The State of Maharashtra v. Engineering College Teachers’Association & Ors.
The State of Maharashtra v. Engineering College Teachers’Association & Ors.
LOK 1996 (7) SC 223
Equivalent citations: AIR 1996 SC 2581 : 1996 (6) AD(SC) 321 : 1996 (74) FLR 2069 : 1996 (7) JT 189 : 1996 LIC 2255 : 1996 (3) SLJ 116 : 1996 (4) SLR 722 : 1996 (6) Supreme 581 : 1996 (5) Scale 649 : 1996 (10) SCC 436 : JT 1996 (7) 189
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- K. Ramaswamy, J.; G.B. Pattanaik, J.
- Case No.
- Civil Appeal No. 9889 of 1996 [Arising out of SLP (C) No. 19768 of 1995]
Order
Delay condoned.
Leave granted.
We have heard learned counsel on both sides.
This appeal by special leave arises from the order of the Administrative Tribunal, Maharashtra made on April 17, 1995 in T.A. No.670/91. The admitted facts are that all the respondents were appointed prior to 1979 as Assistant Lecturers and were possessed of Post Graduation/Doctorate/Higher educational qualifications. The Government of India had taken decision on October 16, 1973 to appoint such lecturers without reference to the Public Service Commission provided they had put in 4 years of service as Assistant Lecturers and also possessed Post- Graduation qualification. The Government of Maharashtra in acceptance of that recommendation had also adopted the same resolution dated March 23, 1990.
The Government of India Resolution reads as under:
"A person already appointed and
suitability of the candidate
Associate Lecturer or recruited
hereinafter as such would be
eligible for being upgraded as
Lecturer after four years of
service as Associate Lecturer
provided he fulfils the prescribed
educational qualifications and he
is adjudged by the Staff Selection
Committee as fit to held the post
of Lecturer."
The Government of Maharashtra Resolution dated March 23, 1990 indicates as under:
"In order to encourage
research, in continuation of post-
graduation studies, candidates,
who, at the time of their
recruitment as Lecturers posses
Master's and Doctoral degree in
engineering/technology shall be
granted 2 and 4 advance increments
in Sciences and Humanities shall be
granted 1 and 3 advance increments
respectively in the scale of
Rs.2200-4000 along with the benefit
of corresponding years of service
for the purpose of promotion. The
existing Lecturers who do not
possess these qualifications, or
who might be recruited in future
without these qualifications will
be eligible for a similar benefit
in service for the purpose of
promotion as and when they acquire
these qualifications, but they will
not be eligible for advance
increments. Existing Lecturers who
possess these qualifications will
also be eligible for the benefit in
service for the purpose of
promotion.
CAREER ADVANCEMENT:
a) Every Lecturer will be placed in
a senior scale of Rs.3000-5000 if
he has:-
completed 8 years of service
after regular appointment with
relaxation in service as
provided in para 7(c) above:-
Participated in two refresher
courses or summer institute
each of approximately four
weeks duration or in other
comparable continuous
education programmes approved
by the All India Council for
Technical Education and
Consistently satisfactory
performance appraisal reports.
All lecturers in the existing
scale of Rs.700-1600 who have
completed 8 years of service on 1st
January 1986, will be placed
through a process of
screening/selection in the scale of
Rs.3000-5000. The benefit of
service provided in para 7(c)
above, will be available for the
initial placement also.
b) Every Lecturer in the Senior
Scale will be placed in a Selection
Scale of Rs.3700-5700 on completion
of 8 years service in the Senior
Scale with relaxation in service as
provided in para 7(c) above.
Placement in the Selection Grade
will be through a process of
Selection by a Selection Committee
set up by the appointing
authorities. Only those who have
attended two refresher courses or
summer institutes or in other
comparable continuing education
after placement in the senior
scale, and whose performance has
been assessed as consistently good,
will be eligible for placement in
the Selection Grade.
c) Existing lecturers, who have
completed or will complete, a total
period of sixteen years of service
on 1st January, 1986 or thereafter
will be eligible for placement in
the Selection Grade. They will also
be entitled to the relaxation in
the years or service as provided in
para 7(c) above.
d) For the purpose of placement of
Lecturers in the Senior Scale and
Selection Grade, the corresponding
number of posts held by them will
be upgraded. The placement shall be
through a process of
screening/selection.
In furtherance thereof, it would appear that a committee of the Secretaries had recommended for upgradation. When a doubt had arisen, the Desk Officer appears to have clarified that the candidates who had put in requisite total service would be eligible for grant of senior scale and selection grade of pay. This was done by proceeding dated August 28, 1992. When the matter was brought to the notice of the Government for higher education by proceedings dated June 23, 1994, it was clarified as under:
"Taking into consideration all
these facts, it is proposed to call
for a meeting of the screening
selection committee, wherein an
issue of granting revised pay-
scales the teachers who will be
held eligible by considering their
regular service for counting it as
experience period, will be
discussed. A proposal for the said
meeting in respect of eligible
teachers who have after taking into
consideration their regular service
upto 1.1.1994 be submitted to
Government for the sanction."
In furtherance thereof, a resolution was passed on January 30, 1995 explaining the position as under:
"The revised pay scales recommended
by the A.I.C.T.E. have been
sanctioned by Govt. to the teachers
in Govt. Aided and un-aided
Engineering Colleges w.e.f.
1. 1.1986. As per G.R. under
reference as provided in para-8 of
the said G.R. the services of the
lecturers after regular appointment
are to be counted as Experience for
the purpose of granting senior
scales and selection grades
prescribed in the revised pay-
scales. It is clarified in this
context that while granting revised
pay-scales to the lecturers in
Govt. Aided and un-aided
Engineering Colleges, only the
services of lecturers who were
appointed or promoted, after the
recommendation of the Selection or
Promotion Committee respectively,
approved by the University are
required to be considered as
regular services while counting
experience in service. The service
of lecturers as Non-gazetted
service,(Class-III) and non-P.S.C.
service, should not be reckoned as
an experience and accepted as it is
lower Division Class-III service or
non-gazetted cadre service. The
pay-scales of these posts being
junior, the responsibilities
attached to then are also of a
lower level. Hence while granting
senior scales or Selection grade to
lects, lower level service period,
will not accepted as an experience.
By order and in the name of
Governor of Maharashtra."
A reading of these resolutions and clarifications would clearly indicate that due to decision taken by the Government, the Assistant Lecturers Class-III became eligible to be regularised as Lecturers in Class-II and accordingly they were regularised . The question is: whether the period of service put in as Assistant/Associate Lecturers would be counted as lecturers for the purpose of selection/selection grade scales? It would appear that since there are no promotional avenues from the Lecturer cadre to higher posts, the Government have evolved the policy of granting senior scales and selection grade scales to the Lecturers after required length of service as qualification was put in by them for fitment in the senior scale and selection grade scale of pay. Rules indicate that a Lecturer who has put in 8 years of service will be eligible for senior scale and a Lecturer who has rendered 8 years of service in the senior scale after putting in 16 years of total service as a Lecturer, namely, 8 years as Lecturer and 8 years as senior scale Lecturer, becomes eligible for selection grade . The question arises: whether the respondents could be fitted into the senior scale of pay or the Selection Grade? It is not in dispute that they have spent more number of year s as Assistant lecturers. The Tribunal has given direction as under:
"In the result, therefore, the
petitioners succeed. It is hereby
declared that while extending the
facility as senior scale/selection
grade, the teaching experience
gained by the petitioners from the
date they acquired qualifications
required for the post of lecturer
prior to 1.4.1979 by their
continuous service either as Asstt.
lecturer prier to 1.4.1979 ; Asstt.
lecturer or as upgraded Lecturer or
as upgraded Lecturer even prior to
the upgraded post, shall be taken
into consideration. With these
directions, the petitions stand
disposed of along with
Miscellaneous Applications for the
proposed amendment. In the
circumstances, there shall be no
order as to costs. it is further
directed that the cases of the
petitioners shall be processed in
accordance with the above
directions and in accordance with
the latter dated 20.8.92 and the
decision thereon shall be taken in
the matter of extending senior
scale or selection grade to the
petitioner within six months from
the date of this order. It is
Further made clear that the
extension of senior scale Selection
grade shall not have any either the
placement of the petitioners in the
seniority list of the lecturers
which shall be regulated in the
absence of any contrary rule either
existence or that may be framed in
future, on the basis of the date of
actual entry in the cadre of
lecturer. In case of the present
petitioners as already pointed put
the date of entry in the cadre of
lecturer shall be 1.4.1979."
The Tribunal has proceeded on the premise that since they had put in required length of service they became eligible for senior/selection grade scales. It would be clear that the Tribunal has not properly considered 'the resolutions passed by the Government. The Government intended to grant the senior scale and selection grade to the Lecturers who had put in required number of service in the respective cadres as a qualification for eligibility. As stated earlier, the Assistant/Associate Lecturers are in Class-III whereas Lecturers are in Class-II. Therefore, the service rendered in Class-III cannot be computed as Service rendered in Class-II service. Moreover, required experience of eight years as Lecturer and another eight years as senior Lecturers is pre-condition for grant of senior scale and selection grade scale. It is not in dispute that scales of pay of Assistant Lecturers are entirely different from the scales of pay of Lecturer As and senior scale Lecturers. Therefore, the entire service as Assistant/Associate Lecturers cannot be and could not be counted as Lecturers and senior Lecturers for grant of respective scales. If the contention of respondents merits acceptance, the respondents would be the Assistant Associate Lecturers who had put in 16 years of service after securing post-graduation or doctorate without service as Lecturer. Consequently, a direct recruit lecturer has to wait for 16 years to get into selection grade while Assistant Associate Lecturer would scale a march over the former. The consequence would be startling. So, such service as Assistant/Associate lecturer except four years for fitment as Lecturer cannot be counted towards the service rendered as a lecturer/senior scale Lecturer. It would therefore, be obvious that any Lecturer to become eligible for fitment in the senior scale of pay has to put in 8 years of service as a lecturer after regularisation and thereafter after putting in 8 years of service as Lecturer in the senior scale or pay; then only he gets into the selection grade scale. Under these circumstances, the view of The Tribunal is wholly illegal.
The appeal is accordingly allowed. The Government is directed to place them appropriately as indicated in the order. No costs.
Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/state-of-maharashtra-v-engineering-college-teachers-as/
