Skip to content

Y.B. Patil v. Y.L. Patil

Y.B. Patil v. Y.L. Patil

LOK Law Journal

LOK 1976 (8) SC 232

Equivalent citations: AIR 1977 SC 392 : 1976 (4) SCC 66 : 1977 (1) SCR 320

Court
Supreme Court of India
Bench
Hans Raj Khanna, J.*; N.L. Untwalia, J.; Jaswant Singh, J.
Decided on
Case No.
Civil Appeal No. 1298 of 1968
For petitioner / appellant
Appeal by Special Leave from the Judgment and Order dated 22-9-67 of the Mysore High Court in Writ Petition No. 2190/67. S.V. Gupte, S.S. Javali and B. Dutta, for the Appellant.
WhatsApp
Print

Referred in 2

  1. Bhanu Kumar Jain v. Archana Kumar & Another LOK 2004 (12) SC 1711 Referred (Para 6)
  2. Hope Plantations Ltd. v. Taluk Land Board Peermade LOK 1998 (11) SC 31 Referred (Paras 9, 3)

Judgment

KHANNA, J.

This is an appeal by special leave against

the judgment of the Mysore High Court whereby the High Court

dismissed petition under articles 226 and 227 filed by the

appellants to challenge the order dated September 12, 1967

of the Mysore Revenue Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter re-

ferred to as the Tribunal).

The brief facts giving rise to this appeal are that the

first resdent applied on April 22, 1959 to the Assistant

Commissioner Bagalkot for the restoration of the

Patilki/watan/lands survey Nos. 32/2, 54/2, and 49/2 under

sections 11, 11A and 12 of the Bombay Hereditary Offi-

cers Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act). Possession of

those lands was sought on the ground that the appellants,

who were strangers, had taken possession of the lands.

The Assistant

Commissioner, as per order dated August 11, 1960, accepted

that application and directed that the possession of the

lands be restored to the respondents. Appeal filed by the

appellants against that order was dismissed by the Deputy

Commissioner as per order dated January 24, 1961. The

appellantas then went up in revision before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal as per order dated May 5, 1962 accepted the

revision petition and held that the appellants were not

strangers to the watan. In arriving as this conclusion, the

Tribunal held disagreeing with the Assistant Commissioner

and the Deputy Commissioner that the watan had been acquired

by Basangouda I. The respondents challenged the order of

the Tribunal by means of a writ petition. The Writ petition

filed by the respondents was accepted by the Mysore High

Court as per judgment dated December 18, 1964, and it was

held that it was not open to the Tribunal to reopen and set

aside findings of fact in a revision petition. The case

was accordingly remitted to the Tribunal for fresh deci-

sion in the light of the observations of the High Court.

When the matter came up before the Tribunal after the

above judgment of the High Court, the Tribunal as per order

dated September 12, 1967 upheld the findings of the Assist-

ant Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner that the watan

had been acquired by Basangouda II and not by Basangouda

I. It may be stated that Basangouda I was the grandfa-

ther of Basangouda II and that unless it be shown that the

watan had been acquired by Basangouda I, the appellant would

have to be held strangers qua the lands in dispute. The

Tribunal accordingly dismissed the revision petition which

had been filed by the appellants. The appellants thereafter

filed petition under articles 226 and 227 before the High

Court and assailed the above order of the Tribunal. The

High Court dismissed the writ petition on the ground that

the finding that the appellants were strangers to the watan

was one of fact and it was not open to the High Court to

reopen the concurrent findings of the Assistant Commission-

er, the Deputy Commissioner and the Tribunal in a writ

petition.

In appeal before us Mr. Gupte on behalf of the appel-

lants has contended that the High Court was in error in not

interfering with the order of the Tribunal whereby the

revision petition filed by the appellants had been dis-

missed. It is urged that the Tribunal in affirming the

findings of the Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy

Commissioner regarding the question of the appellants being

strangers qua the land in dispute took a very restricted

view of section 79 of the Act dealing with revision. This

contention, in our opinion, is not well founded. The High

Court at the time of the decision of the earlier writ peti-

tion on December 13, 1964 recorded a finding and gave direc-

tions to the Tribunal not to reopen the questions of fact in

revision. The Tribunal while passing the order dated Sep-

tember 12, 1967 complied with those directions of the High

Court. The appellants are bound by the judgment of the High

Court and it is not open to them to go behind that judgment

in this appeal. No appeal wag filed against that judgment

and it has become final. It is well settled that princi-

ples of res judicata can be invoked not only in separate

subsequent proceedings, they also get attracted in subse-

quent

stage of the same proceedings. Once an order made in the

course

of a proceeding becomes final, it would be binding at

the subsequent stage of that proceeding. In view of the

High Court judgment dated December 18, 1964, the Tribunal

while passing the order dated September 12, 1967, disposing

of the revision petition filed by the appellant, could not

reopen the questions of fact which had been decided by the

Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner. The High

Court, in our opinion, was right in holding in the judgment

under appeal that the concurrent findings of fact arrived at

by the Assistant Commissioner, the Deputy Commissioner and

the Tribunal cannot be set aside in the writ petition. The

appeal consequently fails and is dismissed but in the cir-

cumstances with no order as to costs.

M.R. Appeal

dismissed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/y-b-patil-v-y-l-patil/