Skip to content

Timber Kashmir Pvt. Ltd. v. Conservator of For

Timber Kashmir Pvt. Ltd. v. Conservator of For

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (10) SC 264

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 151 : 1976 (4) SCC 497 : 1977 (1) SCR 937 : (1976) 4 SCC 498

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
M. Hameedullah Beg, J.*; A.N. Ray, CJI; P.N. Shingal, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal Nos. 313-315 1974. From the Judgment and Order dated 8-8-1972 of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court in Civil First Appeals Nos. 46 to 48 of 1972
For petitioner / appellant
Naunit Lal, for the Appellant.
For respondent
V.C. Mahajan and R.N. Sachthey, for the Respondent.
WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

Cases referred 1

  1. Chand v. State of Madhya Referred (Para 9)

Judgment

BEG, J.

These are three appeals by certification

against the judgment of a Division Bench of the High Court

of Jammu & Kashmir, allowing appeals from the judgment of a

learned single Judge.

Jammu and Kashmir Government had filed three applications

under section 20 of .the Jammu & Kashmir Arbitration Act,

2002, to refer disputes arising out of three agreements

between it and the appellant Company to arbitration under

the arbitration clauses of agreements between the parties.

The applications had been dismissed by the learned

single Judge on the ground that the arbitration clause

was, in each case, a part of an agreement which was not duly

executed in accordance with the provisions of Section 122(1)

of the Constitution of Jammu & Kashmir which correspond to

those of Article 199(1) of the Constitution of India. The

Division Bench had allowed the appeals of the Conservator of

Forests, Jammu Circle, after holding that the provisions of

section 122(1) of the Constitution of Jammu & Kashmir

could not be said to have been infringed if contracts were

signed by the Conservator of Forests in compliance with an

order of the Government.

The main-stay of the case of the appellant company was

an instruction or rule contained in "The book of the Finan-

cial Powers" which reads as follows:

"'S. 13. The power to sanction or cancel the terms of

instruments, leases, agreements is delegated in the follow-

ing cases:

S. Nature of power To whom delgated. Extent

No.

1 2 3 4

X X X

X

X X

9. To sell forest produce Chief Conser- Upto Rs. 7000/-

and to enter into con- vator of forest in value in

tract for the same each case provided

the highest tender

conservators of upto Rs.3000/ in

forests each case provided

the highest tender

is accepted.

Divisional upto Rs.1000/in each

forest case provided the

officer highest tender is

accepted.

The Division Bench observed that this rule existed prior

to the coming into force of the Constitution of Jammu and

Kashmir. It may also be pointed out that this rule deals

with the power to "sanction or cancel" leases, agreements

and other instruments which was delegated to the officers

mentioned there with limitation on their powers specified

there. But, the Constitutional provision, relied upon on

behalf of the appellant, relates to the manner of the execu-

tion of the formal

document containing the contract after its sanction. It is

true that the contract could not be executed without the

sanction. Nevertheless, if the sanction could be either

expressly or impliedly given by or on behalf of the Govern-

ment, as we think it could, and, if some acts of the Govern-

ment could fasten some obligations upon the Government, the

lessee could also be estopped from questioning the terms

of the grant of the sanction even where there is no written

contract executed to bind the lessee.

In the case before us, we have agreements from which the

appellant company has derived benefits. And, there are

contracts validly executed on behalf of the Government of

Jammu & Kashmir by the Conservator of Forests. It is true

that, if the appellant could take up the legal plea that the

contracts were not duly executed, in accordance with section

122(1) of the Constitution of Jammu & Kashmir, it could urge

that they did not have any effect at all as contracts

whatever other legal consequences its acts or conduct may

have had. But, this does not mean that, if a party obtains

benefits on the understanding that it would abide by certain

conditions, as the appellant company had done, it could not

be compelled to observe those conditions, such as the condi-

tion to refer disputes to arbitration. However, in the

instant case, we need not go into that question because the

plea of a violation of Section 122(1) of the Jammu & Kashmir

Constitution is itself not sustainable for the reasons

indicated below.

As the Division Bench of the High Court had pointed out,

there was a Government order and notification of 23rd

February, 1957 which reads as follows:

In exercise of the powers conferred by

sub-section (1) of Section 122 of the Consti-

tution, the Sadar-i-Riyasat is pleased to

direct that the under-mentioned contracts and

assurances of property made in the exercise of

the executive powers of the State may be

executed on his behalf by various Officers

subject to any limit fixed by Government rules

and orders as follows:

VI. In the Department of Development:

(1) Agreements relating to Forest

Leases and appropriation of forest products:

By the secretary to Government, Chief Conser-

vator, Conservators of Forests and Divisional

Forest Officers".

The three leases, containing the arbitration clauses which

the appellant wants to avoid, were executed on 27th Febru-

ary, 1963, and 28th February, 1963, and 19th March, 1963,

after the notification mentioned above. The leases were

duly signed by Conservators of Forests, who were expressly

authorised, without any limits imposed on the valuation of

the leases, to sign and execute them on behalf of the Gov-

ernment. The delegation of power made prior to the Jammu

10 –1338SCI/76

and Kashmir Constitution related to grants of sanction and

their cancellation. It did not expressly refer to powers to

execute leases which is a separate matter. The notification

of 1957, however, is specifically related to the execution

of formal documents including leases. Hence, it will cover

the three leases before us even if the former rules relating

to the limits of the authority of Forest Officers to give

or cancel certain sanctions could be said to be in existence

at all after the enactment of the new Constitution of Jammu

& Kashmir and the notification of 23rd February, 1957, cited

above.

We may mention that, as has been indicated in the

separate judgment of the learned Chief Justice of the High

Court, the Jammu & Kashmir Government had tried to remove

the doubts it entertained about the validity of past leases

executed by the Conservator of Forests. It, therefore,

passed two orders: one of 14th April, 1965, and the other of

29th April, 1971. The order of 14th April, 1965, ran as

follows:

"In supersession of previous orders

regarding signing of lease agreement it is

ordered that the Conservator of Forests will

sign agreements relating to all cases of For-

ests leases and appropriation of forest

products and Chief Conservator of Forests will

act as the arbitrator as provided under C1. 44

of the Agreement.

By order of the Government of Jammu & Kashmir.

Sd/- Bharat Bhushan Secre-

tary to Govt. Forests Department".

The order of 29th April, 1971, runs as fol-

lows:

"Government Order No. FST-31 dated 14-4-65

shall bedeemed to have taken effect from

29-1-63 and all actions taken by the Conser-

vators of Forests in executing the lease

agreements by virtue of the said order are

hereby regularised.

By order of the Government of Jammu & Kashmir.

Sd/- R.C. Bhargava, Secretary to Government,

Agricultural

Department".

The learned Chief Justice had observed that these

orders, purporting to ratify the leases which were valid,

did not have any legal effect whatsoever and were unneces-

sary. If there had been any question to be decided as to

whether the Government had sanctioned the leases, its ac-

tions, apart from the execution of leases, could be consid-

ered. But, once there has been a valid execution of leases

by duly authorised officers, the documents would be the best

evidence of sanction also. That was one of the objects of.

prescribing a formal mode of execution of instruments on

behalf of the Government apart from the need to protect its

interests against mala-fide and other unauthorised acts of

its servants or agents as indicated by this Court in Mulam

Chand v. State of Madhya Pradesh(1)

1) [1968] 3S.C.R. 214.

In the cases before us the only question which needed

decision was whether formal execution of the leases by duly

authorised officers had been proved. We are of opinion that

the Conservator of Forests was, for the reasons given by us,

duly authorised to execute the leases. Accordingly, we

affirm the orders of the Division Bench so that matters

in dispute between the parties could be validly referred to

Arbitration under the appropriate clauses of the agreements.

These appeals are, therefore, dismissed with costs.

Civil Miscellaneous Petition No. 8573 of 1975 for interim

orders is also dismissed as infructuous.

S.R. Appeals

dismissed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/timber-kashmir-pvt-ltd-v-conservator-of-for/