Skip to content

Steel Authority of India v. Dr. R.K. Diwakar

Steel Authority of India v. Dr. R.K. Diwakar

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1997 (8) SC 137

Equivalent citations: 1997 (3) CLT 379 : 1997 (77) FLR 351 : 1997 (7) JT 404 : 1998 (1) LLJ 344 : 1998 (1) SLJ 57 : 1997 (5) SLR 234 : 1997 (7) Supreme 349 : 1997 (5) Scale 478 : 1997 (11) SCC 17 : AIR 1998 SC 2210 : 1998 LIC 2122

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
K. Venkataswami, V.N. Khare., J.*
Decided on
Case No.
The 13Th Day of August, 1997 Present: Hon'ble Mr. Justice K.Venkataswami Hon'ble Mr.Justice V.N.Khare G.M.Mishra and Rathin Das, Advs. for the appellants A.P.Mohanty, Adv. for the Respondents J U D G M E N T S The following Judgment of the Court was delivered: (With C.A. No. 5851 of 1994) J U D G M E N T
WhatsApp
Print

Cases referred 4

  1. ESI v. T.Abdul Razak (1996 Referred (Para 1)
  2. Sastry v. Controller & Auditor Referred (Para 1)
  3. Police v. General Referred (Para 1)
  4. General of Police v. Thavasiappan). Referred (Para 1)

Judgment

K. Venkataswami, J.

A common question of law arises out of these two appeals. As a matter of fact, the High Court disposed of the two Miscellaneous Petitions by one order.

The appellant framed charges against the first respondent in each of the appeals for certain alleged misconduct committed by them. The charge-sheets were issued by the Director. Medical and Health Services of the appellant. The delinquents challenged the charge-sheets on the only ground that their appointing authority/disciplinary authority being the Managing Director of the appellant, the charge memo issued by the Director, Medical and Health Services was invalid and of no consequence. The appellant, however, justified the issue of charge-sheet by the Director. Medical & Health Services on the ground that the powers to initiate disciplinary action had been delegated to the Head of the Department who enjoys a rank of General Manager. The Director, Medical and Health Services, who issued the charge memos, admittedly come under the category of controlling authority.

The High court did not accept the contention of the appellant (respondent before the High Court) stating that the delegation of power has not been established.

Before us, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants, apart from bringing to our notice the relevant proceedings duly delegating the power to the Director, Medical and Health Services, invited our attention to a recent decision of this Court in Director General. ESI vs. T.Abdul Razak (1996 (4) SCC 708). In that case, in answering an identical question, this Court held a follows:-

"With regard to initiation of

disciplinary proceedings by the

Regional Director, we find that the

legal position is well settled that

it is not necessary that the

authority competent to impose the

penalty must initiate the

disciplinary proceedings and that

the proceedings can be initiated by

any superior authority who can be

held to be the controlling

authority who may be an officer

subordinate to the appointing

authority (See: State of m.P. v.

Shardul Singh; P.V. Srinivasa

Sastry v. Controller & Auditor

General and Inspector General of

Police v. General and Inspector

General of Police v. Thavasiappan).

The Regional Director, being the

officer-in-charge of the region,

was the controlling authority in

respect of the respondents. He

could institute the disciplinary

proceedings against the respondents

even in the absence of specific

conferment of a power in that

regard."

(Emphasis supplied)

In the case on hand, it is not in dispute that the authority who issued the charge-sheet was the controlling authority. That being the position, the judgment of the High Court cannot be sustained and accordingly it is set aside and the appeals are allowed. However, there will be no order as to costs.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/steel-authority-of-india-v-dr-r-k-diwakar/