Skip to content

M/s. Hoysala Projects Pvt. Ltd. v. Sajin Paul

M/s. Hoysala Projects Pvt. Ltd. v. Sajin Paul

LOK Law Journal

LOK 2026 (11) Ker. 181

Equivalent citations: 2026:KER:87661

Court
High Court of Kerala
Bench
Mohammed Nias C.P., J.
Case No.
MSA No. 80 of 2026; MSA No. 81 of 2026; MSA No. 82 of 2026; MSA No. 83 of 2026; MSA No. 84 of 2026; MSA No. 85 of 2026; MSA No. 86 of 2026; MSA No. 87 of 2026; MSA No. 88 of 2026; MSA No. 89 of 2026; MSA No. 90 of 2026; MSA No. 91 of 2026; MSA No. 92 of 2026; MSA No. 93 of 2026; MSA No. 94 of 2026; MSA No. 95 of 2026; MSA No. 96 of 2026; MSA No. 97 of 2026; MSA No. 98 of 2026; MSA No. 99 of 2026; MSA No. 100 of 2026; MSA No. 101 of 2026; MSA No. 102 of 2026; MSA No. 103 of 2026; MSA No. 104 of 2026; MSA No. 105 of 2026; MSA No. 106 of 2026; MSA No. 107 of 2026; MSA No. 108 of 2026; MSA No. 109 of 2026; MSA No. 110 of 2026; MSA No. 111 of 2026; MSA No. 112 of 2026; MSA No. 113 of 2026; MSA No. 115 of 2026
For petitioner / appellant
E.K. Nandakumar (Senior Advocate), Nagaraj Narayanan, Advocates
For respondent
K. Shaj, A. Kevin Thomas, Nidhi Sam Johns, Lijo Joseph (Thoppil), Advocates

Municipal LawReal Estate LawRERA

WhatsApp
Print

Provisions referred

Headnote

Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 — Sections 2(q), 2(zf), 11(4)(b), 11(5), 14(3), 17, 18, 31 — Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019 — Rules 19C, 20 — Kerala Real Estate Regulatory Authority (General) Regulations, 2020 — Regulation 21(4) — Kerala Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2018 — Rule 36 — Occupancy Certificate — Jurisdiction of K-RERA and Appellate Tribunal

The appellants, promoters of the project "Hoysala EVM", obtained an Occupancy Certificate on 10.05.2023 from the Thrikkakara Municipality and intimated the allottees to remit balance amounts for execution of sale deeds. One and a half years later, the allottees filed complaints before K-RERA seeking execution of sale deeds, interest for delay, conveyance of common areas, and car parking allotment, alleging that the project was incomplete; K-RERA held the relief regarding completion not maintainable in view of the Occupancy Certificate and Form 6 while keeping other reliefs open. On appeal, the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal found a violation of Regulation 21(4) of the K-RERA (General) Regulations, 2020 and Rule 36 of the Kerala RERA Rules, 2018 for want of notice regarding an inspection by two Deputy Directors, distinguished Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash on the allegation of fraud, and directed K-RERA to consider the complaints in toto. Aggrieved, the promoters preferred 35 Miscellaneous Second Appeals before the High Court.

Held

  1. An Occupancy Certificate issued by the municipal Secretary under Rules 19C and 20 of the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019 certifies that the building is constructed as per the approved permit and is fit for occupation, whereas the RERA Act operates in a distinct field governing the promoter's statutory and contractual obligations toward allottees under Sections 11(4)(b), 14(3), 17, 18, and 31. (Paras 12–18)
  2. Following Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash and Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders and Developers Pvt. Ltd., authorities under the RERA Act cannot inquire into the legality or correctness of an Occupancy Certificate or whether the building is complete as per the permit; even an allegation of fraud in obtaining the certificate does not enlarge RERA's jurisdiction, and any challenge must be pursued against the issuing authority under the law governing it. (Paras 19, 22)
  3. The grant of an Occupancy Certificate does not bar allottees from approaching K-RERA for statutory reliefs such as execution of sale deeds, conveyance of common areas to the Association, allotment of parking slots, structural defects, or delay interest; however, because the Deputy Directors' site inspection regarding building completion was itself outside K-RERA's purview, non-compliance with Regulation 21(4) and Rule 36 could not justify reopening the completion finding. (Paras 20–22)
  4. Modifying the Appellate Tribunal's common order, the High Court declared that RERA authorities shall not inquire into the legality of the Occupancy Certificate dated 10.05.2023 or building completion as per the permit, directed K-RERA to adjudicate all other RERA claims within the timeline indicated in MSA No. 40 of 2026 dated 11.09.2026, and disposed of the appeals. (Para 22)

Cases referred 3

  1. MSA No. 40 of 2026 and connected cases Judgment dated 11.09.2026 (Kerala High Court) Referred (Para 22)
  2. Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash 2024 KHC 7050 Followed (Paras 5, 7, 9, 11, 19, 22)
  3. Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders and Developers Pvt. Ltd. 2023 KHC 9214 Followed (Paras 7, 9, 19, 22)

JUDGMENT

MOHAMMED NIAS C.P.

These Miscellaneous Second Appeals are filed by the promoters of the project “Hoysala EVM” against the common order of the Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal. The first respondents in all the appeals are allottees of the project. They filed complaints before the Kerala Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Thiruvananthapuram (K-RERA), seeking execution of sale deeds, interest for delay and other reliefs.

2. The appellants filed I.A. Nos. 55 to 61, 64 to 70 and 95 to 106 of 2025 questioning the maintainability of the complaints. Their contention was that “Hoysala EVM” is a completed project, that an Occupancy Certificate was issued for it on 10.05.2023, and that this was intimated to all the allottees, who were instructed to remit the balance amounts and get their sale deeds executed. The complaints were filed one and a half years after the Occupancy Certificate was received. Since the Occupancy Certificate was issued by the local authority, the appellants contended that its legality was not a matter for K-RERA to consider. They argued that the complaints were preferred only when the promoter was initiating steps under Section 11(5) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (hereinafter the RERA Act) to cancel the allotments.

3. The complainants alleged that the project is neither completed nor handed over to the Association, that the common areas have not been registered in favour of the Association, and that car parking slots have not been allotted to all the allottees.

4. K-RERA noted that the project was registered under Section 3 of the RERA Act, that the Occupancy Certificate was obtained on 10.05.2023, and that Form 6 uploaded to its registration web portal indicated that the project is complete in all respects and handed over to the Association of allottees. It held that the relief sought regarding completion was not maintainable, while the other reliefs, such as interest for delay in handing over and ensuring conveyance, could be considered. To that extent, the complaints were held maintainable, and the project was to be treated as completed in all respects.

5. The allottees challenged that order before the Tribunal. By a common order, the Tribunal found a violation of Regulation 21(4) of the Kerala Real Estate Regulatory Authority (General) Regulations, 2020 and Rule 36 of the Kerala Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules, 2018, as no notice was issued to the parties before K-RERA deputed two Deputy Directors to inspect the project and ascertain whether it was complete. The Tribunal also noticed the allottees’ contention that show cause notices had been issued to the builder as to why the Occupancy Certificate should not be cancelled. It held that the complaint was maintainable even as to the relief for completion of the project, and that the right of hearing could not be curtailed. The decision of this Court in Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash [2024 KHC 7050], relied on by the promoters, was distinguished on the allottees’ submission that the Occupancy Certificate was obtained by fraud. The Authority was directed to consider the complaints in toto.

6. Aggrieved, the promoters have filed these appeals, contending that the Tribunal went wrong in not following the judgments of this Court, which hold that the correctness of an Occupancy Certificate cannot be gone into by the Tribunal, and that when the Occupancy Certificate is available, there is no scope for a site inspection on the completion of the project.

7. The following substantial questions of law arise for consideration.

(A) Whether non-compliance with Regulation 21(4), arising solely from failure to afford an opportunity to file objections and make submissions on an inspection report, can have any legal consequence in finding that the project building is complete on the basis of an Occupancy Certificate.

(B) Whether the Tribunal and the Authority can disregard an Occupancy Certificate issued by the competent authority and rely on other materials to enter a finding on the completion of a project building under the RERA Act.

(C) Whether the Tribunal can ignore the dictum in Nidhish P.V. v. Sivaprakash (2024 KHC 7050) and Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders and Developers Pvt. Ltd. (2023 KHC 9214) that an Occupancy Certificate is conclusive proof of completion, and direct K-RERA to rely on other materials to adjudicate the completion of the project building.

(D) Whether an Appellate Authority, on a finding of a procedural defect, can permit or direct reopening of a finding that the project building is complete, made on the strength of an Occupancy Certificate, without recording that such an exercise was illegal, without jurisdiction or otherwise invalid.

8. Heard Sri. E.K. Nandakumar, learned Senior Counsel, instructed by Sri. Nagaraj Narayanan, for the appellants and Sri. K. Shaj, learned counsel, for the respondents.

9. It is not in dispute that an Occupancy Certificate was issued to the project on 10.05.2023. The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants relied on Nidhish P.V. (supra) and Siji Jacob v. Ultima Builders and Developers Pvt. Ltd. [2023 KHC 9214], in which this Court held that a completion certificate issued by the local authority certifies that the building is constructed as per the approved plan and permit. If anybody is aggrieved by its issuance, it is for them to challenge it through the proper remedies available under law, and its legality is not a matter for K-RERA to consider.

10. It was therefore contended that an enquiry whether the building is complete, in the sense of complete as per the building permit issued, is totally outside the purview of the RERA Act, and that the authorities under the Act have no jurisdiction to decide the legality of the Occupancy Certificate. According to the appellants, the order of the Authority, which declined to adjudicate completion while leaving the other reliefs open, was in tune with the provisions of the Act and was wrongly reversed by the Tribunal.

11. The learned counsel for the respondents, Sri K.Shaj, on the other hand, submitted that a project can be said to be complete only after the steps mentioned in the RERA Act, including those under Section 17, are completed, and that in this case, except for 15 allottees, nobody could occupy the apartments. It was argued that the issuance of an Occupancy Certificate is different from completion of the project. The Act provides for approaching the authorities under it in case of structural defects and non-compliance with the provisions of the Act and Rules, and the mere fact that an Occupancy Certificate has been obtained cannot be a reason to prevent the allottees from approaching those authorities. The respondents also contended that Nidhish P.V. (supra) has no application as it dealt with the requirement of registration under the RERA and not as to the reliefs allottees can claim before the RERA forums.

12. The Occupancy Certificate in this case was issued by the Thrikkakara Municipality under the Kerala Municipality Building Rules, 2019 (hereinafter the Building Rules). Rule 19C provides that, after completion of construction as per a self-certified building permit, the occupancy certificate shall be issued in Appendix F2A. Under Rule 20(1), every owner, on completion of construction as per the permit, must submit a completion report certified and signed by him, and, for buildings other than small residential ones, also by a registered Institution, Architect, Building Designer, Engineer or Supervisor, together with plans of the completed building.

13. Under Rule 20(3), the Secretary, on receipt of the completion report and on being satisfied that the construction has been carried out in conformity with the permit given, shall issue the occupancy certificate within fifteen days. If none is issued within that time, the owner may proceed as if it had been issued, and the resulting deemed occupancy certificate is to be accepted by all public authorities as proof of completion of the building in compliance with the Rules. Rules 20(4) and 20(5) allow an owner who wishes to occupy a building before its completion to obtain an occupancy certificate for the partially completed building, if the Secretary is satisfied that such occupancy will not endanger life.

14. The Occupancy Certificate under the Building Rules is thus a creature of local building law. It is issued by the municipal Secretary to the owner, which will show whether the building has been constructed as per the permit and plans, and whether it is fit for occupation. Nothing in the Building Rules deals with the contractual or statutory relationship between a promoter and his allottees based on the agreement entered into between them.

15. The RERA Act stands on a different footing. It does not provide for the issue of an Occupancy Certificate and creates no authority to issue one. It speaks of the occupancy certificate as a certificate issued by the competent authority permitting occupation of a building as provided under local laws [Section 2(zf)], and of the completion certificate as one certifying that the project has been developed according to the sanctioned plan, layout plan and specifications approved under local laws [Section 2(q)]. The Act then casts duties on the promoter in relation to that certificate. Under Section 11(4)(b), the promoter must obtain the completion or occupancy certificate, as applicable, from the competent authority as per local laws, and make it available to the allottees individually or to the Association.

16. Under Section 17, he must execute a registered conveyance deed, hand over possession to the allottees, and hand over the common areas, documents and plans to the Association, the latter step following the occupancy certificate. Section 18 makes him liable to pay interest for delay in giving possession, Section 14(3) makes him answerable for defects, Section 11(5) regulates the cancellation of allotments, and Section 31 permits any aggrieved person to file a complaint before the Authority for contravention of the Act or the Rules.

17. The two sets of provisions therefore operate in different fields under different legislation. The Building Rules look at the building and whether it is built as permitted, and whether it is safe to occupy. The RERA Act looks at the promoter’s conduct toward the allottees and whether he performed the obligations the statute places on him. Under the Building Rules, the Occupancy Certificate is the end product, issued by the municipal Secretary and open to challenge only by the remedies known to the law governing it. Under the RERA Act, the same certificate is only an input, a document the promoter must obtain under local law and a trigger for some of his later duties.

18. The RERA and the Tribunal are not the forum for testing its legality, but they are the forum for every obligation the Act imposes. Completion therefore carries two meanings. Under the Building Rules, it means that the building is complete as per the permit, which the Occupancy Certificate settles. Under the RERA Act, it also takes in whether the promoter has done all that the Act requires of him towards the allottees, which the certificate does not settle.

19. Taking note of the provisions of the RERA Act and of the judgments of this Court in Nidhish P.V. (supra) and Siji Jacob (supra), it is clear that the legality of an Occupancy Certificate issued under the Building Rules cannot be called into question before the authorities under the RERA Act. The certificate signifies that the construction of the building is over as per the permit issued and that the premises are fit for occupation. These two aspects cannot be gone into by the Authority or the Tribunal. If the allottees say that the certificate was wrongly issued or obtained by fraud, the remedy lies against the issuing authority and the certificate, in the manner known to law. An allegation of fraud does not enlarge the jurisdiction of the authorities under the RERA Act.

20. The respondents are right in saying that the issuance of an Occupancy Certificate is different from the discharge of the promoter’s duties under the RERA Act. That is the very distinction drawn above. The grievances that the common areas have not been registered in favour of the Association, that parking slots have not been allotted to all the allottees, that sale deeds are yet to be executed, and that interest is due for delay are matters which the RERA Act commits to its authorities. The grant of the Occupancy Certificate does not prevent the allottees from approaching them. What the authorities under RERA cannot do is to look into the correctness of the Occupancy Certificate and its implication, namely that the building is complete as per the permit and fit for occupation.

21. The local inspection by the Deputy Directors, and the consequent breach of Regulation 21(4) and Rule 36 found by the Tribunal, arose because the inspection was aimed at finding whether the project was complete. Since that enquiry is itself outside the purview of the Authority, want of notice before it cannot be a ground for reopening a finding that rests on the Occupancy Certificate. The order of the Tribunal, which permitted even an enquiry as to whether the building has been completed, is clearly wrong.

22. The substantial questions of law are answered accordingly. Question (A) is answered by holding that the breach of Regulation 21(4) can have no consequence for the finding of completion, which rests on the Occupancy Certificate. Questions (B) and (C) are answered in favour of the appellants: the Authority and the Tribunal cannot disregard the Occupancy Certificate, and the Tribunal could not depart from Nidhish P.V. and Siji Jacob. Question

(D) is answered by holding that a procedural defect alone does not justify reopening that finding, though adjudication of all other questions under the RERA Act may proceed.

Given the above, the order of the Tribunal requires modification. It is declared that the authorities under the RERA Act shall not enquire into the legality of the Occupancy Certificate dated 10.05.2023 or into whether the building is complete as per the permit and fit for occupation. Subject to that, the Authority shall proceed with the complaints and adjudicate all the other questions arising under the RERA Act. The Authority will endeavour to finally dispose of the matter within the timeline indicated by this Court in the judgment in MSA No.40 of 2026 and connected cases, dated 11.09.2026. The appeals are disposed of accordingly. All the pending interlocutory applications will stand closed.

Printed from lawlibrary.online · https://lawlibrary.online/judgment/m-s-hoysala-projects-pvt-ltd-v-sajin-paul/