Skip to content

Judgments

3 judgments match your search. Search by party name, citation (e.g. LOK 2026 (10) Ker. 5), case number, judge or words in the judgment, or pick a date of decision.

Clear

Tagged Proportionality ×

LOK 2026 (11) SC 157 · Supreme Court of India

Sumit Kumar v. Union of India

Equivalent citations: 2026 INSC 1221

ActsConstitution of India (Articles 14 and 226); Central Industrial Security Force Rules, 2001 (Rules 36, 36(8)(a) and 36(10)(b)); Official Languages Rules, 1976 (Rule 7(3))

The Supreme Court set aside the removal of a CISF Constable and the Delhi High Court's orders upholding it, holding that the charges of disobedience, circulating his wife's video, and relying on past minor penalties as a fresh charge were unsustainable. Finding gross breach of natural justice from belated Hindi translations and denial of a defence assistant—as well as shocking disproportionality—the Court ordered immediate reinstatement with 50% back wages and consequential benefits.

LOK 2026 (11) SC 160 · Supreme Court of India

Mithilesh Kumar Pathak v. Union of India

Equivalent citations: 2026 INSC 1219

ActsConstitution of India (Article 226); Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 (Rule 27(c)(4))

The Supreme Court set aside a Patna High Court Division Bench order and restored the Single Judge's order quashing a CRPF Constable's removal from service for 99 days' overstay of leave. Holding that rejecting medical records without verification from the treating doctor rested on conjecture and that removal was grossly disproportionate, the Court ordered immediate reinstatement with 50% back wages and consequential benefits.

LOK 2026 (7) Ker. 222 · High Court of Kerala

Bahadur Shah Anakkot Nasirali v. Union of India & Ors.

Equivalent citations: 2026 KER 54792

Constitutional Law — Aadhaar authentication — Tatkal booking — ProportionalityThe petitioner challenged Aadhaar authentication for booking Tatkal train tickets through IRCTC, invoking privacy concerns. IRCTC justified the online requirement as a response to manipulation and bulk booking. (Paras 1–7)Given the purpose of the measure and…