Skip to content

Union of India v. Shri Guru Charan Dass

Union of India v. Shri Guru Charan Dass

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1997 (4) SC 102

Equivalent citations: AIR 1997 SC 2605 : 1997 (76) FLR 464 : 1997 (5) JT 80 : 1997 LIC 2645 : 1997 (2) LLJ 764 : 1997 (3) LLN 77 : 1998 (1) SLJ 33 : 1997 (4) SLR 681 : 1997 (4) Supreme 641 : 1997 (3) Scale 725 : 1997 (4) SCC 660 : 1997 (2) SCJ 310 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987 : 1997 SCC(L&,S) 987

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
K. Ramaswamy, D.P Wadhwa, J.
Decided on
Case No.
No
WhatsApp
Print

Order

This appeal by special leave arises from the order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal at Cuttack in T. A. No. 267\86 on May 26, 1987.

The admitted facts are that the respondent was working in Hirakund Project Prior to 30th march 1960. Consequent upon the closer of the project, offer was given to several persons including the respondent for seeking appointment either in the state service or in the Government of India service or to get retrenched. The alternative appointment in the Government project , namely, Danakarnya Project was given to the respondent by letter dated March 9, 1960 by the chief Administrator of that Project. The letter of appointment read as under:

"The post in question carries the

pay scale of 180-10-300…plus

usual dearness allowances

admissible to central Government

employees. In addition the

following allowances have been

sanctioned for the employees of the

Dandakarnya Project and Sri Guru

Charan Das will be entitled to them

in addition to the extent

admissible.

(i) 25% deputation allowance, if

he is already a permanent /quasi

permanent employee, (ii) 20%

Project allowance permanent/quasi

permanent or not (iii) Rent free

tenanted accommodation in the area

or the present.

3. In case the post is acceptable

to Shri Guru Charan Das on these

terms and conditions, he may be

relieved from his duties so as to

as Publicity officer at Koraput

immediately but act later than 4th

April 1960 after availing joining

time, admissible under the rules."

Obviously the respondent accepted the offer of appointment and in terms thereof by letter dated April 2, 1960, he was appointed temporarily as Publicity Organiser. Since deputation allowance was not paid to him, he filed a writ petition in the High Court. consequent upon the constitution of the Tribunal, the writ petition was has found as a fact that his continuance in Hirakund as U.D.C. was on permanent basis and that, therefore, he is entitled to the deputation allowance.

Mr. P.P. Malhotra, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant contends that since the respondent came to be appointed afresh on temporary basis in terms of the appointment letter, he is not entitled to the deputation allowance. We find no force in the contention.

In view of the offer of appointment given to the respondent and the respondent having accepted the same, he is entitled to the deputation allowance of 25%. Since his status as a permanent U.D.C. was not disputed before the Tribunal and no tangible contra material has been placed before us justifying acceptance of the said finding recorded by the Tribunal, the respondent is entitled to deputation allowance as directed by the Tribunal.

The appeal is accordingly dismissed. No costs.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/union-of-india-v-shri-guru-charan-dass/