order of the learned Single Judge dated 12.7.95 through a Letters Patent Appeal. The Division Bench disposed of the LPA and the learned single Judge was required to reconsider the order dated 12.7.95 and till then the investigation was directed to remain stayed. In actual effect,therefore, the order dated 12.7.95 was set aside and the stay application remanded for fresh consideration by the learned single Judge. The operative part of the order reads:
"Considering the matter in
totality, we are of the view that
this appeal can be disposed of at
this preliminary hearing stage
without notice to the respondents
in view of the innocuousness of the
order proposed to be passed.
Noticing that the stay order dated
26. 5.95 was to hold valid till the
matter was to be considered by the
writ court on the next date and
keeping in regard that prayer for
adjournment had been made on the
personal grounds of learned counsel
for the petitioners, we deem it
appropriate to direct that the stay
matter shall be reconsidered and
counsel for the petitioners heard
and appropriate orders passed
whereon. Order accordingly any
till the matter is considered again
by the writ court, investigation
against the petitioners shall not
proceed in FIR No.3/95."
The State is aggrieved of this Order, hence this appeal by special leave.
Apart from the question that it is rather doubtful whether a Letters patent Appeal would lie against an order vacating an ex-parte interim order of stay, we find that the impugned order of the Division Bench is otherwise also unsustainable. We say it with respect to the learned Division Bench that it was not a proper manner of disposing of the Letters Patent Appeal. The Letters Patent Appeal has been "allowed" at the preliminary stage, without issuance of any notice to the appellant and without even admitting it. It could not be done. According to the Division Bench, the issuance of notice was not considered necessary "in view of the innocuousness of the order proposed to be passed". We cannot agree with the view of the High Court. The order of the Division Bench is not an 'innocuous' order. The Division Bench has in actual effect set aside the order of the single Judge dated 12.7.95 and remanded the case for reconsideration, without expressly saying so. The Division Bench also restored the order dated 27.5.95 by staying the investigation in FIR 3/95. Such an order could not be made by the Division Bench with hearing the parties. On the plainest consideration of justice, in our opinion the Bench was obliged to hear the opposite party i.e. the appellant herein before passing the impugned order more so since the impugned order before the Division Bench had been made after hearing the appellant, herein. We do not wish to express any opinion on the merits of the controversy in the writ petition but find that the order staying the investigation by the Division Bench in the manner in which it has been done is not at all sustainable. The grievance of the appellant that it has been seriously prejudiced by the impugned order is well founded.
This appeal accordingly succeeds and is allowed. The impugned order of the Division Bench is set aside and the order of the learned single Judge dated 12.7.95 is restored. The investigation shall be expedited.
The writ petition shall be decided on its own merits, in accordance with the settled law on the subject, after hearing the parties, expeditiously.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/state-of-jammu-and-kashmir-v-sham-lal/
